In the annals of legal and medical history, few stories are as extraordinary,
tragic, and ultimately redemptive as that of Anne Greene. Her tale, which
unfolded in mid-17th century England, encapsulates a confluence of injustice,
societal cruelty, and a miraculous recovery that has baffled historians and
medical professionals alike. Anne Greene's survival after execution is not
merely a sensational account but a powerful reminder of the flaws of the
judicial system, the resilience of the human body, and the unpredictable twists
of fate.
A Life of Hardship and a Crime of Circumstance:
Born around 1628 in England, Anne Greene's life was marked by the limitations
and hardships common to women of her class and era. In 1650, she was employed as
a scullery maid in the household of Sir Thomas Read in Duns Tew, Oxfordshire.
Like many young women in domestic service, she was in a vulnerable position.
Tragically, she was raped by her employer's grandson, an act of violence which
would set in motion a series of events that led to her condemnation.
At the age of 22, Greene gave birth to a stillborn baby boy. Likely fearing
shame and punishment in a society that harshly judged unmarried mothers—let
alone domestic workers impregnated by their masters - she attempted to conceal
the baby's body. However, the infant was soon discovered. Despite medical
examiners concluding that the child was born dead, Greene was accused of
infanticide, a capital crime at the time under the "Concealment of Birth of
Bastards" Act, which presumed guilt in cases where an unwed mother failed to
properly report or explain a hidden birth.
The Execution:
Greene's trial was swift and merciless. She was found guilty of murdering her
baby and sentenced to death by hanging. On December 14, 1650, the sentence was
carried out. She was hanged in public, and in an act of compassion mingled with
desperation, her friends tugged on her body and struck her legs to hasten her
death - practices not uncommon in hangings intended to ensure a quick demise.
Believing her dead, the authorities released her body for dissection, as was
custom for executed criminals.
However, Anne Greene's fate was not sealed. The next day, three physicians at
the medical school in Oxford prepared to dissect her body. To their
astonishment, they discovered that she had a faint pulse and shallow breathing.
She was still alive.
The Revival:
What followed was an extraordinary medical effort to save someone who, by law
and societal consensus, had been declared dead. The doctors immediately set to
work reviving Greene, utilizing then-common medical techniques. Among the
methods were bloodletting and the administration of a tobacco-smoke enema - a
practice thought to stimulate respiration and circulation. To modern readers,
these methods may sound bizarre or archaic, but they were standard for the
period and, in Greene's case, surprisingly effective.
Over the next two weeks, Anne Greene made a remarkable recovery. She regained
full consciousness and her strength gradually returned. News of her survival
spread rapidly, and public fascination turned her into a living miracle. Some
viewed her resurrection as divine intervention, a sign of her innocence or at
least an indication that justice had erred in her case.
Pardon and New Life:
In light of her survival, and perhaps spurred by the public sentiment
surrounding the event, Anne Greene was granted a full pardon. The pardon was
more than a legal technicality - it was a rare recognition that an injustice had
been committed. She was not returned to prison, nor was she tried again.
Instead, she was allowed to rebuild her life.
Anne Greene eventually married and went on to have three children. Her life
after the execution was reportedly peaceful and stable. She lived for another
fifteen years, passing away in 1665.
The Legal and Social Context:
Anne Greene's story cannot be separated from the legal and social context of
17th-century England. The law under which she was condemned—the aforementioned
Act regarding the concealment of birth - was one of many that disproportionately
targeted women, especially the poor and unmarried. The presumption that a
concealed birth was evidence of murder placed the burden of proof heavily on
women, making justice nearly impossible in such cases.
Her case also illuminates the dangers of limited forensic knowledge. Though the
examiners at the time declared the baby stillborn, the weight of societal
judgment overrode scientific findings. Greene's ordeal reminds us of the
historical use of legal systems to enforce social morality, often at the expense
of truth and justice.
Medical Significance:
From a medical perspective, Greene's survival is a fascinating case study.
Hanging as a method of execution was not always immediately fatal, especially in
cases where the drop was short, as was often the case during that period. In
Greene's case, it is possible that the hanging was improperly conducted or that
her physiological response was unusually resilient. Cases of survival from
hanging, though rare, have been documented in various historical and modern
contexts.
Moreover, the rudimentary revival techniques employed - particularly the tobacco
smoke enema - while seemingly outdated or primitive, may have played a genuine
role in stimulating her recovery. This aspect of her story has drawn attention
from medical historians who study the evolution of resuscitation practices.
Legacy and Reflection:
Anne Greene's story has persisted through the centuries as an example of
miraculous survival and legal redemption. It has inspired historical studies,
fictional retellings, and academic debates about justice, gender, and medicine.
Her experience serves as a cautionary tale about the fallibility of the justice
system and the importance of scientific rigor in legal proceedings.
In a broader sense, Anne Greene's resurrection is symbolic. It represents not
only a literal return from the brink of death but also a metaphorical rebirth
into a society that had discarded her. While her story began in violence,
exploitation, and injustice, it ended in survival, vindication, and new
beginnings.
Conclusion:
The resurrection of Anne Greene is more than a curious footnote in history; it
is a narrative of resilience against the odds, of a flawed justice system
encountering an unexpected challenge, and of early medicine stumbling into
miraculous success. Her ordeal offers a deeply human story of tragedy, survival,
and the hope of renewal. In remembering Anne Greene, we are reminded of how far
we have come - and how far we must still go - to ensure that justice,
compassion, and truth prevail in our societies.
Reference:
- The True Crime File – Kim Daly.
Written By: Md.Imran Wahab, IPS, IGP, Provisioning, West Bengal
Email: imranwahab216@gmail.com, Ph no: 9836576565
Comments