Decoding India's Labour Law Framework: A Critical Legal Analysis

Labour laws are also known as employment laws. They are the body of laws, administrative rulings, and precedents that address the legal rights and restrictions of working people and their organizations. Labour laws attempt to regulate the relationships between an employer or group of employers and their employees. This branch of law has the broadest application, as it affects more men and women than any other branch of law.

As a result of its vast implications and dynamic facets, it is also considered the most fascinating area to study. These laws generally address issues like health and safety at the workplace, collective bargaining, unfair labour practices, certification of unions, labour-management relations, general holidays, annual leave, working hours, unfair terminations, minimum wage, layoff procedures, and so on.

In India, the Central Government has promulgated around 44 labour-related statutes, 29 of which have been consolidated into four new labour codes. This article summarizes some of the labour laws in India, as well as the four labour codes.

Concept and origin of labour laws in India
In society, institutions develop to abhor the gaps that changes leave behind. The Industrial Revolution, a historical phenomenon, completely transformed society from rural and agricultural to industrial and consumerist. The changes brought by the industrial revolution had left some gaps, and it became the responsibility of society to fill those gaps. To fill those gaps, society turned to certain social devices, which are known as labour laws.

Labour laws are the result of the industrial revolution, and they were formed to address the problems caused during the industrial revolution. They are different from ordinary legislation in that they are meant to address unique issues brought on by particular situations. As a result, their orientation, philosophy, and concepts are specific rather than general.

Industrial society resulted in the over-exploitation of the working classes by employers who took advantage of the individual worker's dispensability and sought the highest profit from their investment. Due to the capitalist axiom that 'risk and right' go hand in hand, they had the authority to 'hire and fire." At that point in time, the law also included ideas such as 'Master and servant', etc., and the common law principle was in effect. The terms of contract was typically verbal and were mostly used in cases of breach. This resulted in the prosecution and imprisonment of the workers.

Over time, the scope and purpose of labour laws have evolved. Earlier, labour laws were enacted to protect the interests of employers. It was governed by the laissez-faire doctrine, which means a policy of minimal government intervention in the economic affairs of individuals and society.

On the other hand, contemporary labour law safeguards employees from the exploitation of the employer. The progressiveness of social philosophy, or the doctrine that forms the foundations for a welfare state, has made laissez-faire doctrines obsolete. Theories like "Hire and fire' as well as those of 'supply and demand', which were treated under the notion of laissez-faire, are no longer valid.

The approach to labour law and the sphere of industrial relations has changed dramatically since the Philadelphia Charter, which proclaimed "labour is not a commodity" and that "Poverty anywhere is a danger for prosperity everywhere." W. Friedmann and other scholars trying to analyze legal development in this field identify social duty on the part of government.

Evolution of labour legislation in India
The laws relating to labour in India go back 125 years with the enactment of the Apprentice Act, 1850. This Act allowed orphaned children to seek employment when they reach 18 years of age. This led to the enactment of several Acts relating to labour dealing with various aspects pertaining to industrial employment.

Labour laws not only set the standard of labour in industrial establishments but are also concerned with issues such as trade unions, payment of wages, dispute resolution mechanisms, and others. They also include within their scope the social security provisions for workers, with the Indian Constitution being considered the fundamental basis for all the labour laws. According to the Constitution, labour as a subject fall under the concurrent list and thus allows both central and state governments to enact labour laws. State
legislatures may, however, not enact laws contrary to central legislation.

Further, the Factories Act of 1881 and the Bombay Trade Disputes (and Conciliation) Act of 1934 were also enacted following the Apprentice Act of 1850. These Acts were further amended during the Second World War.

The Bombay Industrial Disputes Act, 1938, was replaced by the Bombay Industrial Relations Act, 1946. In the same year, the Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Act, 1946, was enacted by the central government. Further, the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, was subsequently amended, superseding the Trade Disputes Act, 1947, which later became the primary tool for government intervention in labour disputes. After independence, many laws relating to labour, employment, and social security were enacted. These laws are discussed in brief in the latter part of this article.

Principles of Labour Laws in India

The fundamentals of labour law establish that in a civilized society, workers have rights and responsibilities. The current labour laws of the country, as a form of social security for all citizens, provide progressive benefits like health insurance, an old-age pension, maternity benefits, gratuity payments, and others. Some of the principles of labour laws are as follows:
  • Principle of Social Justice: The basis of this principle is that all social groups must be treated equally, notwithstanding their circumstances, so that they are considered on equal terms. It seeks to eliminate social inequality because it is clear that certain groups face some form of socio-economic disadvantage in terms of employment or labour. The core purpose of this principle is to facilitate equal access for everyone, regardless of social status, to available employment opportunities.
     
  • Principle of Social Equity: In general, the principle of social equity means the creation of fair standards for everyone through statutory obligations. The fundamental idea of this principle involves the preservation of labour-friendly laws for collective social equity, as circumstances do not remain the same and change from time to time. Thus, laws should be updated regularly. Based on this principle, the government intervenes to make changes in the laws to reflect the evolving situation.
     
  • Principle of Social Security: Social security includes the overall security of the person and their family, place of employment, etc. The social security system meets basic needs and unexpected life events as a way of ensuring that people continue to have an adequate standard of living. It envisages collective action against social risks, which are at the heart of labour laws.
     
  • Principle of the National Economy: This principle states that while enacting labour laws, the overall economic situation of the country must be taken into account because the economic condition of the nation has a significant impact on labour laws in any country.
     

Factors Influencing Labour Laws in India

There are various factors that have influenced the development of labour laws. These factors are as follows:
  • Early Industrial Society of Exploitation: The labour laws in India have a long and complicated history. The roots of labour laws initially emerged as a response to the overindulgences of early industrialization following the industrial revolution. Early industrialisation was accompanied by very long working days and the hiring of young children in very unhygienic conditions, as well as low wages being paid to the workers. Legal protection was also limited for the workers. Such abuses could not have gone on forever without public protests and the call for change.
     
  • Development of Trade Unionism: The trade union movement, which emerged from the industrial revolution, was another factor that contributed to the rapid development of labour laws. They helped to protect the interests of the working class, and as a result of this, laws were enacted on wages, working conditions, women's rights, social security, and other issues. However, laws on industrial disputes, their prevention and resolution, as well as trade union privileges and rights, became inevitable due to its expansion.

Emergence of socialist and other revolutionary ideas
Through his analysis of capitalism, Karl Marx demonstrated that the economic system based on capital is innately a form of exploitation against labour. Therefore, he supported the abolition of the capitalist system.

The slogan "The workers of the world unite; you have nothing to lose but your chains" sent shivers down conservative and capitalist circles by bringing forth ameliorative as well as protective labour laws that worked very safely. Soon they realised that an application of labour laws could serve as a measure to prevent the propagation of revolutionary ideals. The trend towards progressive labour laws was bolstered by the first and second internationals, as well as socialist and communist parties established in numerous countries.
  • Establishment of the International Labour Organization (ILO)
    The establishment of the International Labour Organisation (ILO) in 1919 drastically transformed the way in which labour laws evolved across the globe. It can be read through the acceptance of the principle 'labour is not a commodity', and the slogan that 'poverty anywhere is a threat to prosperity everywhere'. Moreover, the ILO has always identified the need for better laws governing labour conditions by investigating workers' living conditions.

    It has proposed new labour laws, undergone a lot of discussion, and reviewed and adopted conventions and recommendations. In an attempt to unify labour standards as far as the conditions prevailing across the globe and the uneven development of the global economy allow, the ILO has done that singular service in the field of labour legislation.
     
  • Factors that affect labour laws in India
    All the above-mentioned factors played a significant role in formulating labour laws. India has unique characteristics that have formed its labour laws.

    They are as follows:
    • Impact of colonial rule
      The first of the early labour laws in India were enacted under pressure from Lancashire and Birmingham manufacturers. They considered the labour, which worked in factories and mills across India, to be very cheap when compared with that of their British counterparts. These laws no doubt helped Indian labour, but they were more concerned with safeguarding the interests of British capitalists. The British Civil Servants carried the democratic and pragmatic traditions of the British. The Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923; the Indian Trade Unions Act, 1926; the Payment of Wages Act, 1936; and other Acts followed the British model.
       
    • The adoption of the Indian Constitution and the struggle for national emancipation
      Indian labour laws were shaped through the adoption of the Indian Constitution as well as the struggle for national emancipation. With the backing of freedom fighters and nationalist leaders, industrial workers worked tirelessly to ensure that protective labour laws were passed. The Indian Trade Unions Act, 1926, the Royal Commission on Labor, and other statutes were framed in pursuance of their fight for freedom. The Preamble, Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles of State Policy in the Indian Constitution are all expressions of promises given by the leaders during the national movement about how a better and more sustainable social order should be established once independence is achieved.
       
  • Constitutional provisions relating to labour laws in India
    The Constitution of India is the supreme law of the land, and all laws are based on it. To this effect, the Constitution guarantees its citizens a 'Socialistic Pattern of Society' and carries on to assert that there would be the creation or formation of the welfare state. The Indian labour laws have been greatly shaped by the interpretation of the Preamble, Fundamental Rights, Directive Principles of State Policy, and judicial wisdom.
    • Seventh Schedule of the Indian Constitution
      The Seventh Schedule of the Constitution outlines the distribution of legislative powers between central and state legislatures on different matters. List III (Concurrent List) covers most of the labour-related issues. These include topics such as maternity benefits, liability of employers, workmen's compensation, invalidity, and old age pensions; social security and social insurance; employment and unemployment; labour unions; industrial and labour disputes; and provident funds. Parliament has legislated labour laws in most of these fields since the majority of issues related to labour are found on the Concurrent List.

Directive Principles of State Policy in India
The constitution emphasises the significance of socio-economic justice as a fundamental right. The framers of the Constitution thought that in a developing country like India, without economic democracy, political democracy would be meaningless, and hence they incorporated certain Articles in the Constitution to improve the socio-economic conditions of the common man. These Articles are known as the Directive Principles of State Policy (DPSP), which are provided under Part IV of the Constitution.

The main purpose of these principles is to ensure the socio-economic objectives that the government must pursue to strengthen and advance the social and economic democracy of the country. When it comes to the law relating to labour, Articles 38, 39, 41, 42, and 43 are very important as they serve as the 'Magna Carta' of industrial law.

These articles impose an obligation on the central and state governments to ensure social order and living wages as per the economic and political circumstances of the nation. It is also important to note that while DPSPs are not legally enforceable by the courts, they are still considered a fundamental part of the Constitution. They serve as the guiding principles for the government while framing policies and enacting laws that promote the welfare of the people.


Article 38 of the Indian Constitution
The concept of social justice has been provided under Article 38 of the Constitution, which states that "the state shall strive to promote the welfare of the people by securing and protecting, as effectively as it can, social order where justice, social, economic, and political, shall inform all institutions of national life."

This principle reaffirms what has been stated in the Preamble to the Constitution, i.e., that the function of the Republic is to ensure social, economic, and political justice. Further, Article 39 mandates the state to incorporate specific principles relating to social justice in its legislative process. Justice Gajendragadkar, in the case of State of Mysore v. Workers of Gold Mines, 1958, stated that "the idea of social and economic justice is a living idea of revolutionary import that upholds the rule of law and gives the welfare state ideal meaning and significance."

Article 39 of the Indian Constitution
According to the Supreme Court's interpretation of Article 39(a), the right to livelihood has been incorporated under Article 21 of the Constitution. In Olga Tellis v. Bombay Municipal Corporation (1986), the Supreme Court stated, "If the state has an obligation to secure to its citizens an adequate means of livelihood and the right to work, it would be sheer pedantry to exclude the right to livelihood from the content of the right to life."

Articles 39(b) and (c) are important constitutional provisions as they have an impact on the entire economic system of India. Socialism seeks to distribute the community's material resources in a way that promotes the welfare of all. According to Article 39(b), socialism requires distributive justice.

Article 39(d) provides for 'equal pay for equal work. Under this Article, the parliament has enacted the Equal Remuneration Act, 1976. The Act prohibits discrimination based on gender and requires that both men and women be paid equally for performing the same or similar work. The Supreme Court, in many of its decisions, has drawn the general principle of equal pay for equal work from the combined reading of Articles 14, 16, and 39(d).

The Supreme Court in Randhir Singh v. Union of India (1982), has identified that even though the idea of 'equal pay for equal work' is not a fundamental right, it is unquestionably a constitutional objective that can be upheld through constitutional remedies under Article 32 of the Constitution.

Articles 42 and 43 of the Indian Constitution
Article 42 mandates the state to make provisions relating to just and humane conditions of work and maternity relief. Article 43, on the other hand, provides for a living wage for the workers. These Articles signify a groundbreaking concept, asserting that specific benefits are inherently owed to employees as a matter of right.

In many cases, the Supreme Court has emphasized that the Constitution expresses strong concerns with respect to the welfare of workers under Articles 42 and 43. It has given a broad interpretation to Article 21, including the right to live with human dignity, by combining it with several Directive principles, including Article 42.

Fundamental Rights (Part III of the Indian Constitution)
Part III of the Constitution provides for fundamental rights. The freedoms and rights that are mentioned in Part III are intended to be protected against the arbitrary actions of the state.

Article 14 of the Indian Constitution
Article 14 states that "the State shall not deny to any person within the territory of India equality before the law or equal protection of the laws." There are two aspects of equality under Article 14, i.e., equality before the law and equal protection of the law. Equality before the law is a negative concept, and it strictly prohibits discrimination. Whereas the concept of equal protection of laws is a positive one, it states that to achieve equality among all, the state has to provide special treatment to people under certain
circumstances.

Article 16 of the Indian Constitution
Article 16 provides for equality of opportunity in matters of public employment. It states that no citizen shall be discriminated against on the grounds of religion, race, caste, sex, descent, place of birth, residence or any of them. The state, under this Article, is also empowered to make special provisions for the underprivileged classes.

Article 19 of the Indian Constitution
Article 19 provides the bundle of rights; it protects 'the right to free speech and expression, the right to peaceful assembly without arms, the right to assemble in unions or associations, the right to practice any profession, and the right to engage in any occupation, trade, or business."

Article 21 of the Indian Constitution
Article 21 protects the right to life and personal liberty of every person. The interpretation of the term 'life' by the Supreme Court has evolved significantly to include in its ambit various rights that contribute to the personal liberty of the individual. Further, the term personal liberty has been construed broadly to include a wide range of rights. These rights must adhere to a proper legal process that is fair, just, and reasonable. Thus, this broad interpretation reflects the developing notion of human rights, elaborating on significant parts of human life within the borders determined by constitutional protection.

Articles 23 and 24 of the Indian Constitution
Article 23 prohibits trafficking in human beings and forced labour. It states that trafficking in human beings, and beggar and other similar forms of forced labour is prohibited, and any contravention of this provision is punishable by law. The Supreme Court has interpreted the term life under Article 21 to include livelihood, and it has held in several cases that any employment below minimum wage levels is illegal as it amounts to slavery. Further, the employment of children below the age of 14 in any factory, mine, or other hazardous occupation is prohibited under Article 24.

Preamble of the Indian Constitution
The preamble to the constitution is another significant source of authority for the legislature to consider while enacting labour laws. It promises 'Social, economic, and political justice; liberty of thought expression, belief, faith, and worship, equality of status and opportunity'. The elaboration of the principles provided under the preamble is found in Part IV of the Constitution, i.e., Directive Principles of State Policy.

This part of the constitution states that the state is responsible for ensuring and safeguarding a social order that is characterized by justice, social equality, and political stability. These principles are intended to permeate all facets of national institutions working towards the promotion of the welfare of the people.

The promotion of the welfare of the people is addressed by some of these directives, such as minimizing inequalities, directing the policy of the state towards securing the satisfaction of certain minimum needs, the right to work, an education, public assistance in some circumstances, just and humane working conditions, maternity leave, a living wage, the participation of workers in the management of industry, providing free and mandatory education for children, and enhancing public health.

History of Labour Laws in India
Prior to India's independence, during the British colonial era, the labor laws in India were established. These laws were established by British government with a motive to safeguard the rights of the nation's employers and industrialists.

In 1883, the Factories Act was established by the British Parliament with the goal of increasing the cost of Indian labor for the advantage of British textile magnates. This Act created guidelines for ending child labor, mandating 8-hour work per day, paying overtime, and forbidding women from working at night. These provisions helped the labor market, but their true aim was to placate special interests.

Following World War I, India witnessed the international labor reform negotiations and the enactment of the Trade Union Act of 1923 and the Industrial Disputes Act of 1929. These were designed to regulate the interactions between workers and employers. They included provisions defending workers' rights to form unions in order to engage in collective bargaining and to take part in demonstrations through strikes and lockouts.

The British government established the Royal Commission on Labour in 1929, during the global economic crisis, the independence movement, and rising unemployment. The Indian labor movement was so strongly opposed to the panel that it decided to boycott it.

On the other hand, the report which was issued that enabled the passage of several labor laws between 1932 and 1937. Among them, the two significant pieces of laws were passed during this period were the Trade Disputes (Amendment) Act of 1938 and the Payment of Wages Act, 1936.

The Indian Labour Conference and the International Labour Conference also had a significant impact on labor laws. Additionally, court decisions regarding bonded labor, minimum wages, contract labor, and child labor have impacted labor laws, as have proposals from national commissions and committees like the First National Commission on Labour (1969) and the Second National Commission on Labour (2002).
Code on Wages The Code's objective is to ensure the proficient and orderly implementation of various wage-related legislations by combining and simplifying them. It combines the following actions:
  • Payment of Wages Act, 1936
  • Minimum Wages Act, 1948
  • Payment of Bonus Act, 1965
  • Equal Remuneration Act, 1976
In compliance with the updated Code, a few changes are being made. Section 6 gives the federal and state governments the authority to set minimum salaries for all employees covered by the Code. This is not the same as the 1948 Minimum Pay Act, which established a minimum pay schedule. In addition, Section 9 of the Code mandates that the central government compute floor wages while accounting for working circumstances. Minimum salaries under the federal government's minimum rates cannot be imposed by state or local governments.

Code on Industrial Relations Layoffs, strikes, relaxations, and lockouts are all covered by the industrial relations legislation. Later laws like the Industrial Disputes Act of 1947, the Trade Unions Act of 1926, and the Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Act of 1946 are also incorporated. The exceptions listed in Section 2(j) have been removed, and Section 2(p)'s industry definition has been updated. The term "industrial dispute" has been expanded under Section 2(k) to encompass worker release, discharge, removal, or termination.

Code on Social Security The Social Security Code reinstated certain statutes and provided benefits to employees. These actions consist of the following:
  • Employees Compensation Act, 1923
  • Employees Provident Fund Act, 1952
  • Employees State Insurance Act, 1948
  • Employees Exchange (Compulsory Notification Of Vacancies) Act, 1959
  • Maternity Benefit Act, 1961
  • Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972
  • Cine Workers Welfare Fund Act, 1981
  • Unorganized Workers Social Security Act, 2008
Final Takeaways
An essential foundation for regulating the intricate interactions between unions, companies, and employees is labor law. Labor law protects workers' rights and upholds fair working practices by addressing important issues such as workplace security, labor-management relations, and employment requirements. The contrast between individuals and collective labor law emphasizes how all-encompassing these laws are, including both individual worker rights and more extensive union activity.

Labor rules have historically changed dramatically between states. The Manu norms of Asia and the European medieval guilds are the origins of labor regulations. An important turning point was the industrial revolution of the eighteenth century, which made legislation necessary to combat worker exploitation and advance social fairness. Throughout the 20th century, labor laws continued to be developed and gained widespread recognition as an essential part of the contemporary industrial society.

The first labor regulations were created in India during the British colonial era to protect the interests of manufacturers and employers. Significant changes were implemented throughout time, such as the Factories Act of 1883 and other laws that were passed after World War I. Modern labor laws were largely shaped by the Indian labor movement and powerful organizations like the International Labour Conference and the Indian Labour Conference. The contemporary legal environment has also been greatly influenced by national commissions and judicial rulings.

Modernizing and streamlining labor laws is the goal of recent initiatives in India, including the Code on Wages, Code on Industrial Relations, and Code on Social Security. These regulations guarantee that workers obtain fair compensation, stable jobs, and necessary social security benefits.

They also incorporate new requirements and combine current laws.
In general, fair labor practices, the protection of worker rights, and the development of positive workplace relationships are all supported by labor legislation. As the political, social, and economic environments change, it keeps developing to make sure that everyone's rights and obligations at work are respected.

Conclusion
Labour law was developed as a result of workers' struggles for their justly deserved rights and lives throughout the world. They engaged in disputes to defend themselves and improve their living conditions. The field of labour law is dynamic and has a unique place in the legal profession. It has specific components aimed towards employees.

In some ways, India's labour laws resemble those of advanced industrial societies. Many laws govern social security, workplace health and safety, and other issues, such as minimum employment standards. However, only a small portion of India's workforce is formally.

covered by the nation's labour laws, and even among that group, the actual application of the law is very limited. The consolidation of multiple labour laws is a significant step towards making compliance easier. Because of the rationalisation of definitions and the expansion of coverage to include the unorganised sector, the benefits of the law will be available to a larger workforce.

Even though it took decades, the change should pave the way for more significant ones in the years ahead, improving India's ease of doing business, creating jobs, and influencing the country's future industrial relations.

Share this Article

You May Like

Comments

Submit Your Article



Copyright Filing
Online Copyright Registration


Popular Articles

How To File For Mutual Divorce In Delhi

Titile

How To File For Mutual Divorce In Delhi Mutual Consent Divorce is the Simplest Way to Obtain a D...

Increased Age For Girls Marriage

Titile

It is hoped that the Prohibition of Child Marriage (Amendment) Bill, 2021, which intends to inc...

Facade of Social Media

Titile

One may very easily get absorbed in the lives of others as one scrolls through a Facebook news ...

Section 482 CrPc - Quashing Of FIR: Guid...

Titile

The Inherent power under Section 482 in The Code Of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (37th Chapter of t...

Lawyers Registration
Lawyers Membership - Get Clients Online


File caveat In Supreme Court Instantly

legal service India.com - Celebrating 20 years in Service

Home | Lawyers | Events | Editorial Team | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Law Books | RSS Feeds | Contact Us

Legal Service India.com is Copyrighted under the Registrar of Copyright Act (Govt of India) © 2000-2025
ISBN No: 978-81-928510-0-6