A company which has only one person as a member.
The concept of One Person Company (here-in-after referred as OPC) is a new
dimension that is introduced by the Companies Act, 2013. It basically means a
company shall have only one shareholder.The Companies Act, 1956 did not have the
concept of OPC and hence a company like OPC did not have corporate liability.
Before the 2013 act, sole proprietorship was the concept in place if one person
had to open or carry on his own corporate sector but it was different from OPC
as it could not enjoy the benefits given under Companies Act.
SocietasUnius Personae is the name given to OPC’s that are included in the draft
bill of European Union in 2015 to facilitate the cross border business of the
Union[1]. This concept is prevalent in other countries like the US, Australia,
Singapore and China (introduced in 2005).Thus it gives a corporate liability to
the risky sole proprietorship format.
The government appointed a committee by name Naresh Chandra Committee in 2003 to
recommend with regards to amongst other acts, the Companies Act, 2013 did not
make any recommendation on OPC[2].This concept was first introduced by a
committee headed by Dr. JJ Irani in 2005[3]. The committee recommended providing
the corporate sector liability to the sole proprietorship firms. Section 3 of
the Act states that One Person Company is a private limited company but with one
member only; as a private limited should have minimum of two members.
· First and foremost is that the company shall have only one member[4].
Member is defined as a shareholder or a person who agrees in writing to become a
shareholder or the subscriber of MoA who has agreed to become the member of the
company[5].
· The member of the company shall always be a natural person. Thus, a
company, which is an artificial person, cannot incorporate OPC as a subsidiary
or holding company.
· The natural person who will be the member of the company shall have to
be an Indian citizen and a resident of India (a resident of India means a person
who has stayed for 182 in the immediately preceding financial year[6]).
· He shall be a major because he would be the person to enter into a
contract on behalf of the company and thus will be liable in breach of the
contract. Indian Contract Act specifies that a person entering into a contract
shall be a major.
· The member of the company shall have only one OPC in his name. The
member cannot be a shareholder of more than one OPC simultaneously[7].
Every company shall have directors. Minimum of two directors in case of private
company and minimum of three directors in case of public company[8]. OPC shall
have minimum of one director and maximum of 15 directors[9]. The member of the
company shall be its first director[10] which shall also be mentioned in MoA.
Section 12 of the Companies Act, 2013 deals with naming of a company, that is,
whether it is a public company or a private company, it should be mentioned
wherever the name of the company is used. The same is in the case of OPC as
well, that is, under the name of the company, ‘One Person Company’ should be
written in brackets, whether the name is printed or affixed or engraved[11].
Company has a feature of perpetual succession. In any other company, on the
demise of the member or his incapacity to act as a member, then the legal
representatives of the incapacitated member shall replace and carry over the
business. But, it is not in the case of OPC, as a member can have more than one
legal representative, on the incapacity of the member to act, all the legal
representatives cannot act as members of OPC, if such were the case, then the
whole purpose of OPC is eliminated[12].
As the definition itself suggests, OPC is a company which has only one member.
Thus, a nominee has to be nominated in the case of death of the existing member
or incapacity of the member to carry on the business any more[13]. In such
cases, the existing member shall have to nominate a person as the member of the
company.This shall happen only with the written consent of the nominee according
to the form INC-3 which is regarding the nominee of a one person company[14].
The nominated member can withdraw from the nominee himself. He has to
communicate this to the existing member who shall then within 30 days
communicate it to the company, that is, the board of directors;And the same
procedure in case of change of the nominee. It shall later have to be mentioned
in the memorandum[15] and shall also have to be informed to the registrar of
companies.
Section 92 of the 2013 Act provides that annual returns shall have to be filed
at the end of every financial year. Annual returns is the document which
contains the record of its composition, turn over, profit, members etc in that
specific financial year.This document shall have to be signed by a director and
the company secretary. But, in the case of OPC, it shall have to be signed by
either the company secretary or a director and not both. The report of board of
director also includes a snippet of the annual returns. Then, it shall be
submitted to the registrar.
Meetings
· Section 96 of the Act provides for conducting annual general meeting
within the prescribed time limit. But, this is not a mandate for OPCs as they
are specifically excluded from conducting general meeting after every financial
year.
· Section 173(5) of the Act provides for conducting board meetings in
the case of OPC, where there are more than one director, a board meeting shall
have to be conducted in every six months of the calendar year and the gap
between the meetings should not be less than ninety days.
· The resolution of the general meetings is deemed to be accepted or
passed when it has been passed by the sole member of the company and this shall
later be communicated to the company, that is, the board of directors. This
resolution shall be later entered in the minutes book maintained and shall be
signed by the member himself[16].
The conversion of OPC can be done in two ways:
(i) Compulsory conversion: under this category, if OPC exceeds
the paid-up share capital of 50 lakhs rupees and if the annual turnoverof the
company for three consecutive years exceeds 2 crores rupees, then it shall
become either public or private company. This has to be done within six months
of the company exceeds its threshold[17].
(ii) Voluntary conversion: if the company is to be converted
voluntarily, it cannot be done so until two years have been passed from the date
of incorporation of the company, apart from satisfying the conditions mentioned
in the category of compulsory conversion of the company.
In either of the categories, the conversion has to be done according to Section
18 of the Act.
Income-tax Act, 1961 hasn’t recognized OPC as a company to levy taxes on it but
considers it as a private company and the taxes levied are similar to that of a
private company. OPC is chargeable at the rate of 30% flat. If the turn over
exceeds 1 crores, then the company is liable to pay surcharge at the rate of 5%.
MAT (Minimum Alternate Tax) and DDT (Dividend Distribution Tax) are also
applicable on OPC. MAT is the minimum tax that is payable by the company on
books profit whether or not the tax on income has been paid or not. DDT is the
tax imposed on the domestic that pay dividends to their investors. It is levied
by the Government of India.
OPCs shall also comply with many other regulations like TDS regulations, GST
regulations, PF and ESI regulations. OPCs shall also have their accounts audited
when the turnover of the company exceeds 2crores rupees. OPCs shall also file
income tax returns for every financial year before 30th September of that
financial year to the Income Tax Department.
Non-applicability of provisions for OPC
Section 122 provides that few provisions like section 98, section 100 to 111 and
few more are not applicable to OPCs. The tribunal cannot call a meeting of OPC
on its own[18]. OPC shall not call for extra-ordinary general meeting as in the
case of other companies, which means notice of meeting need not have to be given
to the company[19]. Since, the company has only one member, quorum of the
meetings[20], electing the chairman of the meeting[21], proxies during the
meeting[22], the member cannot exercise a vote on his own share[23], voting by
electronic media or by showing hands or postal ballot are also not applicable to
OPC[24]. Thus, a resolution among the membersof the company cannot be
passed[25].
Financial Statement
Section 134 of the Act deals with filing of financial statements. Financial
statement is defined in Section 2(40) of the Act as a statement to include
balance sheet, changes in equity, cash flow statements, profit and loss account
and an explanatory note for these statements. But, in the case of OPC, the
financial statement shall not include cash flow statement. According to Section
134, the financial statement shall have to be attached with the report from the
Board of directors. In case of OPC, the report of the directors attached to the
financial statements shall be considered as explanations or comments given by
the directors on the financial statement of the company. This shall be filed
with Registrar of the companies within 180 days from the closure of the
financial year with necessary documents[26]
Thus, these are few features of One Person Company which makes it different from
any other company and benefits the person who wants to invest his own capital in
the company without fund raising for the company. These features make the
company to have its own advantages when a person wants to start OPC. Thus, with
the increase of sole proprietorship before Companies Act, 2013, legislation
incorporated the concept of OPC in the 2013 act and gave a corporate liability
to such companies. Thus, they have their own separate legal entity and have
those features that come along separate legal entity.
OPC and Sole Proprietorship
Sole proprietorship is a concept where in a single person carries on a business
or firm in the form of sole proprietor. The business is unregistered and it is
carried on from generation to generation. Other features of the same shall be
looked into with comparison.
Registration of the business
OPC is a private limited company and has to be registered by following the
procedure as given under the Companies Act, 2013 and Companies Incorporation
Rules, 2014. As soon as a company is registered and incorporated, it becomes a
separate legal entity with limited liability.
Whereas, in the case of sole proprietorship, registration of the firm in not
mandatory. Thus, it is not a separate legal entity and does not fall with the
ambit of company law and hence not recognized and secured. Since, it does not
have a separate legal entity, the liability is unlimited.
Limited and Unlimited Liability
As seen above, OPC has limited liability on its shareholder. This means, in case
of loss, the shareholder is liable to pay the limited amount that he is liable
for and the remaining loss shall be borne by the company. Thus, OPC is a company
limited by shares.
Whereas, in the case of sole proprietorship, the owner and the business are one
and the same. Thus, the owner shall have unlimited liability when losses are
incurred. The owner or the sole proprietor of the firm shall have to borne the
entire losses and will not be able to shift it on the shoulders of others.
Succession
OPC is a single member company which has been discussed throughout the article.
Nomination of a member to OPC is one of the salient features of the company. As
already seen in Section 3 of the Companies act, 2013 a nominee shall have to be
appointed by the sole member of the company when the existing member becomes
incapacitated. Thus, the nomination of the member carries on the root of OPC,
that is, a single member company.
Whereas, in the case of sole proprietorship, on the death or incapacity of the
sole proprietor, succession of the business is carried on through an execution
of will, as this business is considered as family business. If the sole
proprietor has passed it to more than one person, then it shall no longer be a
sole proprietorship. Thus, the business loses its agenda of sole proprietorship.
Income tax Act, 1961 does not have taxing regulations for OPC as OPC is
introduced in the year 2013. Thus, OPC is taxed as a private limited company.
The taxation rates are already seen in the salient features of OPC.
Whereas, in the case of sole proprietorship, the firm is considered as income or
profit of the sole proprietor as it is carried on by a person and it does not
have legal status to it. Thus, it is taxed accordingly and does not have
separate provisions for the same under tax law.
Conversion
Conversion of OPC into a private or public limited company is not a hideous
process. It can be done in two ways: they are compulsory conversion and
voluntary conversion. The company should also exceed the minimum paid-up share
capital and average annual turnover.
Whereas, in the case of sole proprietorship, conversion of the firm into any
forms of a company is very difficult as the whole structure of the firm will
have to be changed to that of a company. MoA and AoA have to be filed. The firm
will have to bring in new members and directors and many other formalities.
Thus, the process is very hideous.
Thus, the comparison between OPCs and sole proprietorship indicates that
carrying on a business in the form of OPC is always secured, with fewer risks
involved as compared to that of sole proprietorship which comes with a lot of
risks and unnecessary burden on the sole proprietorship. The Companies Act, 2013
has given legal status to that of OPCs in order to encourage secured limited
liability sole proprietorship. Thus, One Person Company is more secured and
advantageous when compared to the sole proprietorship firms.
Conclusion
Prior to the Companies Act, 2013, a company with minimum 2 members and 2
directors was supposed to be formed. Thus, One Person Company was not recognized
in the 1956 Act. But, 2013 Act has given it OPCs a separate legal entity and
other facilities which accompany separate legal entity. Other privileges like
limited liability, separate property, perpetual succession, capacity to sue and
be sues as an artificial person and few fundamental rights like Article 14 of
the Constitution of India, 1950 as well.
Everything has its own criticisms as well. OPCs are criticized to be the
possible way to tax evasion. As we have seen in the case of Sir DinshawManekjee
Petit Case[27], in which Dinshaw was the maximum shareholder of the four
companies and the main purpose for which the companies were incorporated was for
tax evasion. In the case of OPCs, since there shall be only one shareholder, he
shall invest in the company to evade tax and simultaneously earn profits from
the company. There has to be a constant check on this aspect of OPCs.
In respect of OPC which is a completely new concept that is introduced by the
Companies Act, 2013 is interlinked with other legislation like tax laws, GST
regulations, Contract Act and many others. OPCs are private limited companies
and also with single membership. In order to OPCs being recognized as single
member company and not clubbed with other private limited companies, certain
amendments have to be made to other legislations which are interlinked. Thus,
OPCs are benefiting the Indian Society with their enormous remarkable features.
End-Notes
[1]T. P. Ghosh, Article, SocietasUnius Personae One Person Company movement in
India to accelerate for business expansion, [2016] 133 SCL 77 (Article).
[2]T. N. Pandey, Article, One Person Company – The new concept under the
Companies Bill, 2012 (as passed by Lok Sabha) whether necessary?,[2013] 118 SCL
59 (Article).
[3]J.J Irani, Report of Expert Committee on Company Law, 31-5-2005.
[4] Section 2(62) of the Companies Act, 2013.
[5] Section 2(55) of the Companies Act, 2013.
[6] Rule 3 of the Companies Incorporation Rules, 2014.
[7]Ibid.
[8] Section 149 of the Companies Act, 2013.
[9]Ibid
[10] Section 152 of the Companies act, 2013.
[11] Section 12 of the Companies Act, 2013.
[12] R. Saluja, One Person Company (2014).
[13] Section 3 of the Companies act, 2013.
[14] Companies Incorporation Rules, 2014.
[15] Section 4 of the Companies Act, 2013.
[16]Section 122(3) of the Companies Act, 2013; Table-F, Articles of association
of a company limited by shares, given in the Companies Act, 2013.
[17] Rule 6 of Companies Incorporation Rules, 2014.
[18] Section 98 of the Companies Act, 2013.
[19] Sections 100 and 101 of the Companies Act, 2013.
[20] Section 103 of the Companies Act, 2013.
[21] Section 104 of the Companies Act, 2013.
[22] Section 105 of the Companies Act, 2013.
[23] Section 106 of the Companies Act, 2013.
[24] Sections 107, 108 and 110 of the Companies Act, 2013 respectively.
[25] Section 111 of the Companies Act, 2013.
[26] Section 137 of the Companies act, 2013.
[27] AIR 1972 Bom 371.
How To File For Mutual Divorce In Delhi Mutual Consent Divorce is the Simplest Way to Obtain a D...
It is hoped that the Prohibition of Child Marriage (Amendment) Bill, 2021, which intends to inc...
One may very easily get absorbed in the lives of others as one scrolls through a Facebook news ...
The Inherent power under Section 482 in The Code Of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (37th Chapter of t...
The Uniform Civil Code (UCC) is a concept that proposes the unification of personal laws across...
Artificial intelligence (AI) is revolutionizing various sectors of the economy, and the legal i...
Please Drop Your Comments