India and China are emerging giants of Asia. Both of them are the world's most
populous countries and the fastest-growing major economies in the world. The
far-reaching development in the global diplomatic and economic influence of
China and India has also enhanced the importance of their bilateral relations.
China and India are the two oldest civilizations in the world that have
coexisted in peace for millennia. China has emerged as India's largest trading
partner and the two countries have tried hard to expand their strategic and
military ties. The economic relationship between the two countries is considered
as one of the most important bilateral relations in the current global economic
scenario and this trend is expected to grow in the coming years.
The
Flowering relationship between India and China in the early 1950s was
based on peaceful coexistence. But after 1962 the war between the two countries,
faded in an atmosphere of mutual enmity. India and China has a long history of
troubles with its 3,488 kilometer-long border, including a war in 1962 and
several more conflicts such as the Doklam standoff which took place in the year
2017.
The current
Line of Actual Control that creates an effective border
between the two countries is based on the borders were drawn before India's
independence in 1947 and have been the subject of several rounds of negotiations
and agreements. Emerging trends indicate that both India and China will continue
to be highly competitive in the global and regional trade and economic sphere,
and will continue to compete for position and influence, particularly in the
Asian region and especially in South Asia. This article aims to analyze the
inception of and reasons for the emerging drift between two giants; India and
China.
Introduction
This article begins from the consensus-building and pragmatism has increasingly
become the basis of India-China relations. There was extensive cultural contact
between the two countries since the spread of Buddhism from India to China in
the first century A.D. There was a conflict of interest between the two
countries in Tibet. At the end of the Civil war in 1949, China wanted to regain
control of Tibet and to free the Tibetan people by Lamaism and feudalism with
the use of weapons in 1950.
Nehru communicated with the Chinese leaders that
India has no political, regional interest nor does it want any special
principles in Tibet. With Indian support, Tibetan representatives signed an
agreement in May 1951 believing that Chinese sovereignty would make progress in
the current political and social system in Tibet. At the end of the Korean War
(1950-1953), direct negotiations between two Asian veterans began to support
India's mediation efforts.
In 1954, India and China signed an eight-year agreement in Tibet, which laid
down the foundation of their relationship as
Panchsheel. (Peaceful coexistence
agreement between India and China, not interfere between each-others work, 5
things were agreed btw them. And within 10 years of this treaty, India's china
war occurred which destroyed the essence of the agreement.)
In the 1950s the term
Hindi-Chini-Bhai-Bhai was taken into consideration by
the citizens of the country. However, relations between these two countries were
better discussed after their independence from foreign powers at the end of the
fifth decade of the 20th century. The relations between India and China have
been cold since the 1962 war and the mistrust between these two countries has
been prevalent since then.
We can say that the veteran of economies on the world
stage is China; it has developed itself at that level. But, it has miserably
failed in granting human rights, democracy, and social freedom. On the other
hand, India has managed to balance economic development with wide-ranging human
rights. Although it has not managed to keep pace with China as far as economic
prosperity is concerned, however, it has preserved its cultural diversity,
secularism, democratic socialism.
It is surprising that two states with such a rich and sometimes frightening
history, including the border conflict in 1962, could have such a largely
sensitive relationship. An unstable and largely unprofitable preoccupation with
the Indian past, and an equally intense preoccupation with domestic
consolidation on the Chinese side, have tarnished the relationship. For
outsiders, India and China shows some striking similarities. In the
mid-twentieth century both regionalist civilizations reborn as modern republics,
and are now growing forces Both have nuclear weapons, the economy is booming,
military budgets and large reservoirs of manpower expanded, and are dying for
influence in the Indian Ocean, the Persian Gulf, Africa, Central Asia, and East
Asia.[1]
Historically, negotiations between India and China have always been few and far
between. An analysis of India's relations with China today must take into
account the historical perspective, differences in the global situation,
domestic policies, and perceived national security interests. Given the issues
and diversity in which India and China are engaged, the India-China relationship
can be described as a very complex engagement.
Conflict Of 1962
One of the turning points in the relationship between India and China, when
China's perception of India became one of the most prominent causes of the
Sino-Indian War for its rule over Tibet Various military incidents flared up
between India and China during summers, and over 350 Chinese soldiers surrounded
an Indian outpost in Chushul and used loudspeakers to convince the Gurkhas that
they should not fight for India.
The Chinese attacked in the North Eastern Border Region (NEFA) and Ladakh on 20
October 1962 and occupied about 5000 square miles of Indian Territory. China
announced a unilateral ceasefire on 10 November 1962 and retreated the McMahon
Line in the NEFA sector. Although it gained about 3000 sq. km in the Indian
Territory, however, according to China, it does not occupy even an inch of
Indian Territory. In the same year, the Indian Parliament passed a resolution to
wage a united struggle until the recovery of the Indian Territory from China and
it also refused to close any territory occupied by China as part of any
settlement.
The 1954 Agreement on Tibet was buried before the conflict. Business
relations between India and China broke down after 1962 but were later resumed
in the year 1978. The anti-India policy adopted by China was not only to
encourage and incite Naxalite violence in India but also to train Nagas and
Mizos in China to fight against India and send them back after the training was
over.
The 1962 China conflict was also reflected in China's policies towards
India during the 1965 and 1971 wars with Pakistan. China had already signed a
friendship treaty with Pakistan in 1963. It is clear that the Indo-China border
conflict in 1962 severely damaged the friendship between the Chinese and the
Indians. The shadow of the 1962 conflict has still not disappeared. Therefore,
it was indeed one of the biggest challenges to change the mindset and seek
anarchy in India-China relations, which reached a nadir after 1962 conflict.
The period during 1959-1976 for India-China relations is portrayed as a period
of mutual mistrust, suspicion, and unfriendliness. India and China had gone
through and witnessed an important era during 1976-1988 where both nations have
made maximum efforts to clear misunderstandings among themselves. These efforts
were mainly in the context of understanding each other to create a positive
environment.
The year 1976 was a historic year in India-China relations as both
countries were able to restore their diplomatic relations by restoring their
ambassadors. Sikkim's declaration with India in 1975 shocked the Chinese
authorities. China had refused to accept and continued with its policy of
autocracy. Despite efforts, India was able to restore confidence among the
Chinese people and reactivated their ambassador positions.
In 1991, border trade was revived at a minimum, but it is a shadow of its
former self. China's economic reform and opening up to the world brought
unprecedented change within the country and produced a major global impact.
Years passed, and by 2010 it had become the largest trading partner of goods in
India. The volume of trade symbolizes the diversification of relations beyond
historical and political.
The Current Dynamic
After understanding many ideas of the Sino-Indian relationship it is the
believed that two growing powers with fast-growing economies and global
ambitions at such close quarters cannot co-exist peacefully.
In the past, China has formed alliances and partnerships with countries in the
Indian periphery, most notably with Pakistan, and also with Myanmar, Nepal, Sri
Lanka, Bangladesh, and, most recently, with Afghanistan. Combined with the
Chinese presence in the Indian Ocean region, this has caused some concern among
Indian policymakers of the strategic enclosure. Relations between India and
China have improved significantly in the last nine to ten years. However,
generalization does not mean that differences in strategic perceptions between
the two have suddenly transformed or that conflicts of interests and differences
on different issues have disappeared. Despite the improvement in India and China
relations, many issues have come up as bottlenecks. The main issues are as
follows:
Border And Territorial Dispute
China has been claiming some northeastern parts of the territory of India for a
long time. China claims 90,000 square kilometers as its territory, calling
it
South Tibet which is a significant territorial part of the state of
Arunachal Pradesh. It refuses to recognize Arunachal Pradesh as part of India.
The border is now known as the Line of Actual Control (LAC) in both India and
China. Later, China was found occupying the Aksai Chin region, northeast of
Ladakh. India claims that around 38,000 sq. km in Jammu and Kashmir was
occupied. Under the Sino-Pakistan border agreement of 1963, Pakistan illegally
ceded 5,180 sq. km of Indian Territory (Trans-Karakoram Path) to China. The
transfer is disputed by India as it is a part of Jammu and Kashmir.[2]
These were some of the major border issues that are being violated by China,
despite signing bilateral agreements, and most recently in the year 2020, the
Galwan Valley incident was fought on the Line of Actual Control (LAC). There was
the third round of core commander-level talks was held between India and China.
Both sides emphasized rapid and stage-wise de-escalation in the areas close to
the Line of Actual Control (LAC) in Ladakh as a priority.
On May 5th and 6th,
Indian and Chinese troops scrambled at Pangong Tso in Ladakh during the clash,
and risked 20 Indian soldiers' lives, and an unknown number of casualties on the
Chinese side. The stand-offs in the Galwan valley of Ladakh had increased due to
infrastructure projects undertaken by India in recent years. India is
constructing a strategic road through the Galwan Valley which is close to China,
connecting the region to the airstrip. This was the biggest flashpoint of the
1962 conflict.
The border or Line of Actual Control has not been demarcated and China and India
have different views on where it should be located, which leads to regular
border conflicts. Chinese try to change these disputed areas unilaterally. This
is part of China's 'nibble and negotiates policy'. Their objective is to ensure
that India does not build any infrastructure alongside LAC. This is their way of
achieving a political goal with the military while gaining more territory in the
process and this is the main reason behind the conflicts and disputes. [3]
Conflict Amidst Covid-19
Plagued by a lack of trust, the COVID-19 epidemic added a new twist to the old
tale. India was the first non-communist country in Asia to establish diplomatic
relations with the People's Republic of China on 1 April 1950. It's been 70
years of the establishment of diplomatic relations between China and India.
To
celebrate the milestone, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Chinese
President Xi Jinping named 2020 as
India-China Cultural and People-to-People
Year and marked the milestone planned to organize 70 activities. Both sides had
the planning for deepening exchanges between their assemblies, political
parties, cultural and youth organizations, and military forces at all leve1.
However, plans came to a halt due to the emergence of the Covid-19 pandemic.
The move which was seen as targeted at China at the very first was, in April.
During which India called for greater scrutiny of investment from neighboring
countries to prevent the
opportunistic takeover of businesses that may have
been facing financial issues due to the epidemic. Under the new policy, all
countries that share a border with India, including China, Nepal, Bhutan, and
Myanmar, earlier it was only applied in Bangladesh and Pakistan that can only
invest under the
government route, which requires government approval. During
these situations, the Indian council of medical research (ICMR) decided to
return all the test kits rapidly that were produced by Chinese firms over
quality issues.[4]
Well, the response from China was an argument that the move is a 'Discriminatory
Act' performed by India and it violates the principle of non-discrimination
which is one of the core principles of WTO law and policy. Beijing stressed the
need to "treat investments from different countries equally, and promote an
open, fair, and equal trade environment".[5]
To boost its screening and virus
testing, India ordered more than half a million Chinese test kits but as earlier
the decision which was taken by the Indian council of medical research (ICMR),
the Chinese Government reacted that India is labeling Chinese products
faulty
and irresponsible These approaches highlight the increasing extravagance
resulting from the epidemic between India and China. These feelings will only
get stronger with time.
Further, discord is expected over the disintegration between the US and China,
seeing India as a US ally and a stakeholder for potential movements of the
global supply chain. As it has crossed the 70s, India-China relations will see
more flow and remain under more tension, even as the two countries seek to
maintain peaceful co-existence.
Banning Chinese Applications In India
On June 29, the Government of India decided to ban the use of 59 Chinese apps in
India. However, tensions between China and India increased with the Indian
government calling for apps to be blocked for security reasons. An interim order
was issued in this regard by the Ministry of Electronics and Information
Technology cited in Section 69A of the Information Technology Act (2000), which
empowers the central government to block online public access to any
information.
Section 69A
Power to issue directions for blocking for public access of any
information through any computer resource[6]
However, India has banned 47 more apps that were primarily clones of the
previously banned 59 apps. According to reports, the Ministry of Home Affairs
has prepared a list of over 250 Chinese apps, which can be declared based on
national security breaches. Although China has said that it violates the World
Trade Organization (WTO) rules, it is unclear whether it will approach the WTO
against the Indian apps ban. With its digital protectionist policies, the
possibility of China taking the issue to the World Trade Organization seems
limited.
Conclusion
The problem in India-China relations is the lack mutual awareness,
understanding, and trust. As a result, India's Chinese policy has been described
as slow, although it has been largely successful in maintaining peace and
tranquillity between the two countries. Therefore, it appears that with their
gradual expansion to each other's existence and profile, there has been
competition between India and China. The gradual march of human civilization
into the future will only make this fact more transparent and clear.
It is clear from the experience of the past 70 years that India-China relations
are complex and there are challenges for both practitioners and scholars of
international relations. The future of Sino-Indian relations lies in the
cooperative working with each other. Under the present circumstances,
India-China relations have acquired strategic importance in a world of
uncertainty. The way forward for them is to approach the problem pragmatically
and positively, with cooperation and mutual understanding.
End-Notes:
- David M. Malone & Rohan Mukherjee, India and China: Conflict and
Cooperation, Survival, vol. 52, (February-March 2010
- India China Relations a Perspective History Essay, UK Essays, November
2018, available at: https://www.ukessays.com/essays/history/india-china-relations-a-perspective-history-essay.php.
(accessed on 02/09/2020 at 02.13 am.)
- See Galwan Valley Clash, Drishti IAS, and 29 June 2020, available at:
https://www.drishtiias.com/daily-updates/daily-news-editorials/galwan-valley-clash.(accessed on
02/09/2020 at 02.50 am.)
- See: Amrita Jash, China relations: Compromises and conflicts amid
Covid-19, 1 3 May 2020, available
at: https://www.thinkchina.sg/india-china-relations-compromises-and-conflicts-amid-covid-19. accessed
on 02/09/2020 at 3.00 am)
- Ibid.
- See: Section 69A, The Information Technology Act, 2000, Indian Kanoon,
available at: https://indiankanoon.org/doc/10190353/#:~:text=(1)%20Where%20the%20Central%20Government,or%20public%20order%20or%20for (accessed
on 02/09/2020 at 03.15 am.)
Please Drop Your Comments