State recognition is a fundamental concept in international relations that
refers to the formal acknowledgment of the legal existence and sovereignty of a
state by other states. This process is a key aspect of diplomatic relations, as
it establishes the legitimacy of a state in the eyes of the international
community and is often a prerequisite for the establishment of formal diplomatic
relations and the negotiation of treaties.
State recognition is a complex issue that is influenced by a range of political,
legal, and historical factors. While some states may recognize others based on
criteria such as territorial control, population size, and economic or military
power, there are often competing claims to sovereignty and disputes over
territory that can complicate the recognition process. In addition, the
recognition of a state can be influenced by geopolitical considerations,
domestic politics, and international norms and values.
The recognition of a state can has significant political, economic, and social
implications for both the recognized state and the international community.
For example, the recognition of a new state can lead to changes in political
alliances, the establishment of new trade relationships, and the extension of
legal protections and obligations to citizens of the newly recognized state.
Overall, state recognition is a critical component of international relations
and diplomacy and plays an important role in shaping the global political
Meaning of recognition
State recognition refers to the formal acknowledgement of the legal existence
and sovereignty of a state by other states. In other words, recognition of state
under international legal system can be define as the formal acknowledge or
acceptance of a new state as an international personality by existing state of
the international community. it is the acknowledge by the existence state that a
political entity has the characteristics of statehood.
Essentials of recognitionArticle 1 of the Montevideo Convention on the Rights and Duties of States,
signed in 1933, states:
"The state as a person of international law should possess the following
qualifications: a) a permanent population; b) a defined territory; c)
government; and d) capacity to enter into relations with other states."
This article sets out the basic qualifications that a state must possess to be
recognized as a person of international law. According to this article, a state
must have a permanent population, a defined territory, a government, and the
capacity to enter relations with other states.
The requirement for a permanent population means that a state must have a group
of people who live within its borders on a permanent basis. The requirement for
a defined territory means that a state must have a clearly defined and
internationally recognized territory.
The requirement for a government means that a state must have a system of
government that is able to exercise authority over the population and territory.
Finally, the requirement for the capacity to enter relations with other states
means that a state must have the ability to enter into treaties and other
international agreements with other states.
Overall, Article 1 of the Montevideo Convention provides a useful framework for
determining whether a political entity can be recognized as a state under
international law. It has been widely accepted and adopted by the international
community as a basis for state recognition.
Legal effect of recognition
recognition has important legal effects in international law.
Some of the key legal effects of state recognition include:
Establishment of diplomatic relations: Recognition of a state establishes formal diplomatic relations between the
recognizing state and the recognized state, allowing for the exchange of
ambassadors, establishment of embassies, and other diplomatic privileges and
Establishment of legal obligations: Recognition of a state creates legal obligations between the recognizing
state and the recognized state, such as obligations to respect each other's
territorial integrity and sovereignty, and to refrain from interfering in
each other's internal affairs.
Participation in international organizations: Recognition of a state is often a prerequisite for participation in
international organizations such as the United Nations, which can provide
access to important legal and political mechanisms for resolving disputes
and promoting international cooperation.
Treaty-making: Recognition of a state allows for the negotiation and signing of treaties
and other international agreements, which can have important legal
implications for trade, investment, and other areas of cooperation.
Protection of citizens: Recognition of a state provides legal protections and rights to its citizens
under international law, such as the right to diplomatic protection and the
right to access consular services when traveling abroad.
Overall, state recognition has significant legal effects in international
law, creating important obligations and opportunities for states to engage in
cooperation and promote peaceful coexistence.
Theories of recognitionThe recognition of a new entity as a sovereign state is based on two main
Declarative Theory: According to this theory, statehood is a matter of fact, and recognition by
other states is simply a declaration of an existing situation. In other
words, a state exists regardless of whether other states recognize it or
not, and recognition simply acknowledges this fact. This theory is based on
the principle of effectiveness, which emphasizes that the key criteria for
statehood are effective control over a defined territory and population.
The declaratory theory of recognition has been criticized for
oversimplifying the complex process of state recognition, ignoring the role
of politics and power in the decision to recognize a state, and failing to
account for the legal and functional criteria for statehood.
Constitutive Theory: According to this theory, statehood is a matter of law, and recognition by
other states is necessary to establish a new state under international law.
In other words, a state does not exist until it is recognized by other
states, and recognition creates a new legal entity with rights and
obligations under international law. This theory is based on the principle
of consent, which emphasizes that statehood requires the consent of other
states in the international community.
The constitutive theory of recognition has been criticized for its lack of
clarity on the criteria for statehood and recognition, its subjectivity and
reliance on political judgments, its perpetuation of bias and inequality in
the international system, and its inconsistency in practice.
Modes of recognitionThere are two modes of recognition of state:
- De facto recognition:
Refers to the recognition of a new state or government based on factual or
practical considerations, rather than legal criteria. When a state extends
de facto recognition to another state, it acknowledges the existence of that
state or government without necessarily endorsing its legal or political
De facto recognition may be based on a variety of factors, including the
control of territory, the exercise of authority, and the ability to enter
international relations. De facto recognition may be expressed through
actions such as establishing diplomatic relations, engaging in trade or
other economic activities, or providing military or humanitarian assistance.
De facto recognition may be contrasted with de jure recognition, which is
the formal and official recognition of a new state or government in
accordance with international law and legal criteria for statehood.
- De jure recognition:
Refers to the formal and official recognition of a new state or government
in accordance with international law and the legal criteria for statehood.
When a state extends de jure recognition to another state, it acknowledges
the legal and political legitimacy of that state and establishes formal
diplomatic relations with it.
De jure recognition is typically expressed through a formal declaration or a
diplomatic exchange and it requires that the recognizing state consider the
legal and political criteria for statehood, such as a defined territory, a
permanent population, a government, and the capacity to enter international
relations. De jure recognition is often contrasted with de facto
recognition, which is recognition based on facts or practical considerations
rather than legal criteria.
Withdrawal of recognitionWithdrawal of recognition is also two ways:
Withdrawal of De facto recognition:
- Withdrawal of De facto recognition
- Withdrawal of De jure recognition
If a state has de facto recognition and it fail to fulfill the essential
condition of statehood it can be withdrawal over declaration or through
communication with the authority of the recognized states and be done by issuing
a public statement.
Withdrawal of De jure recognition:
It is interpreted that de jure recognition cannot be revoked but there are some
jurist who consider de jure recognition as a political act that considers it
revocable. Therefore, there are unlike opinions about the withdrawal of de jure
recognition. Such recognition can only be made in exceptional cases or when the
state does not fulfill the essential condition of statehood. It can be withdrawn
over by issuing a public statement.
Recognition of government
An important factor is any state is the government. When a state is formed, the
government changes from time to time. When the government changes as an ordinary
course of political action, the recognition of government by the existing state
is not required, but when the government changes due to any revolution, then its
recognition by the existing state is required.
For the recognition the new government establish out of revolution, the
existing state need to consider that:
- The new government has sufficient control over the territory and its
people or not.
- The new government is willing to fulfill the international duties and
obligation or not.
When the existing states are satisfied that the new government resulting out of
the revolution can fulfill the condition as mentioned above, then the new
government can be recognized by the existing states.
State recognition refers to the process by which a country is recognized as a
sovereign state by other countries and international organizations. It is an
important aspect of international relations, as it determines a state's status
in the international community and its ability to participate in international
affairs. The recognition of a state as sovereign is typically based on several
criteria, such as the existence of a defined territory, a stable government, and
the ability to conduct international relations.
State recognition is a complex issue that requires careful consideration by
governments, international organizations, and other actors in the international
community. It can impact a state's ability to participate in international
forums and organizations, access resources and assistance, and engage in
diplomatic relations with other states.
Furthermore, state recognition can also have broader implications for regional
and global stability, as the recognition of a new state or the withdrawal of
recognition of an existing state can potentially lead to conflict and
instability. Overall, state recognition is a key aspect of diplomacy and
international relations, and it is important for states and the international
community to approach this issue with careful consideration and an understanding
of its potential implications.
Please Drop Your Comments