Why Was Gandharva Vivah Considered As An Unapproved Form Of Marriage In Ancient Times?
Gandharva Vivah, also known as Gandharva Marriage, is a type of marriage in
Hinduism that is based on mutual love and attraction between the bride and
groom. It is believed to be one of the oldest forms of marriage in India and has
been mentioned in various ancient Hindu texts such as the Rigveda, Mahabharata,
and Manusmriti.
In a Gandharva Vivah, the bride and groom choose each other as partners and get
married without the consent of their parents or any formal ceremony. The
marriage is considered valid as long as the couple is in love and committed to
each other. It is believed that this type of marriage was prevalent in ancient
times among the Gandharva community, who were known for their musical talents
and love for music.
Introduction;
The term "Gandharva" is derived from the Sanskrit word Gandharva." which means a
celestial musician. According to Hindu mythology, the Gandharva were celestial
musicians and singers who lived in the heavens and entertained the gods and
goddesses with their music. They were also known for their love for music and
were believed to have the power to create and control the emotions of people
through their music.
Argument;
The concept of Gandharva Vivah is based on the idea of love and attraction
between two individuals. It is believed that love is a powerful force that can
bring two people together and create a strong bond between them. In a Gandharva
Vivah, the bride and The bride and groom are believed to have a deep and genuine
love for each other, which is why they choose to get married without the
approval of their families or society.
The concept of Gandharva Vivah is also associated with the idea of freedom and
individual choice. It is believed that in ancient times, individuals had the
freedom to choose their life partners based on their own preferences and
criteria. This idea of freedom of choice is reflected in the Gandharva Vivah
where the bride and groom choose each other without any external pressure or
influence.
However, it is important to note that the concept of Gandharva Vivah is not
without its criticisms and controversies. Some argue that this type of marriage
promotes individualism and goes against the traditional values of Hinduism which
emphasizes the importance of family and community. Others argue that it can lead
to social and cultural conflicts as it goes against the norms and values of
society.
Despite the criticisms, Gandharva Vivah remains a popular concept in Hinduism,
especially among those who believe in the power of love and the importance of
individual choice. In modern times, the concept of Gandharva Vivah has evolved
to include elements of traditional Hindu marriage ceremonies such as exchange of
vows and blessings from family and friends.
It is also worth noting that Gandharva Vivah is not the only type of marriage
mentioned in Hinduism. There are several other types of marriages such as Brahma
Vivah (where the bride's family chooses the groom), Daiva Vivah (where the
marriage is arranged by the gods), and Asura Vivah (where the groom pays a bride
price to the bride's family).
In conclusion, Gandharva Vivah is a unique and ancient concept in Hinduism that
is based on the idea of mutual love and attraction between the bride and groom.
While it has its criticisms and controversies, it remains a popular concept
among those who value the importance of individual choice and freedom. Its
relevance and significance continue to be debated and discussed in modern times,
but its impact on the culture and traditions of Hinduism cannot be denied.
In ancient times, Gandharva Vivah was considered an unapproved form of marriage
because it did not involve the consent of the parents or guardians of the bride
and groom. Gandharva Vivah was a type of marriage where the couple married each
other without the knowledge or consent of their families. This type of marriage
was typically conducted in secret and was considered to be a form of elopement.
In ancient Hindu society, arranged marriages were the norm, and the parents or
guardians of the bride and groom played a significant role in the selection of
their partners. The consent of both parties' families was considered essential
for a marriage to be considered valid. Gandharva Vivah, however, did not involve
the participation of the families and was therefore viewed as an improper and
unacceptable form of marriage.
In the ancient Hindu texts, such as the Manu Smriti and the Mahabharata,
Gandharva Vivah is described as a form of marriage that is inferior to the
traditional arranged marriage. The Manu smriti, in particular, states that a
Gandharva Vivah is not a valid form of marriage and should be avoided.
Overall, Gandharva Vivah was considered an unapproved form of marriage in
ancient times because it went against the traditional customs and expectations
of Hindu society, which emphasized the importance of parental consent and family
involvement in the marriage process.
Yes, that's correct. In ancient Hindu texts, including the Manusmriti and the
Mahabharata, Gandharva Vivah was viewed as an inferior form of marriage, as it
did not follow the traditional customs and expectations of Hindu society.
According to Hindu tradition, arranged marriages were considered the most ideal
and socially acceptable form of marriage. These marriages were typically
arranged by the parents or other family members of the bride and groom, and were
seen as a way to ensure compatibility between the two individuals, as well as to
strengthen family ties and alliances
On the other hand, Gandharva Vivah was seen as a marriage that was entered into
solely by the bride and groom, without the consent or involvement of their
families. This form of marriage was considered to be based purely on love and
attraction, rather than on practical considerations such as family connections
or social status.
As a result, Gandharva Vivah was not considered a valid form of marriage
according to the Manu smriti, which stated that only marriages that were entered
into with the consent of the parents and other family members were considered
legitimate. Despite this, however, Gandharva Vivah continued to be practiced in
ancient Hindu society, albeit in a somewhat secretive manner.
While the laws and regulations surrounding Gandharva Vivah have undergone
significant changes from ancient times to modern times, it can be argued that
these changes have been mostly positive and have improved the status and
recognition of this form of marriage.
In ancient times, Gandharva Vivah was considered a invalid form of marriage in
Hinduism, and it was recognized as a unapproved union between the bride and
groom. However, with the passage of time and the influence of various social and
religious factors, the laws and regulations surrounding Gandharva Vivah have
changed.
In modern times, Gandharva Vivah is recognized as a legal form of marriage under
the Indian legal system. Though, the laws regarding marriage have also become
more inclusive and progressive. For example, the minimum age of marriage has
been increased to 18 years for females and 21 years for males, and the consent
of both parties is required for the marriage to be considered legal.
Furthermore, the Indian legal system recognizes various forms of marriage,
including civil marriages, religious marriages, and customary marriages. While
Gandharva Vivah may not be recognized as a legal form of marriage, couples who
choose to get married in this manner can still have their union recognized
through various means such as a court affidavit or a religious ceremony.
Moreover, the Indian Constitution guarantees the right to freedom of religion
and the right to choose one's partner, and these rights have been upheld by the
judiciary in several landmark cases. In recent years, there have been several
cases where couples who have chosen to get married in the Gandharva Vivah style
have faced legal challenges and opposition from their families and society.
However, the courts have upheld their right to choose their partner and have
recognized their union as valid.
In addition, the concept of Gandharva Vivah has been reinterpreted and redefined
in modern times to be more inclusive and accepting. It has been adapted to
include same-sex marriages, thus promoting inclusivity and acceptance in the
Hindu community.
Overall, while Gandharva Vivah may not be recognized as a legal form of marriage
under the Indian legal system, the laws and regulations surrounding marriage
have become more inclusive and progressive in modern times. The right to choose
one's partner and the right to freedom of religion have been upheld by the
judiciary, and the concept of Gandharva Vivah has been reinterpreted to be more
inclusive and accepting. These changes have improved the status and recognition
of Gandharva Vivah and have promoted the importance of love, freedom of choice,
and individuality in the Hindu community.
One of the interesting aspects of Gandharva Vivah is that it is not restricted
by any caste, creed or religion. Anyone, regardless of their social status, can
choose to get married in this manner as long as they have mutual love and
respect for each other.
Moreover, the concept of Gandharva Vivah is not limited to just heterosexual
couples. In recent times, it has been adapted to include same-sex marriages as
well, thus promoting inclusivity and acceptance in the Hindu community.
It is also important to note that while Gandharva Vivah is based on the idea of
love and attraction, it does not mean that it is devoid of responsibility and
commitment. The couple is expected to be loyal and faithful to each other and to
work together to build a harmonious and fulfilling life.
Another interesting aspect of Gandharva Vivah is its association with music and
art. As mentioned earlier, the Gandharva were known for their musical talents
and love for music. In modern times, many couples choose to incorporate music
and art into their Gandharva Vivah ceremonies, thus adding a unique and creative
touch to their wedding.
Conclusion:
Overall, Gandharva Vivah is a fascinating and unique concept in Hinduism that
promotes the importance of love, freedom of choice, and individuality. Its
relevance and significance continue to be debated and discussed in modern times,
but its impact on the culture and traditions of Hinduism cannot be ignored.
Law Article in India
You May Like
Legal Question & Answers
Please Drop Your Comments