Ajay Amitabh Suman

Ajay Amitabh Suman

Member since: January 10, 2019
Total live articles: 217

Myself Ajay Amitabh Suman, An Advocate Practicing Hon'ble High Court of Delhi, having specialization in Intellectual Property Right for more than 20 years. Besides practicing in Hon'ble High Court of Delhi, I am also a Poet, Author, Blogger, Vlogger and Writer.

Recent Articles by Ajay Amitabh Suman

Non-Impleadment of Legal Heirs of Deceased Partner in Partnership Firm

Titile

In a recent legal case, the question arose as to whether the legal heirs of a deceased partner of a partnership firm should be impleaded in a trademark cancellation proceeding. The trademark in...

Dark Patterns and Personality Rights: An Analytical Legal Perspective

Titile

In a rapidly evolving digital landscape, the intersection of technology and law has given rise to complex legal issues surrounding the protection of an individual's personality rights. The case...

Refusal of Injunction in a Patent Infringement Case Based on the Balance of C...

Titile

The case at hand revolves around the refusal of an injunction in a patent infringement lawsuit, with the court favoring the defendant based on the principle of the "balance of convenience....

Trademark User Claimed By A Party Prior To What Has Been Claimed In Trademark...

Titile

The issue of whether a party can claim use of a trademark prior to what has been declared in a trademark application is a matter of significance in trademark law. This article delves into a not...

The Maximum Time Limit for Filing Replication in Delhi High Court

Titile

In civil litigation, the replication plays a significant role in responding to the defendant's written statement. In the Delhi High Court, the time limit for filing a replication is governed by...

Testimony of a Deceased Witness and its evidentiary value

Titile

In the realm of legal proceedings, a crucial question often arises when a witness who has been examined-in-chief passes away before the completion of their cross-examination. This scenario pose...

Bad Faith and Trademark Rectification

Titile

Trademark law places a significant onus on trademark registrants to act in good faith when seeking registration and using their marks. In this article, we delve into the case of ROCKPAPA, a bra...

Patent Eligibility for Computer-Related Inventions

Titile

This article discusses the evolving standards for patent eligibility in the context of computer-related inventions, with a focus on the requirement of "novel hardware." It examines a ...

No prior leave under Section 124 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 is must in Rec...

Titile

Factual Background The case under consideration involves a dispute between a Plaintiff and a Defendant over trademark issues. The Defendant raised an objection to the maintainability of the pr...

The Impact of Acquiescence in an action for Copyright Infringement

Titile

The case at hand revolves around a copyright infringement dispute between the Plaintiff/Appellant [referred to as the Plaintiff] and the Defendant/Respondent [referred to as the Defendant], bot...

Discerning Consumer and Probability of Confusion in Trademark Use

Titile

Trademark disputes often hinge on the crucial question of whether the marks in question are likely to cause confusion among consumers. This article delves into a recent case involving two educa...

Ex Parte Injunction: Requirement of detailed discussion of Prima Facie Case, ...

Titile

The matter at hand involves an appeal filed against the grant of an ex parte injunction in a trademark dispute. The key issues discussed in this article revolve around the necessity of detailed...

Doctrine of Extended Passing Off in Relation to Expired Patent

Titile

The intersection of intellectual property rights, pharmaceuticals, and competition in the Indian legal landscape has been a subject of significant litigation and jurisprudential development. On...

Examining The Validity Of Registered Trademarks In Indian Courts: Section 57(...

Titile

The case at hand revolves around the dispute between the plaintiff, who holds a registered trademark for "POSTMAN" in relation to edible groundnut oil, and the defendant, who sought a...

The Evidentiary Value of Wikipedia Articles in a Legal Proceeding

Titile

In recent years, the use of Wikipedia as a source of information in legal proceedings has become a subject of debate and contention. This article aims to analyse the evidentiary value of Wikipe...

The Relevant Date For Trademark Infringement And Passing Off Is The Date When...

Titile

In the realm of intellectual property law, the determination of the relevant date for proving trademark infringement and passing off claims holds paramount importance. The recent case of Appolo...

Evaluating Territorial Jurisdiction: The Significance of Plaint Content

Titile

This article delves into the intricacies of evaluating territorial jurisdiction, with a specific focus on the importance of the content of the plaint (the legal document that initiates a lawsui...

Rectification of a Registered Trademark due to Non-Renewal

Titile

The case at hand revolves around the rectification of a registered trademark based on the non-renewal of the said trademark within the specified time frame. The petitioner asserted that the su...

Service Through the Learned Local Commissioner and Its Implications on Order ...

Titile

The matter at hand revolves around the interpretation and application of Order VIII Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), specifically in relation to the service of summons through a le...

Requirement of Plea of invalidity for applicability of Section of the Trade M...

Titile

Section 124(1)(ii), allows a defendant to seek an adjournment of proceedings to file a rectification petition for the cancellation of a registered trademark. This article delves into a specific...

Analyzing the Refusal of an Injunction in case of PRINCETON Educational Insti...

Titile

Trademark disputes can be intricate legal battles, often hinging on various factors such as the history of trademark usage, the likelihood of confusion, and the balance of convenience. In the c...

Use Of Trademarks As Keywords In Online Advertising

Titile

In recent years, the intersection of intellectual property rights and the digital landscape has given rise to complex legal issues. One such issue is the use of trademarks as keywords in online...

Copyright Infringement: The Test of Substantial reproduction :The Case of Gul...

Titile

In the realm of intellectual property law, copyright plays a pivotal role in protecting the creative works of individuals and entities. This article delves into a legal analysis of a copyright ...

Jurisdictional Reach of Trade Marks Act, 1999: Analyzing Section 47, Section ...

Titile

The jurisdictional boundaries of legal proceedings under the Trade Marks Act, 1999 in India have been a subject of legal debate. In a recent judgment, the court held that applications under Sec...

The Applicability of Section 100A of the Code of Civil Procedure in Appeals f...

Titile

In the realm of trademark law in India, the Registrar of Trade Marks plays a pivotal role in administering and regulating trademark registration. Disputes often arise in the course of trademark...

Importance of Proper Service of Notice in Trademark Opposition Proceedings

Titile

This article delves into the legal intricacies surrounding the service of notice in trademark opposition proceedings, focusing on the case where the mere dispatch receipt of an email was deemed...

Legal Issues Arising from Relying on the Contents of a Notice of Opposition i...

Titile

The case at hand delves into a significant legal issue that emerged during a trademark opposition proceeding. In response to the counter statement of the applicant, the opponent opted not to fi...

Intellectual Property Rights in Bar Codes

Titile

This analytical legal article delves into the landmark judgment of the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi, recognizing and upholding the intellectual property rights associated with bar codes. The cas...

Non-Enforceability of Individual Elements in Composite registered Trademarks

Titile

The issue of whether individual elements of a composite registered trademark can be enforced individually has been a topic of legal debate and significance. This article delves into a recent ca...

Non-Usage Of A Patent In India As A Ground For Declining Injunction

Titile

This legal article examines the intricate legal nuances surrounding the refusal of an injunction in a patent infringement case due to non-use of the patent in India. It delves into the case of ...

Descriptive Trademarks and the Significance of Secondary Meaning in Trademark...

Titile

One category of trademarks, known as "descriptive trademarks," often faces challenges in registration due to their inherent nature. However, the concept of secondary meaning has emerg...

Passing off Action Succeeded Despite Failed Infringement Claim

Titile

Intellectual property disputes often revolve around the protection of trademarks, especially when two entities claim ownership of similar or identical marks. The case at hand involves a passing...

Infringement made out, but injunction declined on the ground of prima facie ...

Titile

This detailed analytical legal article examines a trademark dispute involving the plaintiff's registered trademark "PANTOCID" and the defendant's trademark "PANTOPACID." Bot...

In order to qualify as design, the Article must have independent existence

Titile

This analytical legal article delves into a hypothetical case involving a dispute over the design protection of a front fender. The plaintiff claimed registered design infringement, asserting t...

Claiming incorrect claim of user does not necessarily results into cancellati...

Titile

The present case revolves around a dispute over the registration of the DHARIWALWOOLTEX device mark. The appellant asserts that they have been using this mark since 1 January 1984 and have prov...

Trademark Infringement and Unfair Competition in the Case of RAZO vs. RAZOFAST

Titile

The case of RAZO vs. RAZOFAST involves allegations of trademark infringement and unfair competition arising from the defendant's use of the mark "RAZOFAST," which closely resembles th...

Examination and Disclosure Requirements for Designation of Well-Known Marks u...

Titile

The concept of a "well-known mark" holds significant importance in the realm of trademark law, representing marks that have acquired substantial recognition and reputation among the p...

Prior User Of A Trade Mark Versus Registered Proprietor Of A Trademark

Titile

The Impugned Order: The impugned order dated 10 10.2022 in question appears to have been solely based on the registered trademark favoring the plaintiff-respondents. Lack of Discussion on Pri...

Use of Plaintiff's Trademark Mark as Part of Defendant's Trade Name

Titile

Trademark infringement cases often involve intricate legal arguments that revolve around the nature and use of marks. One such argument arises when a defendant contends that their use of a mark...

Admissibility of Documents in Post Grant Opposition Proceedings under Patent Law

Titile

One key aspect of Post grant Patent opposition proceedings is the submission of relevant documents and evidence by both the opponent and the patentee. This article delves into the intricacies o...

Removal of a Registered Trademark on Grounds of Non-Use

Titile

The removal of a registered trademark on the grounds of non-use is a crucial aspect of trademark law that ensures trademarks are actively used in commerce to maintain their exclusivity. Thi...

Maintainability of Suit for Infringement of Design by Unregistered Licensee

Titile

The subject matter under scrutiny pertains to a legal dispute involving the maintainability of a suit for infringement of design filed by Plaintiff No.1 and Plaintiff No.2 jointly. Plaintif...

The Interplay of Socio-Economic Status and Caste Identity: A Multi-Faceted An...

Titile

The aphorism "It is better to give a poor certificate than to give a caste certificate" encapsulates a complex intersection of socio-economic status and caste identity that is prevale...

What Defendant Is Required To Prove In Order To Take Advantage Of Section 34 ...

Titile

The case at hand involves a dispute between the Plaintiff and the Defendant over the alleged infringement of the Plaintiff's registered trademark "HTA" for oil seals and automobile ru...

Defendant's Burden of Proof under Section 34 of the Trademarks Act 1999

Titile

The case at hand involves a dispute between the Plaintiff and the Defendant over the alleged infringement of the Plaintiff's registered trademark "HTA" for oil seals and automobile ru...

The Role of Judges in Shaping Public Policy in India

Titile

The Constitution of India stands as the bedrock of the nation's legal and political framework, enshrining the principles of justice, equality, and democratic governance. Central to this framewo...

Proposed Amendments to IPC, CRPC, and Evidence Act 2023: A Legal Perspective

Titile

The Bills proposing amendments to the Indian Penal Code (IPC), Code of Criminal Procedure (CRPC), and the Evidence Act encompass a myriad of salient features that aim to address various shortco...

Google Ad Programme and Trademark Infringement

Titile

The case at hand involves a legal dispute between Agarwal Packers And Movers and Google with regard to the use of trademarks as keywords in the Google Ads Programme. The Plaintiff alleges th...

Reassessing The Role Of Training For Politicians: Implications For Democracy ...

Titile

The world of politics is a unique arena where power, decisions, and governance converge. Unlike most other professions, the role of a politician often lacks the stringent training and preparati...

Analyzing The Necessity Of Prima Facie Case Balance Of Convenience And Damage...

Titile

The legal landscape surrounding interim applications for injunctions is a complex and multifaceted arena that requires a careful consideration of various factors. In the case at hand, where an ...

Difference between Non-Disclosure of Cause of Action and Defective Cause of A...

Titile

This analytical legal article discusses the distinction between non-disclosure of cause of action and defective cause of action in the context of a trademark infringement case. The case in ques...

Maintainability of Letters Patent Appeal against Judgment passed by High Cour...

Titile

The issue of maintainability of Letters Patent Appeal (LPA) against a judgment passed by the High Court in a Trademark Rectification Petition has been a matter of contention. This article analy...

The Effect of Disclaimers on Subsequently Associated Registered Trademarks

Titile

This article analyzes a recent judgment before the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi, which addressed the effect of disclaimers attached to an earlier registered trademark on subsequently associated ...

Revocation Petition for Patent: Suit or Not within Section 10 CPC?

Titile

The matter at hand revolves around the question of whether a revocation petition for a patent can be treated as a suit within the meaning of Section 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC). ...

The Lack of Person Law in strike a balance between religious practices and e...

Titile

The freedom to practice one's faith is a fundamental human right, and it should be respected and protected. However, there is an ongoing concern regarding the excessive noise pollution caused b...

Use of House Mark as Prefix and Trademark Infringement

Titile

This article discusses a legal case involving the use of a house mark as a prefix with another trademark and its potential implications for trademark infringement. The case revolves around ...

Intention to Use an Expression as a Descriptor is Immaterial if it Actually R...

Titile

In this legal article, we delve into a case where the plaintiff claimed to be the registered proprietor of the marks "MADHUR" and "MADHUR MADHUR GULAB" written in devanagari...

The Static and Dynamic Effect of Patent and Territorial Jurisdiction of High ...

Titile

This analytical legal article explores the territorial jurisdiction of High Courts concerning patent revocation and patent appeals after the abolition of the IPAB (Intellectual Property Appella...

The Promise of a lawyer: A Journey of Compassion and Commitment

Titile

In the chambers of the High Court, a fateful encounter took place that would forever change the life of one man. Today, among the sea of lawyers and dignitaries, a familiar face caught the eye ...

Transfer of Patent Cancellation Petition by one High Court to another High Court

Titile

Abstract: This article examines the issue of transferring patent cancellation petitions between different High Courts in India. It analyses a specific case where the respondent no.2 sought the...

Identity-Based Prejudice in the Legal Profession

Titile

In today's diverse and interconnected world, it is essential for society to promote inclusivity and understanding among different cultural and religious groups. Unfortunately, prejudices based ...

Impact on Stay of Suit under Section 124 of Trademarks Act 1999 in view of ab...

Titile

This article examines the implications of the abolition of the Intellectual Property Appellate Board (IPAB) and the subsequent vesting of powers to entertain cancellation petitions with the Hig...

Quia Timet Action: Implications on Jurisdiction and Interim Injunction

Titile

The jurisdictional aspect in trademark infringement lawsuits plays a crucial role in determining whether a court has the authority to entertain a case and decide on its merits. Additionally, th...

Evaluating Inventive Step in Patent Applications

Titile

This article analyzes the criteria required to be taken into consideration by the Controller of Patent while assessing the patentability of a patent application concerning inventive step. It...

Consolidation of various Trademark Proceedings pending before various forum b...

Titile

This article analyzes the power and discretion of the High Court of Delhi to consolidate suit proceedings pending before the District Court, Delhi, cancellation proceedings pending before the R...

The Impact of Expiry of Design in a Design Infringement Suit

Titile

This legal article delves into a crucial aspect of design infringement cases where the plaintiff's registered design has expired. The focal point is a specific case where the plaintiff's design...

Consolidation of various Trademark Proceedings pending before various forums ...

Titile

This article analyzes the power and discretion of the High Court of Delhi to consolidate suit proceedings pending before the District Court, Delhi, cancellation proceedings pending before the R...

Fate of non reasoned Order Passed by the Controller of Patents: The Scope of ...

Titile

This analytical legal article delves into the fate of an order passed by the Controller of Patents, which was challenged in the High Court of Delhi through an appeal filed under Section 117A of...

Analyzing Product-by-Process Claims in a Suit for Patent Infringement

Titile

This legal article delves into the dispute brought before the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in a patent infringement suit, where the primary issue revolves around the scope of the plaintiff's rig...

Entitlement of Ordinary Dictionary word to be declared as well known Trademark

Titile

This article discusses a recent judgment by the Delhi High Court, which dealt with the issue of whether an ordinary dictionary word can be declared a well-known trademark. The Court's decision ...

Patent Infringement Dispute: Unraveling the Contention Surrounding Essential ...

Titile

The case at hand centers around a patent infringement dispute where the Plaintiff accuses the Defendant of utilizing their patented technology without authorization. The Plaintiff's patent comp...

Appealability Of WIPO Administrative Panel Orders Under Section 91 Of The Tra...

Titile

This legal article explores the issue of whether orders passed by the administrative Panel of the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) are appealable under Section 91 of the Trade Ma...

Analyzing the Jurisdictional Overlap: Competition Act v/s Patents Act in Pate...

Titile

This legal article delves into the critical question of whether the Competition Commission of India (CCI) can inquire into the actions of a patentee who asserts their patent rights in India. Th...

Documentary Evidences Required to Prove a Trademark as a Well-Known Trademark

Titile

This article examines the documentary evidence required to establish a trademark as a well-known trademark under the Trade Marks Act, 1999. The article delves into the relevant criteria outline...

Analyzing the Jurisdictional Overlap: Competition Act Vs Patents Act in Paten...

Titile

This legal article delves into the critical question of whether the Competition Commission of India (CCI) can inquire into the actions of a patentee who asserts their patent rights in India. Th...

In Passing Off Action, The Relevant Date Of Proving Goodwill Is When The Defe...

Titile

A critical element in a passing off claim is the establishment of goodwill and reputation in the relevant market. This article examines a notable case in which the Hon'ble Court refused to gran...

Prior User Of Trademark In India v/s Prior Adopter Of Trademark In World

Titile

In a recent legal battle over trademark rights, both VIP and Carlton filed suits against each other claiming to be the registered proprietor of the trademark "CARLTON". The issue befo...

Plaintiff Is Not Required To Lead Evidence In Ex-Parte Matters

Titile

In the fast-paced digital age, the internet has provided countless opportunities for individuals and businesses to connect and share information globally. Unfortunately, this unrestricted acces...

The Presumed Knowledge Of The Ex-Dealer Or Distributor Regarding Owner's Trad...

Titile

When relation ship of distributor or dealer is terminated with a trademark owner, question may arise regarding the use of that trademark or any other trademark deceptively similar thereto ,by t...

Section 6 Of Commercial Court Act 2015, Not In Negation Section 62 Of Copyrig...

Titile

At first glance, some may assume that the Explanation to Section 6 of the Commercial Court Act 2015 and Section 62 of the Copyright Act 1957 are in conflict. However, upon closer examination...

Classification Of Goods Is Not Decisive For Evaluating Trademark Confusion

Titile

In the realm of trademark law, disputes often arise when two parties claim ownership or exclusive rights over similar trademarks for different classes of products. This article analyses a recen...

New Variety Versus Extant Variety within the provision of The Plant Varieties...

Titile

The Plant Varieties and Farmers' Rights Act 2001 is a significant legislation enacted by the Indian Parliament to address the rights and interests of both farmers and breeders. This act aims...

The Locus of Foreign entity to Invoke Writ Jurisdiction in India

Titile

Article 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India grant the power of writ jurisdiction to the High Courts in the country. This power allows the courts to issue writs for the enforcement of funda...

The Requirement Of Affidavit In Support Of Documents Before Registrar Of Tra...

Titile

In the realm of intellectual property rights, trademarks play a vital role in protecting the distinct identity and reputation of businesses. The process of establishing a trademark as "wel...

No Exclusive Right Over Generic and Non Distinctive Word

Titile

The Intellectual Property Rights are subject to certain limitations to these rights, particularly when it comes to generic and non-distinctive words. This article will delve into one Judgment d...

Bar To Take On Record Additional Document Is Not Absolute In Commercial Suits

Titile

In a recent landmark judgment reported as 2021 SCC Online SC 734 Sudhir Kumar Vs Vinay Kumar GB, the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India addressed the issue of taking additional documents on record....

No Copyright In Idea Or Story Line, Except Tangible Expression Thereof

Titile

The Subject Matter Suit: The Subject Matter Suit was filed by the Plaintiff against the Defendant on the ground inter alia that that the the plaintiff is the author and first owner of the copy...

Terms Of Family Settlement Has To Be Honored

Titile

The history of Rathi Family 1942: Parent Company , Rathi Steel Rolling Mills [G.D.Rathi, K.L.Rathi and H.K.Rathi]. 1969: Divided into G.D.Rathi Steels Ltd. [family members of G.D.Rathi] and ...

Remedy against Non Appealable Order in Commercial Court Act 2015

Titile

The Subject Matter Petition: The Subject Matter CM Main under Article 227 of Constitution of India was filed against Order dated 25.09.2021 passed by Ld. ADJ, South District , Saket Courts, Ne...

If Functional Feature Of Design Can Be Achieved Through Different Form Of Art...

Titile

The Subject Matter Suit: The Subject Matter Suit for Infringement of Design was filed by the Petitioner on the basis of their registered Design titled as Sonic Nozzle , which they have registe...

Biological Male, Is It Merely A Notion?

Titile

The statement that "the biological male is a biological male, biological female is a biological female" is a statement of fact, not a question of notion. It is not a human construct, ...

Patentability Of Antina Having Asymetric Beam Pattern

Titile

The Suit Patent has been a topic of controversy in the technology world for some time now. It is a patent that describes a configuration for enhancing subscriber capacity in a cellular wireless...

What Is Use Of That Decision, Which Comes After Inordinate Delay?

Titile

The concept of justice is an integral aspect of any society, and it is the fundamental responsibility of the judicial system to provide justice to the victims of crimes. However, the Indian ...

The Right Of Same Sex Couples To Adopt A Child

Titile

The right of same-sex couples to adopt a child is a subject of fierce debates globally. Some countries fully recognize the rights of same-sex couples to adopt a child, while others are still co...

Pith and Marrow Doctrine and Infringement of Patent

Titile

As patent law continues to evolve, so does the doctrine of pith and marrow in patent infringement cases. This doctrine is an important concept that addresses the issue of a patent claim's core,...

Disclosure And Coverage In A Selection Patent

Titile

The grant of interim injunction in a lawsuit pertaining to the infringement of patent is always a complex matter. There are various factors that the court has to consider while granting interim...

The Legal Age For Committing Illegality

Titile

The consumption of substances such as tobacco, alcohol, and gambling has long been a part of human culture. However, it is no secret that these habits can lead to negative health and social con...

Is Opinion Of Patent Board In Post Grant Opposition Proceeding Is Subject To ...

Titile

This factum can not be disputed that order of sub ordinate authority , court or tribunal can be challenged to the High Court in India through a writ petition filed under Article 226 of the Indi...

Injustice in Justice delivery System: The Uncle Sam Syndrome

Titile

The judicial system is the bedrock of any democracy. It is the system that ensures that everyone, irrespective of their social status, is treated fairly and justly. The judiciary is the guardia...

The Use Of Family Of Trademark Does Not Amount To Be Use Of Registered House...

Titile

What could be effect of in case a party is not using the registered trade mark and instead of this the same has been using family of trademarks with suffix or prefixes? Let us first of all ...

Copyright Filing
Online Copyright Registration


Popular Articles by Ajay Amitabh Suman

Guidelines For Implementation of Section...

Titile

Section 209 of IPC has remained unchartered territory in matters pertaining to Intellec...

Additional Documents At The Trial Stage

Titile

This case relates to intellectual property right, more especially trademark right. The judgm...

Producing Additional Document At The Sta...

Titile

The Criminal Method Code of 1973 is the main code governing the procedure followed by Indian co...

Filing of additional Documents in Commer...

Titile

Prior to enactment of Commercial Court Act 2015, normally Plaintiff or Defendant could file the...

Lawyers Registration
Lawyers Membership - Get Clients Online


File caveat In Supreme Court Instantly