lawyers in India

Legal Rights of Street Traders in India - Hawkers

Written by: Neethu Ravikmar. Law Student of fourth year from Nuals Cochin
Environmental law
Legal Service India.com
  • In this paper, Hawkers and Vendors have similar meaning and they are often swapped. Though Hawking is a street trade done by moving from one place to another while Vending is another street trade that is done by occupying a space on pavements i.e. temporary shelters.

    Hawking (Vending) means the act of selling of goods for a living. It is one of the oldest occupation in India and by virtue of Article 19(1)(g) every citizen has a right to carry on any lawful trade or business. It is this right vested in the citizens that the hawkers exercise while engaging themselves in the trade. The right to carry on trade is a fundamental right of the vendors and hawkers but it doesn't mean that street trading is a right as such without any restrictions. Hawkers cannot be permitted to carry on their trade on every road in the city. Hawking is not permitted in those areas where road is not wide enough to accommodate traffic.

    Hawking Zone

    Marking of Hawking zone is necessary because it constitute a serious obstruction to the public and creates traffic problems. State and the Municipality got the right to designate and allocate the places from where street trading can be done. Hawker doesn't have the right to earmark the place to trade. In Bombay Hawker Union vs. Bombay Municipal Corporation, the Court held that The Non-Hawking Zones maybe fixed by the Municipal Commissioner in his discretion, in consultation with the Bombay Municipal Corporation. In areas other than the Non-Hawking Zones, licenses should be granted to the hawkers to do their business on payment of the prescribed fee. That will be without prejudice to the right of the Commissioner to extend the limits of the Non-Hawking Zones in the interests of public health, sanitation, safety, public convenience and the like. Further the Court observed that, Hawking licenses should not be refused in the Hawking Zones except for good reasons. The discretion not to grant a hawking license in the Hawking Zone should be exercised by the Commissioner reasonably and in public interest.

    Hawking is prohibited near hospitals or where necessity of security measures so demand. If the roads are not wide enough to manage traffic on it, then hawking may not be permitted in those areas. In Maharashtra Ekta Hawkers Union vs. Municipal Corporation, Greater, Court held that they should not hawk within 100 meters from any place of worship, holy shrine, educational institution and general hospital and within the periphery of 150 meters from any Municipal or other market.

    Legal Provisions under Constitution

    Preamble of Indian Constitution states that India shall secure to its citizens justice, social, economic and political and equality of status and of opportunity. Article 14 of the Constitution deals with equality before law. Even the vendors got right just like any other persons and they will be protected by the law of the country without any discrimination.

    Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution guarantees to every citizen the right to practice any profession or to carry on any occupation, trade or business. Likewise, hawkers have the fundamental right to carry on trade or business of their choice. But it is subjected to reasonable restriction imposable under Article 19(6) of Indian Constitution. The court must balance freedom of trade under Article 19(1)(g) and freedom of inter-State trade and commerce under Article 301against the national interest. In South Calcutta Hawkers, Association vs. Govt. of West Bengal, the court observed that " Street trading being a fundamental right has to be made available to the citizens but subject to Art. 19(6) of the Constitution. It is within the domain of the State to make any law imposing reasonable restrictions in the interest of general public on such right." The court also observed that proper regulation is essential condition as otherwise the very object of laying out roads to facilitate traffic may be defeated.

    The right to life includes protection of means of livelihood. Forcible eviction of hawkers without prior notice is infringement of Article 21 of the Constitution. In Olga Tellis & Ors vs. Bombay Municipal Council, the court observed that "no person can live without the means of living, that is the means of livelihood. If, the right to livelihood is not treated as a part of constitutional right to life, the easiest way of depriving a person of his right to life would be to deprive him of his means of his livelihood to the point of abrogation." Performance of public act must be fair and reasonable. So before eviction of the hawkers from the area, they must be served with notice so that their right is not infringed.

    Other Important Acts

    Section 201 of Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 penalizes anyone who obstruct the flow of traffic on the public highway. It is specially designed for avoiding unnecessary traffic block and is applicable to both motorised and non-motorised vehicles.

    Section 151 of the Criminal Procedure Code,1973 permits the arrest of anyone about to commit any cognizable offence without orders from a Magistrate and without a warrant, however, the person cannot be detained in the police custody for more than 24 hours from the time of his/ her arrest.

    National Policy on Urban Street Vendors 2009

    National Policy on Urban Street Vendors 2009 was a second revised policy of the Bellagio International Declaration of Street Vendors, 1995. It was approved by the UPA government, which recognises street vendors as an integral and legitimate part of the urban retail trade and distribution system. Bellagio Declaration covers importance of vending license, planning of hawking zones and other related matters but even after a decade, still in India, vending is not legalized. National Policy on Urban Street Vendors was adopted earlier in 2004 with the object of providing and promoting a supportive environment for the street vendors to earn a livelihood while avoiding the congestion on the street so that pedestrians can move freely on road. In Kerala, this policy was adopted in the year 2011 but state level survey and fixing of vending zone is pending. National Policy on Urban Street Vendors, 2009 is an advanced one.

    According to the plan of National Policy on Urban Street Vendors 2009, each vendors will be allowed to carry on business for 20 years. This policy also concern about access to credit, skill development, housing, social security and capacity building for street vendors. Registration of vending business is the main aim to facilitate the smooth flow and Town Vending Committee will collect the registration fee which is minimal and will also charge for monthly maintenance charge. TVC will issue registration certificates and identify trespassers to ensure that legalized vending business is legitimate. One of the motive is to avoid traffic congestion by fixing vending zone and no-vending zone.

    Licensing

    The idea of licensing came up to prevent illegitimate business which run in the name of street vending. It also aims at protection of hawkers from the harassment of police and other influential persons. It would serve the purpose of identification of vendors in the area so as to maintain the space management and it also helps in registration.

    Licensing also makes the vending business of a person legal and the authorities can keep record of the business of each vendors. Census can be made easier when the records are correct. The idea of licensing pop up from the National Policy on Urban Street Vendors and it made the problems to be tackled easily such as allocation of space in pavement for trading, legitimate tax collection on monthly basis, etc. No hawking license shall be issued in non-vending areas. The license will be only issued after the survey and registration fees will be notified by the authority.

    National Association of Street Vendors of India (NASVI)

    This was registered in the year 2003 under the Societies registration Act of 1860 and it aims to organize and protect the street vendors. It is a National federation of street vendor organisations. Its secretariat is in Patna. They have conducted many surveys in many cities to study about the vendor's problem and also other related matters. Their main aim is tackle the problems faced by the hawkers.

    Conclusion
    Though there is no separate act governing Hawkers, Supreme Court of India directed Delhi Government to enact a law to regulate hawker's rights which often contradict with commuter's right to road and street. Justice Ganguly, in his judgement said "This court is giving this direction in exercise of its jurisdiction to protect the fundamental right of the citizens. The hawkers and squatters or vendors' right to carry on hawking has been recognised as a fundamental right under Article 19 (1) (g) of the Constitution. At the same time, the right of the commuters to move freely and use the roads without any impediment is also a fundamental right under Article 19 (1) (d)."

    Reference
    # Reports on Street Vendors by NASVI
    # Street Vendors in the Global Urban Economy, Sharit Bhowmik, Indian Journal of Human Development, Volume 5, Number 1.
    # see http://www.greaterkashmir.com/news/2011/aug/16/a-case-for-regulating-hawking-11.asp
    # (1985)3 SCC 528
    # AIR 2004 SC 416, JT 2003 (10) SC 1, 2004 (3) MhLj 437
    # AIR 1986 SC 180, quoted in AIR 1987 Ori 189 at 190.

    The author can be reached at: [email protected] / Print This Article

    Related Articles:
    Company as State under Article 12 of Constitution of India
    one Person Company Concept
    Oppression and Mismanagement
    Freedom of Trade and Commerce
    Trips and Right To Health
    FDI policy, April 2010 - An Analysis
    Corporate Personality
    Foreign Direct Investment in Real Estate Business
    Remuneration of Directors
    Limited Liability Partnership in India
    Anti Competitive Practices in India
    Controversial IPL 2010: Sweatly Bid Rigged?
    ADR Mechanism in India
    Passing off and the Concept of Goodwill
    Why Mergers and Acquisitions fail?
    Is your company's name legal?
    Negotiation-Mode of Alternative Dispute Resolution
    SEZ Act 2005
    Globalization
    Underwriting contract at the time of issue of securities
    Position of Directors In A Company
    Limited Liability Partnership
    Reconstruction and Amalgamation
    Financial Markets
    Merging a company
    Partners under Limited liability partnership Act 2008
    Incorporation of Company
    Indian Corporate Law
    Demerger under Company Law
    Which employees do not fall under the ambit of Industrial Dispute Act, 1947
    special Economic Zones Act, 2005
    Understanding the Concept of Corporate Governance in the Light of Companies Bill 2009
    Prevention of oppression and mismanagement
    Corporate Criminal Liability - Doctrine of Identification
    Mergers and Acquisitions and the IPR Issues Involved
    Easy Exist Scheme 2011
    Importance of meetings
    Directors and Their Liabilities
    Challenges Faced by Power Purchase Agreement
    Competition and Corporate Governance
    Corporate Social Responsibility
    Corporate Lobbying: Do We Need a Law to Regulate Whistle Blowing?
    Judicial Accountability of Grameen Banks
    Is Capitalism dead
    Micro Finance and The Indian Economy
    Laws Relating to Mines and Minerals in India
    Liberalisation of the Law relating to Foreign Institutional Investment and its Impact on Economic Development
    Anti Dilution Protection
    Forming of Company In India
    SEBI: Consent Orders and Compounding of offences
    The Employees Deposit-linked Insurance Fund Scheme
    Abuse o Dominant Position
    Corporate Social Responsibility
    MAT
    Infrastructure Project Financing
    Sterlite Industries Ltd's Buyout of Asarco LLC
    Mergers and Acquisitions in Aviation Sector
    FDI Retail in India: A Critical View
    So you think 433 (e) of the Companies Act,1956 can be taken for a ride?
    Retrenchment under Industrial Dispute Act, 1947
    Needs of Corporate Governance
    Mergers and Acquisitions in Aviation Sector
    Unit-Linked Insurance Plans - An Indian Perspective
    The Art of Giving - Corporate Social Responsibility in India
    Improvements to mortgaged property
    Implications to Securitization Act
    Clause 49 of the Listing Agreement
    New Lease of Life to Corporate Entity-Mergers And Acquisitions
    Cross Border Mergers: Implications under the Competition Act, 2002
    Independence of Independent Directors in India
    Corporate social responsibility
    Foreign Direct Investment: A general understandng
    Globalization and its impact on Indian Economy: Developments and Challenges
    Mergers and Acquisitions for firms
    Liberalisation of Indian Banking and Regulation
    Role of Central Government in Mergers and Amalgamations
    Non Performing Assets in PSB's
    Land Acquisition for SEZ
    Articles of Association and Alteration of Articles
    Dissolution of partnership firm
    Section 25 Companies
    Foreign Venture Capital Investment In India
    Company: Meaning and Interpretation under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894
    TRAI - A Legal Analysis
    The Doctrine of Promissory Estoppel
    Public Policy under Arbitration Law
    Procedure for Establishment of a LLP
    Project Finance
    Legal provisions regarding setting up base by foreign universities in India and related issues
    Understanding Derivatives
    ISDA Master Agreement
    Winding Up of a Company
    Meeting of Creditors
    Pros and Cons of Linking Trade and Labor Standards
    Winding Up of Banking Company
    Director
    General Format of the Joint Venture Agreement
    Guidelines on Fair Practices Code For HFCs
    Insider trading laws in India
    Reconstruction and Amalgamation
    Reservation For Women In The Board of Directors
    Government Companies
    Implementation of Corporate E-Governance: Implementation of MCA 21 Model
    Companies Act 1956 and Company Bill 2011
    FDI in Retail Sector
    changes in the national and international corporate environment
    Appointment, Disqualification And Liabilities of Directors of A Company: A Legal Perspective
    Squeeze out of minority shareholders
    IPO Scam: With Special Referance To NSDL V. SEBI Case
    Minority Rights on Oppression and Mismanagement Under Companies Act, 1956 And Companies Bill, 2011
    Manufacturers Liability, Case Developments in UK, USA and India
    IT Sectors Corporate Social Responsibility towards Public Infrastructre in India
    Mergers and Acquisitions
    Can mere fine compensate the wrongs done under the name of Corporations
    How Mediation Can Benefit The Business Community
    VTB Capital PLC V. Nutritek International Corp and Ors
    Duel Listing of Companies
    Corporate Social Responsibility
    Equidistance and Equitable Principle under the law of the Sea
    CSR under the Companies Act 2013
    Has Companies Act, 2013 really enhanced position of women in corporate world?
    Appointment of Woman Director
    one Person Company
    Buying a new company points to be considered
    Business structures available for a start up
    Merger and Acquisition in the Information Technology Industry
    Exceptions of agreement in restraints of trade with reference to Indian and English case laws
    one Person Company under Companies Act 2013
    Corporate Social Responsibility And Sustainable Development
    Damages Under Indemnity
    The need for women directors in Indian companies
    Position of a promoter in establishing a Company
    Company Law Articles
    Cross Border Mergers and Takeovers
    Efficacy of Present Legal Framework In Combating Transgression By Transnational Corporation
    Lifting of Corporate Veil: Indian Scenario
    Steps to be followed for the Incorporation of Company in India
    Killer Provsions of The Companies Act, 2013
    Business Ethics and Corporate Frauds
    Corporate Social Responsibility
    The Role of Securities and Exchange Board of India in Regulating the Primary Market for Securities
    Obligations under GATT and GATS
    Establishment of Foreign Entity in India
    Role of Securities Exchange Board of India
    Need For Corporate Social Responsibility
    The Corporate as a Criminal
    Trade, Commerce and Intercourse
    Corporate Renaissance
    Voluntary winding-up of the Company by Members
    Fast Track Exit
    Doctrine of Alter Ego and Attribution
    Distribution arrangement, whether it creates a permanent establishment
    Corporate Criminal Liability: A Jurisprudential and Comparative Approach
    one Person Company
    Incorporation of A Private limited Company Under Companies Act 2013
    Competition Law and Role of merger
    Incorporation of A Public limited Company
    Various Committees and provisions under Companies Act, 2013
    Winding up of a Private Limited Company under Companies Act, 2013
    Corporate Social Responsibility
    Fast Track mergers
    Need For Corporate Social Responsibility
    Role of Proxy Advisory Firms In Corporate Governance
    Distinction between Companies Act 1956 and Companies Act 2013
    Articles of Association
    Banking Ombudsman Scheme 2006
    one Person Company
    Principle of Lifting the Corporate Veil
    Appointment of a director other than a retiring director in the General Meeting
    Payment of compensation for loss of office of MD or WTD or Manager
    one person company
    Holding first Meeting of Board of Directors of a Company Under Companies Act 2013
    Procedure for declaration and payment of interim dividend by the board of directors
    Risk Management and Corporate Management
    How to convert one Person Company to Private Limited Company
    Corporate Governance
    Corporate Governance for a changing world
    Insider Trading laws in India in comparison with the laws in US and UK
    Applicability of Limitation act on Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code
    Government decides to strike off 1.2 lakh more companies again

    How To Submit Your Article:

    Follow the Procedure Below To Submit Your Articles

    Submit your Article by using our online form Click here
    Note* we only accept Original Articles, we will not accept Articles Already Published in other websites.
    For Further Details Contact: [email protected]


    Divorce by Mutual Consent in Delhi/NCR

    Mutual DivorceRight Away Call us at Ph no: 9650499965

    File Your Copyright - Right Now!

    Copyright Registration
    Online Copyright Registration in India
    Call us at: 9891244487 / or email at: [email protected]