Is A Whatsapp Group Administrator Is Liable For Any Objectionable Content Posted By Any Of The Group Member?
Whatapp has proved its relevance in decimation of information very fast. One
of unique feature of this application is that it also provides the users a right
to create a group. In that group any member can post his view. The person who
creates Whatsapp group is called administrator (admin) of the group. He may also
make other members of group as group admin. This application provides this right
to Whatsapp administrator either to add any member or remove him from a group.
The admin also has right to remove objectionable content.
Because of rapid popularity of this android application , many issues are
propping up, having legal consequences also. Many members of a whatsapp group
put objectionable contents. In such situation , if whatsapp admin does not
take any action against such offending contents , then what could be his
liability? Can he made vicariously liable for such offending content posted by a
member of group?
Recently Nagpur Bench , Mumbai High Court , while dealing with such situation,
has absolved a whatsapp group admin from criminal liability. It was a case where
a complaint was filed before before District Gondia consequent there to FIR No.
36 of 2016 was registered. The complainant filed this complainant against the
whatsapp admin namely Mr. KIshore who was resident of District Gondia. In this
case charge sheet was filed against the whatapp admin. The offences invoked
against the whatsapp Administrator were punishable under sections
354-A(1)(iv), 509 and 107 of the Indian Penal Code and section 67 of the
Information Technology Act, 2000 and also proceedings bearing Regular Criminal
Case No.177 of 2016.
The case was filed against whatsapp Administrator on the ground that accused
no.1 has used filthy language against the complainant. Grievance of the
Complainant was that the neither the group administrator removed the accused
number 1 from whatsapp group , nor asked him to submit apology to the
complainant. In such situation FIR No. 36 of 2016 was registered against
whatsapp group admin and the Investigating Agency, after completion of
investigation, filed charge-sheet before Judicial Magistrate First
Class, Arjuni-Morgaon in the afore mentioned proceeding.
Being aggrieved of framing of charge in this case, the afore mentioned whatasapp
admin filed petition under section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which
was numbered as Criminal Application (Apl) 573 of 2016 . This matter was heard
by Z.A.Haq And Amit B. Borkar, JJ., Division Bench, Nagpur Bench, Mumbai
High COurt. The title of case was Mr. Kishore Vs The State of Maharashtra and
another. This Judgment came very recently , i.e. on 01.03.2021.
The Court decided this issue that whether an administrator of Whatsapp group
can be held criminally liable for objectionable post of its member for
committing offences punishable under sections 354- A(1)(iv) , 509 and 107 of
the Indian Penal Code and section 67 of the Information Technology Act, 2000.
The Hon'ble Court discussed the nature of Whatsapp group. It observed that " A
chat group is a feature on Whatsapp which allows joint participation of members
of the chat group. Group Administrators, as they are generally called, are the
ones, who create the group by adding or deleting the members to the same. "
Now what is the function of Whatsapp administrator , the court observed as
under: "Every chat group has one or more group administrators, who control
participation of members of the group by deleting or adding members of the
group. A group administrator has limited power of removing a member of the group
or adding other members of the group. Once the group is created, the functioning
of the administrator and that of the members is at par with each other, except
the power of adding or deleting members to the group. "
The court while dealing with the right of a Whatsapp group admin , was also not
oblivion of limitation of the admin. The Hon'ble Division Bench observed as
under: "The Administrator of a Whatsapp group does not have power to regulate,
moderate or censor the content before it is posted on the group. But, if a
member of the Whatsapp group posts any content, which is actionable under law,
such person can be held liable under relevant provisions of law. In the absence
of specific penal provision creating vicarious liability, an administrator of a
Whatsapp group cannot be held liable for objectionable content posted by a
member of a group."
The Hon'ble High Court laid down certain pre condition for making a Whatsapp group
administrator to be vicariously liable for any objectionable contents posted by
any member in a group. These guidelines are " unless it is shown that there was
common intention or pre-arranged plan acting in concert pursuant to such plan by
such member of a Whatsapp group and the administrator. Common intention cannot
be established in a case of Whatsapp service user merely acting as a group
administrator. When a person creates a Whatsapp group, he cannot be expected to
presume or to have advance knowledge of the criminal acts of the member of the
After observing this the Hon'ble Court quashed the The First Information Report
No.36 of 2016 was quashed as the Court did not find any active role of Whatsapp administrator
in posting of objectionable content.
Thus a Whatsapp administrator can not be held liable for any objectionable
content posted by any of the member, until and unless it can be proved that a Whatsapp group
administrator was having pre-arranged plant in connivance with any other member
in putting the objectionable content. This Judgment has come to a great relief
to all the Whatsapp group administrator who were under the scanner of law for
objectionable contents circulated on the Whatsapp group.
Written By: Ajay Amitabh Suman - Advocate, Hon'ble High Court Of Delhi
Law Article in India
You May Like
Legal Question & Answers