File Copyright Online - File mutual Divorce in Delhi - Online Legal Advice - Lawyers in India

Forensic Odontology: Role in Police Investigation & Identification

Forensic odontology falls under the realm of forensic science, a specialized field that uncovers the identity of individuals through their dental records. The discipline delves into the scrutiny of dental remnants - chiefly teeth and records - in aid to criminal investigations and judicial matters. Experts in forensic odontology draw from their knowledge in dental anatomy, pathology, and radiography when called upon to identify victims of accidents or mass disasters (or even where traditional means are not applicable). Their role does not stop there: they also play an instrumental part in cases involving bite marks, which can tie suspects to crime scenes or absolve innocents from false accusations.

Throughout history, teeth have served as unique identifiers: Nero, the Roman emperor, recognized his mother Agrippina whom he had murdered in 59 CE by her teeth. Similarly, William the Conqueror used to seal his letters with wax imprints using his irregular teeth marks to verify their sender. The first documented case of dental identification was for John Talbot, Earl of Shrewsbury, who died during the battle of Castillon in 1453 - a report that marked this historic milestone.

Ten months after the burial of American patriot Paul Revere's friend Dr Joseph Warren (a victim from the 1775 Battle of Bunker Hill), Revere was able to identify him easily since he had crafted dentures for Warren - another noteworthy case.

In 1865 there was an instance where John Wilkes Booth (President Abraham Lincoln's assassin) was identified through dental means - recording yet another significant event via this methodology which has been prominent throughout various points across time and space.

Identification of the first fire victims killed in 1849 was carried out at Vienna Opera House, using teeth. This was followed by 126 rich Parisians who lost their lives in a charity bazaar fire in 1897 and again dental records came into play.

Forensic odontology is the convergence of three disciplines - anatomy, pathology, and radiography - in the study of dental remains as means for identification and investigative ends. The knowledge of dental structures and variations among individuals that we draw from anatomy enables us to have a distinct footing on what we are looking at. From pathology we gather information regarding any disease or trauma that may have affected the teeth - which would serve well in identification or even go so far as to hint at the individual's medical history. On the other hand, radiography (inclusive of X-rays and other imaging techniques) allows us to closely inspect these abnormalities in dental structures through which their uniqueness can be identified.

These findings from each field work together cohesively within forensic odontology; helping provide valuable inputs by experts into legal investigations where they are needed or even victim identification processes when those come up later on down line too.

The main use of forensic odontology lies in the ability to identify human remains through unique traits found in individuals' teeth. This field holds great importance in disaster victim identification, particularly in situations where severely mutilated bodies are found due to events like tsunamis or bomb blasts. These incidents typically result in high numbers of casualties with little chance for immediate recognition based on physical features. The process is referred to as Disaster Victim Identification (DVI). Teeth are the strongest part of the human body - they can survive high impact explosions unscathed - meaning they can be easily recovered even in mass fatality incidents where other identifying factors are destroyed.

The adult human dentition consists of incisors, canines, premolars and molars that are unique in shape, size and spacing within each individual. The arrangement of these teeth in every oral cavity is distinctively individualized while each tooth also possesses its own set of unique characteristics known as 'tooth class characteristics' - serving as identification markers. Other features that aid in identification include dental pathology, restorations, anomalies or any other peculiarities which can be used to establish the identity of a person; age, sex, race/ethnicity occupational habits can all be determined from an individual's teeth.

The uniqueness of tooth impressions for each individual is based on various factors such as chips, fillings, misalignments and missing teeth. Dentists make it a routine to take note of the surfaces of all 32 adult teeth for every patient. Despite the technological advancements in DNA analysis which is expensive and time-consuming (weeks or months), obtaining dental records remains the primary means of identification when fingerprints are not available. However, entering dental records onto a computerized database is much cheaper - making it an attractive option for maintaining easy access to this information.

When identifying victims of crime through dental examination, X-rays can be taken at the crime scene using portable equipment - allowing forensic odontologists to compare different areas like tooth numbers or specific details on them. In addition, materials and methods used in dental work can give clues about origin countries due to varying practices.

While dental records are generally reliable due to the durability of teeth, there are limitations with this method of identification. In certain situations, investigators only have access to partial or even zero dental records, or they may not be able to recover all teeth and their corresponding restorations. Surprisingly, even the enhancement of dental health through widespread fluoridation acts as a negative factor for identification since it reduces cavity formation: meaning fewer people have restorations. Moreover, laws in some countries - like the United States - have regulations that protect medical records which could impede an investigation slightly.

Burned Beyond Recognition: Identification Through Dental remains
The phrase "burned beyond recognition" is used when a person's body cannot be identified due to being consumed by fire. Nevertheless, forensic investigators are able to make identifications through the dental remains that they recover. Forensic odontologists - who specialize in reading dental remains or DNA - need to come up with identification techniques that do not compromise the integrity of these remains. They struggle to work with these delicate remnants because most soft tissues turn into charred structures (which are difficult to handle) upon burning.

Charred teeth are delicate constructs that disintegrate easily if not gingerly handled. Typically, they require a strong force to break - often leading to complete destruction of the dental remains. An effective way to gauge fragility is by observing colour: ashen grey teeth tend to be more brittle compared to blackened ones. The anterior surface enamel on these particular teeth is prone to easy cracking as they are most exposed to fire.

It is vital to document all pertinent information before the tooth succumbs to inevitable fragmentation. Once a tooth shatters into pieces, accurate reconstruction for identification purposes becomes nearly unattainable. This includes obtaining radiographs, impressions or photographs - all potential postmortem evidence sources. A systematic preservation approach of charred dental remnants plays a critical role in successful identification process of burnt individuals; such information must be recorded without any delay as it may disappear during the further manipulation with tooth material.

Evidentiary Value of Odontologist Report:
Dentists specializing in various fields are called upon to provide their expert opinion on cases related to identification of individuals through oral and dental structures, as well as injuries. The scope of person identification can involve individuals who are alive or deceased, healthy or injured, as well as those who are skeletonized or mummified. Dentists also play a role in crime scene investigations, mass disaster victim identifications, and determining cases of professional negligence or injury. A report is drawn up based on the findings from the dental evidence available to be presented during deposition testimony by a dental surgeon acting as a forensic expert in medico-legal issues.

The determination of whether a forensic odontologist's report can be presented in court as admissible evidence is influenced by several elements. These consist of the laws governing the jurisdiction, the validity and value of the report with respect to its applicability, as well as whether the odontologist qualifies to testify on certain specific grounds related to his or her expert status.

An odontologist's expert testimony can be admitted in many legal systems if the court finds the expert qualified to opine on the matter at hand. This usually entails an evaluation of the expert's education, training, experience and competence in the relevant field.

Aside from those considerations, other matters of import include the reliability and relevance of the odontologist's report. It must be rooted in valid scientific principles and methods that draw logical conclusions based on substantiated evidence - such a report will only hold weight if it pertains directly to the issues under litigation.

In the end, it is up to the judge to decide whether or not an odontologist's report can be taken into evidence. The judge will need to see if there is any value in the report as a piece of evidence that outweighs any possible harm it could cause, should the report not meet such standards. Should the judge find that the report meets all requirements set by law, then it can indeed be considered as evidence and taken into account during trial. All things considered, it is the judge who ultimately decides on what basis he/she makes this decision.

Written By: Md.Imran Wahab, IPS, IGP, Provisioning, West Bengal
Email: [email protected], Ph no: 9836576565

Law Article in India

Ask A Lawyers

You May Like

Legal Question & Answers

Lawyers in India - Search By City

Copyright Filing
Online Copyright Registration


How To File For Mutual Divorce In Delhi


How To File For Mutual Divorce In Delhi Mutual Consent Divorce is the Simplest Way to Obtain a D...

Increased Age For Girls Marriage


It is hoped that the Prohibition of Child Marriage (Amendment) Bill, 2021, which intends to inc...

Facade of Social Media


One may very easily get absorbed in the lives of others as one scrolls through a Facebook news ...

Section 482 CrPc - Quashing Of FIR: Guid...


The Inherent power under Section 482 in The Code Of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (37th Chapter of t...

The Uniform Civil Code (UCC) in India: A...


The Uniform Civil Code (UCC) is a concept that proposes the unification of personal laws across...

Role Of Artificial Intelligence In Legal...


Artificial intelligence (AI) is revolutionizing various sectors of the economy, and the legal i...

Lawyers Registration
Lawyers Membership - Get Clients Online

File caveat In Supreme Court Instantly