"
Industrial jurisprudence is the corner stone of the fabric of the entire
human race."-- Mahesh Chandra
Labour Law can be defined as employment law governing the legal rights and
liabilities on workmen and their organisations. It recognises the rights
available to working people, workmen, trade unions and employers in the
workplace and provides for their duties and relations[1]. Labour Law has been
broadly categorised as - Individual Labour Law, which is concerned with the
rights of workmen in workplace and Collective Labour Law, providing for the
relationship between employer-employee, union and its members, as well as
provisions for settlement of disputes, etc[2].
With the start of industrial revolution in the 1850s, labour rights became a
vital part for economic and social development and this gave rise to the framing
of regulatory guidelines for safeguarding and defining their rights and
relations with the employer[3]. Employment laws, cover within its ambit,
Industrial relations, for example smooth working of Trade Unions and resolving
trade disputes, workplace safety, meaning ensuring safety against accidents and
redressal mechanisms and employment standard, meaning provisions regarding
minimum wages or working hours regulation, etc. [4]
Labour statutes largely govern and regulate rights and working conditions of
blue-collar employees, whereas white-collar employees are governed by private
contracts[5]. However, labour falls under the Concurrent list[6], so both
central and state have the power to legislate on it.[7] Labour laws are of two
types, as stated earlier- individual (working condition of workmen) and
collective (employer-employee relationship)[8].
Statutes such as Factories Act, 1948 and Shops and Commercial Establishments
Acts (SEAs) focus on the working condition of employees whereas enactments like
Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 and the Industrial Employment (Standing Orders)
Act, 1945 deal with the relations between employer and employee of the
organisation. [9] Now, twenty-nine labour laws have been codified into 4 codes-
Wage Code, Social Security Code, Occupational Safety, Health and Working
Conditions Code, and the Industrial Relations Code[10].
Purpose of Labour Law:
The primary focus and concern of employment laws in 2020 and further were:
- With regard to covid-19, the execution of health and safety guidelines for
employees in workplace,
- Adoption of work from home system of working for employees,
- Adoption of digital form of filings and labour law procedures. [11]
EMERGING CHALLENGES
"The Constitution of India guarantees to all citizens the right to practice any
profession, or to carry on any occupation, trade or business, provided in
Article 19(1)(g)[12]." The Contract Act, 1872 also lays out that all contracts
that exert restraint on trade are void in nature[13]. However, certain
restrictions, in the form of restrictive covenants cannot be regarded as
restraint on trade.[14]
These restrictive covenants are to protect the business interests and need to be
clearly mentioned in the contract of employment and consented by the employees
or notified in the guidelines or rules such that the employer must have
knowledge about the restrictions[15]. This will have a deterrent effect upon the
employees and prevent them from engaging in activities that may adversely affect
the entity, such as disclosing confidential information to competing agencies.
[16]
- Pre-employment Considerations
When a foreign employer enters the Indian market, there are a number of
aspects that need to be predetermined before they have a place of business
in India. For such purpose, they will require an agent or a local entity in
India to facilitate all arrangements[17]. It is not mandatory for the
foreign employer to set up a local entity immediately and start generating
revenue in India, they may hire/engage agents or representatives to meet
their business requirements[18]. The employer can employ an agent or
representative either through a manpower agency or employing them as an
independent contractor.
In such a case of staffing through a manpower agency, it would be pertinent
on the agency to fulfil few conditions- i. processing the salaries of
identified employees under them, ii. Satisfaction of all legal compliances
upon the employees owing to being their employer[19]. In case of recruitment
of a single representative or agent, the relation of such agent with the
employer will be of a 'contract of services.' The hired individual will
exercise in the capacity of independent contractor wherein they exercise
their own knowledge, skills and discretion rather than being subject to
guidelines and directions from the employer. [20]
This arrangement poses a challenge to the employer as well as the individual
or entity hired such that the employer would have to ensure that all the
preconditions are met before establishing work in India and could be
referred as a hindrance in setting up business here.
While for the employee, this arrangement could be termed risky because no
matter what method of hiring was taken up by the foreign employer, the
employee will be uncertain about the termination of their employment after
the employer permanently establishes workplace in India as whether their
work will be needed further or not, will be decided by the employer.
Â
- Restrictions on Selection Process
The Constitution of India, which is the supreme law of land, protects its
citizens from discrimination against race, religion, caste, sex, etc.,[21]
and hence it is essential that the employer(s) keep these in mind during the
selection process. However, needless to say, such factors still cause
hindrance in the selection process.
Transparency, is referred to as one of the largest goals and objectives but
also the biggest challenge to the employment sector. Indian labour and
employment laws have provisions for transparency in selection and
recruitment process, however they are mum on the topic of transparency in
the private sector, that is, disclosing why a person was rejected or
disqualified. [22]
During the background check process, as provided by the IT Rules, sensitive
data, termed Sensitive Personal Data or Information (SPDI), can only be
collected from the employees when it is notified and consented upon, and
such collection must be necessary to achieve the lawful purpose of a
function of the company[23].
Internet, being the biggest revolution of the 2000's, has made it even more
imperative to ensure safeguarding of personal data of the employees, for
example, bank details, passwords, medical records, sexual orientation,
etc[24]. It is no question that in case of withdrawal of consent by any
candidate, all SPDIs collected in regard to such person, must be duly
returned back[25].
Such information poses great threat to the employer such that it must be
handled so the information doesn't get leaked or lost or destroyed and
reasonable care must be taken. Most companies, conduct a basic background
check on the prospective employees adhering to the IT Rules. It has to be
kept in mind that collection, disclosure, or usage of any sensitive
information during background checks must also be consented[26].
Â
- Employment Contracts
With a prevalent market-practice of written contracts specifying all the
requirements and conditions of the employment, it has become a mandate for
almost all entities to have written employment contracts consented and
signed by the employees[27]. The written contracts are governed by the
Contract Act, so all ingredients required to constitute a valid contract
would also be applicable to employment contracts, such as competent parties,
consideration, etc[28].
Employment contracts can be of two types- fixed term contracts and unlimited
term or permanent contracts[29]. Earlier, it was established that successive
fixed term employment contracts cannot be turned into permanent contracts
but with new norms, fixed term employees can now avail the benefits of
permanent employees, such as gratuity before completing five years of
service. [30]
The current trend within companies is of hiring employees on a Trial or
Probation period basis to check if they are suitable for the organisation
and to assess their skills and capabilities. But this arrangement offers
huge discretionary freedom to the employers to terminate employees during
this period, as provided in the Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Act,
1945[31].
The probation period undertaken by companies generally is of three to six
months and during this, the employers are given the power to terminate
without a prior notice.[32] That there is, an obligation upon the employer
under The Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 to provide a 21-day prior notice to
the workman before making any unilateral changes in their service or working
conditions[33].
But there is no statutory obligation upon the employer to give a prior
notice to white-collar employees, that is, non-workers for any amendment in
their employment contracts.[34] Further, a workman with at least one year of
continuous service are authorized to a notice period of one month in
inclusion of retrenchment compensation, whereas a workman who has been
dismissed for misconduct, etc. is not entitled to any such notice or
retrenchment compensation[35].
However, the employees, irrespective of their probationer status should also
analyse the provisions of the Shops and Commercial Establishments Acts (SEAs)
regarding notice period to avoid any confusion.
There is no provision in the employment laws to present and publish all
contractual documents and statutory guidelines in the regional language or
in the dialect of the employee.[36] However, there is an obligation to
attain consent from the employee over these matters so it is advisable to
the employees to make sure the employees understand each and every
provision.
Â
- Working Conditions
One of the biggest questions of ambiguity that arises in employment law is
in the definition of wages. Wages has been defined in "Section 2(s) of the
Payment of Wages Act, 1936 as all emoluments which are earned by an employee
while on duty or on leave in accordance with the terms and conditions of his
employments and which are paid or are payable to him in cash and includes
dearness allowance but does not include any bonus, commission, house rent
allowance, overtime wages and any other allowance[37]," whereas in "Section
2(b) of Employees' Provident Funds and Miscellaneous provisions Act, 1952,
basic wages has been defined as all emoluments which are earned by an
employee while on duty or 4[on leave or on holidays with wages in either
case] in accordance with the terms of the contract of employment and which
are paid or payable in cash to him, but does not include:
(i) the cash value of any food concession;
(ii) any dearness allowance (that is to say, all cash payments by whatever
name called paid to an employee on account of a rise in the cost of living),
house-rent allowance, overtime allowance, bonus commission or any other
similar allowance payable to the employee in respect of his employment or of
work done in such employment;
(iii) any presents made by the employer;[38]"
In both these definitions, an ambiguity in regard to dearness allowance
arises and it is unclear whether dearness allowance is included in wages or
not and what is the difference between wages and basic wages and their
applicability. In order to remove the repugnancy, the meaning of both these
terms must be construed in a way that all ambiguities related to these terms
are removed and their meanings and application is clear.
Limitation has been imposed on the employers with regard to maximum working
hours of employees. As a general rule, an employee can work for nine hours
on the maximum every day [39]and 48 hours maximum weekly[40]. Beyond these
limitations, the employees are entitled to overtime payment[41]. But most
companies do not abide by this rule and make employees work overtime. By
using the shield of consented contracts, companies avoid overtime payments
to such employees.
Also, it is the employer's duty to ensure a safe and healthy workspace
environment[42], and it is especially applicable in manufacturing sector,
where big machineries and construction apparatus make it accident prone.
They are also required to make some provisions regarding safety of women
working night shifts, for example, by providing safe and free transport
services.[43] The Factories Act, 1948 and State specific rules provide
guidelines to ensure safe and healthy workplace to the employees.
They include provisions with respect to proper lighting and ventilation,
clean drinking water and toilets, system to prevent injuries by preventing
overcrowding, providing proper tools and gears to ensure safety etc[44].
There are also provisions which make non-compliance with the Factories Act,
1948 guidelines a punishable offence, awarding penalty as well as
punishment. [45]But with the pandemic, there have been new challenges
attacking the safety of the workplace through masking. In an online
platform, it is easy to hide identity and attack someone so there needs to
be new guidelines drafted to ensure safety of employees even in the work
from home scenario.
In the private sector, however, there is lack of extensive provisions with
respect to safety of employee complainants and whistle-blowers to protect
them by keeping them anonymous and providing sufficient security[46]. The
'Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and
Redressal) Act, 2013 provides for protection of complainant from retaliation
at the workplace during the trial or inquiry of the accused'[47].
Moreover, the trade union must be registered as well as recognised for
certain rights such as collective bargaining, but the employer is not
obligated to recognise the union[48]. This gives power to the employer to
trample upon the demands and claims of the union by not recognising them. No
legal obligation upon employer to recognise a union. Further, the members of
the trade union have lots of work with respect to the union and sometimes,
that clashes with their work in the establishment. Therefore, members should
be given work cover during important union related work such as union
meetings, etc.
Â
- Anti-Discriminatory Laws
It is no question that India lacks a complete and comprehensive legislation
against workplace discrimination and harassment, except the Sexual
Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal)
Act, 2013.[49] There are provisions for persons with disability and HIV in
the workplace, but no such extensive and comprehensive legislation has been
implemented pertaining to all these matters.
Other major issues concerning discrimination at workplace are harassment
against sexual orientation, bullying, etc. Multiple private companies have
started providing benefits to LGBTQ+ communities such as bigger packages,
etc.[50] But there is still no statutory obligation upon the employers to
ensure prevention of harassment against LGBTQ+ community at workplace. There
is also a lack of provisions for menstruating women at workplace. Maternity
provisions have been taken up and provided under the Maternity Benefit Act,
1961 [51]but there are still no provisions regarding paternity benefits or a
comprehensive legislation with respect to parental leaves.
There is no requirement under Indian law to make policies ensuring
prevention of harassment against issues like disability, sexual orientation,
etc. mandatorily and are only upon the discretion of the employers to make
such policies. The issuing of notices and guidelines as well as employment
contracts must also be made in the local language, especially the notices
given in industrial establishments, where most of the workers are not used
to the English language and it is the responsibility of the employer to make
sure that the employees are consenting to the said contracts and rules after
having clear understanding and knowledge of the matter.
The Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and
Redressal) Act, 2013 also only includes 'aggrieved women' [52]under its
scope, while it should be a gender-neutral legislation, and broaden its
scope to other genders as well because sexual harassment at workplace is not
just limited to women. Women can approach the Internal Complaints Committee
(ICC)[53] under the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention,
Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013 and disabled persons can complain under
Rights of Person with Disabilities Act, 2016[54] but what about persons not
in both these categories? The current legislation must make changes in the
Act according to the changing times. Although companies have strict internal
policies regarding these pertinent issues, but they do not have a statutory
obligation per se.
The inquiry and redressal process for sexual harassment complaints is long
and chaotic where it is upon the Internal Complaints Committee (ICC) and not
any statutory authority to resolve these issues. The committee, although
subject to many rules to make it an inclusive and unbiased committee may be
subject to influences and threats as it is not a statutory being and this
can make the process delayed and unsatisfactory.
Â
- Social Media and Data Privacy
India is on its way in formulating a comprehensive legislation on data
protection, through PDP Bill, which will direct and restrict the employer's
entitlement to view sensitive data of the employee. [55]Data protection is
required to restrict the employer's accessibility and monitoring employee's
sensitive information, such as bank details, biometrics, passwords, etc., as
well as restrict employees' accessibility and use of confidential
information.
Currently, there are no specific laws, except the IT Act, 2000, which
imposes individual liability, governing employees' use and divulging of
confidential information of the organisation[56]. But doing so will confer
upon the employee, criminal and civil charges such as breach of contract,
defamation, etc. Remedies will be available under The Indian Contract Act,
1872, Indian Penal Code, 1860, Specific Relief Act, 1963 read with the Civil
Procedure Code, 1908 and the Information Technology Act, 2000[57].
Since there are no specific laws currently regarding this, it is advisable
to employers to include provisions regarding using and sharing of
confidential secrets and information about the establishment in the contract
of employment or letter of appointment with the employees' consent, for
protection of their information and preventing it from being spread. And
since there is complete right of the employer over information of the
establishment, the employee will be liable for leaking such information. The
employer may also be made liable vicariously through the actions of their
employees, hence, the employer should also educate the employees of the
implications of such act.
The PDP Bill, 2019 was presented in the Lok Sabha in December, 2019 and it
seeks to adjust the use of a person's information by the government as well
as private companies and establishes a Data Protection Authority for that.
The committee's report on the bill is pending and its enactment will change
the current provisions related to data protection in establishments. [58]
Background checks are very common in today's selection process but is
subject to certain limitations.[59] The criminal record of an employee, for
example, is public information but are available readily. They have to be
obtained after taking authorization. And sensitive information such as
credit or financial information comes under the ambit of SDPI, so would
require consent of the individual. Provisions related to background checks
are not provided, yet, information such as religion, caste, etc should not
be extracted by the employers.
Â
- Authorizations for foreign employees
Unless a legal entity is established, or unless they are registered in India
for an offshore company, they cannot engage employees here through third
parties and agents, except by forming 'contract of service' with the
independent contractor[60]. Further, it is an imposition upon the employer
to maintain record of its employees, like their wages, attendance, etc.[61]
Valid employment visas are required for the foreign employees who are
skilled and experts, etc. [62]
There is also a challenge as to the tenure of a foreign worker's project,
usually dependent on the validity of the employment visa, that is, up to
five years[63]. Another condition on the employment visa is that the annual
salary of the foreign worker must at least be Rs. 1,625,000 from an employer
of India. [64]Business visas are only issued for business purposes and for
foreign employees coming to work in India, employment visas are issued.
Further, the tax position of any expenses bore by an Indian entity with
regard to foreign company must also be examined along with the tax situation
of the individual in India.
Â
- Termination of Employment Contracts
In case of retrenchment, the last employee to join the entity is the first
one to be terminated as a way of collective dismissal[65]. The employers are
under the obligation to notify the employees and provide retrenchment
compensation[66], however the 'last in first out' rule (LIFO) gives the
employer huge discretionary power to terminate employees collectively for
any reason they may think fit, except as punishment of disciplinary action.
Further, in case of managerial employees, who are categorised separately to
workmen, no requirements are given for their dismissal in the statute and
would take place according to the employment contract, which is conferring
discretionary power upon the employers to make whatever terms of the
contract as they deem fit. [67]
Guidelines with respect to providing prior notice to the employees for
retrenchment and retrenchment compensation are also subject to limitation
such that if the employee is being terminated for misconduct in the
organisation, no such prior notice or retrenchment compensation is required
to be granted. [68]
At present, legislation with respect to whistleblowers are only concerned
with listed companies and the public sector companies, hence, there is a
requirement as to whistleblower laws in private companies. Whistleblowing
legislations allow listed companies to create a system where employees can
freely communicate about the illegal and unethical practices in the
entities, for example, misuse of power, corruption, etc.[69]
Therefore, to protect employees who give such essential information that can
be used to curb corruption or bring forward the illegalities committed,
legislation regarding whistleblowers need to be devised for private
companies as well.
Â
- Restrictive Covenants
Non-complete clauses, which are prevalent in most private companies, are
introduced in the employment contracts to restrict employees from engaging
in any task that may be in rivalry with the occupation of the employer[70].
They also stop the employee from associating with the rival company or
starting a competent business with them after the term of employment in the
company is over. Such clauses can be referred to as "restraint in right to
freely trade or practice profession", violating Article 19 of the
Constitution[71] but since restrictive covenants are allowed, they cannot be
challenged.
However, restrictive covenants, incorporated in the employment contracts,
that are applicable even after the employment tenure is over can be said to
be violative. As the employer is the higher authority and the terms and
conditions expressed by them will ultimately be accepted by the employee,
such consented contracts cannot then be challenged.
The rule of 'Garden leave' poses a limitation on the right to freely trade
of the employees and may also be the cause of their financial problems. This
rule allows the employer to incorporate such clauses in the contract which
can keep the employee out of the market and away from the company's
competitors so long so that no confidential information with the employee
may reach the competitors. [72]This can lead to unemployment of the employee
for a long time, leading to financial problems.
Â
- Trade Unions and Employers' Associations
The Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 and the Trade Unions Act, 1926 provide for
the formation of trade union at an industrial establishment. The registered
trade unions are conferred some rights, one of which states that "No suit or
other legal proceeding can be maintained in any civil court against any
registered trade union or any office-bearer or member in respect of any act
done in contemplation of a trade dispute to which a member is a party, on
the ground that such act induces some other person to break a contract of
employment, or that it interferes with the trade, business or employment of
some other person or interferes with the right of some other person to
dispose of his capital or labour as he wills." [73]
This right protects the trade union from any civil suit, providing them
immunity from legal charges. This can have an adverse effect on the other
party, whose right has been violated by the union.
With regard to the appointment of the redressal or works committee, there is
a provision explaining that there shall be at least one female member on the
grievance redressal committee[74]. The provision is limited to the women
members and doesn't expand its ambit to woman chairperson. It is no question
that women face challenges such as glass ceiling and glass cliff, and so,
there must be a provision for female chairperson in the committee.
Further, the concept of trade unionization is limited to the manufacturing
sector, such as in mining entities, factories, etc.[75] Since trade
unionization is limited to the manufacturing industry, provisions related to
redressal committee, etc. cannot be applied to other industries.
Â
- Employee Benefits
India doesn't own a systematic social security regime but has various
legislations governing employee benefits. Another example of the
discretionary power vested in employers is in terms of the provident fund
scheme in establishments. Employers often put a condition in the contracts
that employees earning less than INR 15,000 per month have to compulsorily
contribute in the provident fund scheme in their establishment and the
choice to opt out of this scheme is only with employees earning more than
this.[76] For employees, who are having trouble surviving in such salary
should also have a choice to opt out of contributing to the scheme.
As mentioned above, the Maternity Benefit Act, 1961 only provides for
maternity leaves and benefits and not for parental (maternity and paternity)
leaves and benefits. Paternity leave has not been recognised under Indian
law and this must change as women are not the only ones with the
responsibility to take care of the child. When the woman has to work, it
will be upon the father to take over such responsibilities and therefore,
needs paternity leave and benefits.
Further, maternity leaves are only provided to women who have been in the
establishment for more than 160 days, this leaves out the category of women
who have recently joined the establishment[77]. There also is a lack of
disability leave and it has not been recognised under Indian law.
Â
- COVID-19 Creates New Hurdles
The outbreak of the pandemic has caused major disorder and trouble in the
employment sector, with mass unemployment, lay-offs and unfamiliar work
conditions. Production came to a halt and the question of future work
conditions cannot be avoided. Along with the pandemic, new technologies and
inventions keep derailing the stability as machines take over employees in
the new era of digitalisation. Given the circumstances, reformulation of the
legislations and major amendments is required and hence, changes like
fixed-term employment, work from home policies, longer work durations, were
introduced by the government.
CONCLUSION
The prime objective with all enactments in employment law is ease of doing
business along with ensuring a better working environment for all, to accelerate
economic growth[78]. Labour law enactments are codified into four codes to
facilitate empowerment of employees in the industrial establishment.
Various challenges have emerged since the first statute related to employment
law was enacted, that is, the Trade Dispute Act, 1929, including the current
wave of uncertainties brought by the pandemic. The Codes need to implement
changes with the changing times and safeguard the rights and interests of
employees as well as employers. This will lead to a stable system of business to
benefit both.
End-Notes:
- Mrs. Archana Sawant, 'Contemporary Issues and Challenges in Labour Law Reforms: An Overview' (2015) Bharati Law Review
http://docs.manupatra.in/newsline/articles/Upload/63A37B09-15CF-4FE2-A276-CC223FD2C989.pdf accessed 17 October 2021
- Rahul Chadha, Savita Sarna, Manila Sarkaria and Natasha Sahni, 'The Employment Law Review: India' (2021) The Law Reviews
https://thelawreviews.co.uk/title/the-employment-law-review/india accessed 15 October 2021
- Bhumita Dubey, 'Industrial Revolution in India' (2020) Law Times Journal
https://lawtimesjournal.in/industrial-revolution-in-india/ accessed 16 October 2021
- ibid (n 1) 1.
- Avik Biswas, 'Employment Law Overview: India' (2019-2020) L&E Global
https://knowledge.leglobal.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/LEGlobal-Employment-Law-Overview_India_2019-2020.pdf accessed 17 October 2021
- Constitution of India, 1950 Schedule VII Concurrent List, Item 22.
- 'Issues for Consideration: Labour Codes-Three Bills on Occupational Safety and Health; Industrial Relations; and Social Security, 2020' (2020) PRS Legislative Research
https://prsindia.org/billtrack/prs-products/issues-for-consideration-labour-codes-2020-3583 accessed 16 October 2021
- ibid (n 7) 1.
- Ibid (n 5) 1.
- Government of India, Ministry of Labour & Employment, New Labour Code for New India: Biggest Labour Reforms in Independent India, pg 8 (2020). See also Ministry of Labour & Employment, 'Labour Law Reforms' (Government of India, 2020).
- ibid (n 7) 1.
- Constitution of India, 1950, a 19(1)(g).
- Indian Contract Act, 1872, s 27.
- Wipro Limited v Beckman Coulter International; 2006 (3) ARBLR 118 Delhi, 2006 (2) CTLJ 57 Del, 131 (2006) DLT 681.
- Suneeth Katarki, Mini Kapoor, Indus Law 'Employment Contracts- Enforcements of Restrictive Covenants Under Various Jurisdictions' (2016) Mondaq
https://www.mondaq.com/india/employee-rights-labour-relations/486496/employment-contracts--enforcement-of-restrictive-covenants-under-various-jurisdictions accessed 17 October, 2021
- Paul Maynard, 'Restrictive Covenants' (Gaby Hardwicke Solicitors, September 2019)
https://www.gabyhardwicke.co.uk/briefing-notes/restrictive-covenants/ accessed 15 October 2021
- Ibid (n 5) 1.
- Ibid (n 5) 1.
- KSK Energy Ventures Limited, 'HR-IR Policy' (KSK Energy Ventures, 2020)
http://ksk.co.in/vslp/docs/nit/reqdocs051219/Annexure13-HR-IR-Policy.pdf accessed 5 October 2021
- Khadija Khartit, 'Independent Contractor' (Investopedia, October 15, 2021)
https://www.investopedia.com/terms/i/independent-contractor.asp accessed 16 October 2021
- Constitution of India, 1950, a 15(1).
- Ministry of Labour & Employment, 'Employment Exchanges (Compulsory Notification of Vacancies) Amendment Bill, 2013' 2016 Government of India
https://labour.gov.in/nes accessed 10 October 2021
- Ministry of Communications and Information Technology Notification (2011), Information Technology (Reasonable security practices and procedures and sensitive personal data or information) Rules, 2011, Rule 5.
- Ministry of Communications and Information Technology Notification (2011), Information Technology (Reasonable security practices and procedures and sensitive personal data or information) Rules, 2011, Rule 3.
- Talwar Thakore & Associates, 'Data Protected- India' 2020 (Linklaters, 15 March 2020)
https://www.linklaters.com/en/insights/data-protected/data-protected---india accessed 12 October 2021
- Information Technology Act, 2000, s 72. See also Information Technology (Reasonable Security practices and procedures and sensitive personal data and information) Rules, 2011 ("IT Rules").
- Anshul Prakash, Kruthi N. Murthy, 'Employment and Labour Law' 2020 (ICLG, 2020) -
accessed 10 October 2021
- Nishith Desai Associates, 'Employment Contracts in India: Enforceability of Restrictive Covenants' (2019) NDA - accessed 12 October 2021
- BI India Bureau, 'Private Companies in India Can Now Convert Permanent Jobs into Fixed-Term Contracts' 2020 (Business Insider, 8 October 2020) - accessed 13 October 2021. See also Industrial Relations (IR) Code 2020.
- Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Act, 1946, s 13(2).
- Ibid 31 5.
- Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, s 9A(b).
- Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, s 9A.
- Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, s 25F.
- Ibid (n 2) 1.
- Payment of Wages Act, 1936, s 2(s).
- Employees' Provident Fund and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952, s 2(b).
- Factories Act, 1948, s 54(f)(a).
- Factories Act, 1948, s 88(f)(a).
- Factories Act, 1948, a 59(f)(a).
- Factories Act, 1948, s 7A.
- The Associated Chambers of Commerce & Industry of India (ASSOCHAM), 'Night Shift for Women: Growth and Opportunities' National Commission for Women India (NCW India) - accessed 16 October 2021
- Factories Act, 1948, ch III.
- Factories Act, 1948, ch X, s 92.
- Ibid (n 5) 1.
- Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013, s 16, 17.
- Vinay Joy and Luv Mohan Saggi, 'Proposed Amendment on Recognition of Trade Union (Amendment) Bill, 2018' (2018) Mondaq - accessed 16 October 2021
- Vikram Shroff, 'Indian Laws on Employee and Workplace Discrimination and Harassment' (2012) Vol 16 No. 2 NDA India - accessed 17 October 2021
- Vikram Shroff, 'Indian Laws on Employee and Workplace Discrimination and Harassment' (2012) Vol 16 No. 2 NDA India
http://www.nishithdesai.com/fileadmin/user_upload/pdfs/Indian_laws_on_employee_and_workplace_discrimination_and_harassment.pdf
- 'Corporate India Walks-the-Talk on Equal Rights for LGBTQ+' (Economic Times, 2021)
https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/company/corporate-trends/corporate-india-walks-the-talk-on-equal-rights-for-lgbtqia/
- Maternity Benefits Act, 1961, s 5.
- Maternity Benefits Act, 1961, s 3(o).
- Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013, ch II.
- Rights of Person with Disabilities Act, 2016, s 7(2).
- Personal Data Protection Bill, 2018, s 16.
- Ibid (n 5) 1.
- Pareekshit Bishnoi, 'Breach of Confidentiality Maintenance Covenants Amid Work From Home : Concerns and Remedies' (Bar and Bench, 21 April, 2020)
https://www.barandbench.com/columns/breach-of-confidentiality-maintenance-covenants-amid-covid-19-concerns-and-remedies
- 'The Personal Data Protection Bill, 2019' (2020) PRS Legislative Research
https://prsindia.org/billtrack/the-personal-data-protection-bill-2019
- Ibid (n 2) 1.
- Ibid (n 2) 1.
- Ibid (n 2) 1.
- Ministry of Home Affairs, Annexure III, 'Details of Visas granted by India', Rule 28
https://www.mha.gov.in/PDF_Other/AnnexIII_01022018.pdf
- Ministry of Home Affairs, Annexure III, 'Details of Visas granted by India', Rule 30
https://www.mha.gov.in/PDF_Other/AnnexIII_01022018.pdf
- Ibid (n 62) 9.
- Sunil Kumar and Bhanu Harish, 'Mandatory Requirements for Retrenchment Under Employment Laws in India' (2015) S&P Solicitors and Advocates
https://www.manupatrafast.in/NewsletterArchives/listing/.pdf
- Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, s 25(f)(c).
- Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, s 2(s)(iii).
- Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, s 33 (1)(b).
- Ibid (n 16) 2.
- Anshul Prakash, Abhinav Rastogi, Deeksha Malik, Kosheel Gupta, 'Restrictive Covenant Clauses Q&A: India (31 Jan, 2021) Thompsons Reuters Practical Law
https://www.khaitanco.com/sites/default/files/2021-07/Restrictive%20covenant%20clauses%20QAndA%20India_0.pdf accessed 16 October 2021
- Constitution of India, 1950, a 29.
- Ibid (n 70) 10.
- Trade Unions Act, 1926, s 17, 18.
- Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013, s 4(2).
- Ibid (n 5) 1.
- Sunil Dhawan, 'What is EPF Scheme and How to Calculate PF Balance' (Economic Times, 4 October 2021)
https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/wealth/earn/all-about-employees-provident-fund-scheme/articleshow/58906943.cms?from=mdr
- Maternity Benefits Act, 1961, s 5(2).
- Ibid (n 10) 2.
Please Drop Your Comments