File Copyright Online - File mutual Divorce in Delhi - Online Legal Advice - Lawyers in India

Should India Start Taxing The Religious Institutions

Despite possessing characteristics of being uncritical, irrational and heavily dogmatic, religions have played an undeniably crucial role in shaping the history of mankind. The faith and fear of humans in a supernatural creator deity has helped clergy earn and live without much of a work which would also enjoy tax exemption. Any form of organized religion generally has a place of worship and there are billions of followers visiting them and most of these followers offer their wealth to the place of religious worship. Whether it is the Tirumala Balaji Temple or WAKF Board, irrespective of their faiths, believers have contributed every penny for making some of these religious organizations even richer than some sub-Saharan countries.

All the religious organizations are getting this exorbitant amount of money from people. All these institutions are exempted based on ancient mythology and with claims which are proved to be either unverifiable or empirically proven to be wrong. In this paper, I would be talking about the donations which a religious organization receives from a devotee. However, I feel the need for setting this up as a separate specific charity trust which is not the part of any religious organization.

There are various countries which are governed by secular laws and these are the countries which have separated religion from the public sphere. The limitation of religion to a personal sphere is possible in those countries where modern education is almost mandatorily accessed by everyone. The idea of scientific temperament is there in a lot of people and consequently in the legislators. They were intelligent enough to separate religion from influencing legislations.

This is not the case in India because majority of the believers have helped the politics get based on identity rather than issues or the issues are shaped based on the caste or religious identity. When vote-banks and election manifestos are typically reflecting on religions, Indian secularism is not the separation of state from religion but a strike of balance of harmony between various religions. Before delving into the legal aspects of taxing the religions, the famous idea of Dworkin about law and politics being inseparable should never be forgotten. With the caveat that Indian secularism is a misnomer for religious harmony, I would briefly analyze the jurisprudence of taxation and the possible ways in which more revenue can be extracted out of various religious organizations in the country.

We must look at the various examples of Indian religious organizations and their incomes to understand why Indian gods are very rich. The wealthiest of all temples in India is the Padmanabhaswamy temple [situated in Kerala] which is assessed to have about $20 billion USD.[1] The next one is Tirumala Balaji Temple which is visited by approximately 60,000 devotees who bequeath around INR 650 crore to the temple annually. The gold on the idol itself weighs 1,000 kg.[2] Now we must consider another endemic aspect of devotion in India which is the concept of godmen.

For example, Sai Baba of Shridi who had relinquished all the riches in his life and ended up leading an abstemious presence, is supposed to possess gold and silver jewelry priced roughly at INR 320 million and silver coins worth more than INR 60 million. The temple at Shirdi receives donations worth INR 35 million every year. There are various other so called spiritual gurus in India like Sri Sri Ravishankar who is the organizational head of Art of Living, Baba Ramdev, Asaram Bapu, etc who are wealthy. Shashvat Committee, which was supervised by Justice Shahsvat Kumar, came up with an extensively prepared status report on Muslims in India in 2011 which found out that Nationwide, WAKF properties constitute a land bank worth INR 1.2 lakh crore and could have generated annual returns of INR 12,000 crores.[3]

Like the US, there is like an unwritten contract made between these kinds of religious organizations and the government which seems more like a perfidious compromise with the clergy. Simply put it is this: You don't obstruct polity and governance, and in return the state will not tax religious proselytism.[4] This cannot be done in case of India because the lack of necessity of religions in politics is not even recognized by the state. Additionally, various states as well as the union government have established various subsidies for pilgrimage tours like Haj, Amarnath, etc. Since this is irrelevant to taxation, I would not elaborate on that.

There is an aspect of charity attached to tax exemption which is almost at the same level ludicrousness when compared to Indian agricultural loans which were misused blatantly. It is definite that there a lot of people who would be noble enough to do charity just like some poor farmers who would have used the loan because they genuinely needed it. Laws are not immune from misuse nor are without any loopholes. There is a way out if a person wishes to legitimize his/her black money, a donation of the same to any charitable institution after cutting a deal, based on a quid pro quo, with the owner of that institution can ensure the legitimization of black money.

The various tax exemptions given to religious organizations accrue broadly from section 10 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. Religion is considered as a non-profit entity in the act. Sub-sections (23BBA), (23C) [v] are some of these which enables tax exemption to religious organizations.[5]

The institution must spend 85% of its income in any financial year which is from April 1st to March 31st on the purposes of the organization. Surplus income may be collected for precise projects for a period alternating from 1 to 5 years. Section 11[5] specifies the methods to deposit.

There are a lot of procedural technicalities mentioned in the act in other sections as well. Religious and other charitable institutions are both liable for registration and are governed by rules relating to application and accumulation at present. Direct Taxes Code of 2009 would also give a more privileged position of total immunity from taxation for religious trusts and institutions by exemption in Item No. 37 in the Seventh Schedule.[6] Except for a very few instances, there is no way in which a religious entity can be taxed.

To get registered as a religious entity in a country as corrupt as India is not a very difficult task, just like how some rich industrialists ends up under the BPL. Making charity through government is the only way out to solve this issue. Government can collect the money which all these noble people are willing to give away as charity and redistribute it to the not so privileged class of people who are needy. Previously, even according to Service Tax religious organizations providing shops as rentals or any place to religious function in this area were also exempt from service tax.

The way in which tax exemptions for religious organizations are misused would be better explained with the help of a case. After the introduction of GST in July 2017, Tirumala temple has come under the ambit of taxation. A lot of its tax-exempt properties were taken away once GST was introduced. As per some unofficial records, the pilgrimage visits by the devotees all over the year fetched supplementary income of 12% in the form of spending on transport and hospitality industry to the state exchequer. Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams [TTD] is estimated to have a burden of INR 50-100 crores.[7] Unlike the previous exemptions allowed by the state and union in case of the Value Added Tax, GST on all goods and services is held obligatory even for charitable and religious institutions. Union Finance Minister Arun Jaitley has affirmed its obligation as immutable. TTD had challenged certain provisions of the Finance Act, 1994 in February 2014 in the Supreme Court by claiming violations of A 26 and Article 27 of the constitution. Similarly, under the same garb of doing a religious function, TTD had challenged service tax of their guest houses in 2012.[8] That writ petition was not allowed by Andhra Pradesh High Court.

The way in which the words for charitable purposes is tried to be misinterpreted is because of the vagueness which makes it difficult to be defined. The case of TTD is just one of many where multi-million business turnovers are avoiding tax under the pretext of religious purposes. There are a lot of other religious organizations which are filthy rich too and they should also be similarly dealt with.

The problems of not taxing religions are lot of unaccounted money and misuse of legal provisions to avoid taxes. There are various solutions to this like bringing these organizations completely under the ambit of RTI & ensuring that government has complete control of these institutions. Government should not interfere in the traditions and rituals but the financial aspect should be scrutinized by the government at any cost.

End-Notes
[1] http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/kerala/in-numbers-the-story-behind-sree-padmanabhaswamy-temple-vaults/article19251538.ece
[2] http://www.tirumala.org/
[3] http://m.greaterkashmir.com/news/opinion/wakf-properties-not-wakf/220402.html
[4] http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/sophie-turton/church-taxes_b_5144964.html
5 The Income-tax Act, 1961
[6] http://www.thehindu.com/business/Economy/Highlights-of-Direct-Taxes-Code-Bill/article15911527.ece
[7] http://www.tirumala.org/
[8] http://www.thehindu.com/todays-paper/tp-national/tp-andhrapradesh/High-Courts-ldquonordquo-to-writ-on-TTD/article16271421.ece

Law Article in India

Ask A Lawyers

You May Like

Legal Question & Answers



Lawyers in India - Search By City

Copyright Filing
Online Copyright Registration


LawArticles

Section 482 CrPc - Quashing Of FIR: Guid...

Titile

The Inherent power under Section 482 in The Code Of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (37th Chapter of th...

How To File For Mutual Divorce In Delhi

Titile

How To File For Mutual Divorce In Delhi Mutual Consent Divorce is the Simplest Way to Obtain a D...

Whether Caveat Application is legally pe...

Titile

Whether in a criminal proceeding a Caveat Application is legally permissible to be filed as pro...

The Factories Act,1948

Titile

There has been rise of large scale factory/ industry in India in the later half of nineteenth ce...

Constitution of India-Freedom of speech ...

Titile

Explain The Right To Freedom of Speech and Expression Under The Article 19 With The Help of Dec...

Copyright: An important element of Intel...

Titile

The Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) has its own economic value when it puts into any market ...

Lawyers Registration
Lawyers Membership - Get Clients Online


File caveat In Supreme Court Instantly