lawyers in India

YouTube case

Written by: Priyanka Mukherjee and Shachi Punani - Legal Professional and Law Student respectively
Constitutional Lawyers in India
Legal Service
  • The Delhi High Court recently passed an order of interim injunction against YouTube and its parent company Google against the business practice of Youtube of earning profits at the expense of a rightful copyright owner. YouTube is facing quite a few legal battles for its business plan for copyright infringement. The recent being a suit filed by T-series in the Delhi High Court. The Delhi High Court issued notice and summons against YouTube and Google, Inc and passed an interim order restraining them from reproducing, adapting, distributing, communicating, transmitting, disseminating or displaying on their websites or otherwise infringing in any manner any audio visual works in which the Super Cassettes Industries (hereinafter referred as SCIL) owns exclusive, valid and subsisting copyright.

    The business model of YouTube allows, encourages and profits from use of copyrighted work uploaded on the website without obtaining any license or permission from the rightful copyright owners and without paying them any royalty. The profits from this business model, which is based on copyright infringement, are enormous.

    The arguments on the basis of which the injunction order was passed were:

    YouTube and Google profit at SCIL's expense by showing SCIL's songs for free to the public, while displaying advertising on the screen and collecting revenue from the advertisers based on the number of hits on the site.

    SCIL's revenue comes from manufacturing and selling DVDs, CDs and audio cassettes of its copyrighted music and from royalties collected by licensing the copyrighted music to hotels, restaurants, television companies, radio stations, telecom operators and internet websites. YouTube LLC and its parent, Google Inc., have on their website been showing videos of SCIL's copyrighted songs without SCIL's license or permission.

    It will be interesting to see what defense YouTube takes when the case comes up for hearing in February next year.

    The grounds which might be highlighted by YouTube to avoid copyright infringement during the hearing are as follows:

    # Whenever a user uploads any videos on YouTube the following message appears to avoid copyright infringement “Do not upload any TV shows, music videos, music concerts, or commercials without permission unless they consist entirely of content you created yourself. Please refer to our Copyright Tips page for some guidelines and links to help you determine whether your video infringes someone else's copyright.”

    # Moreover nearly 3, 00,000 to 5, 00,000 videos are uploaded daily on YouTube. Giving regard to the number of videos that are being uploaded everyday it is not technically possible for the website to make such filters that would restrict uploading of copyright protected material.

    However the other side of the story is that, Google has in the past objected to provisions in India's Information Technology Act 2000 which make intermediaries such as ISPs (Internet service providers), website hosting companies, search engines, e-mail services, and social networks, liable for their users' content.
    Ironically, many other Internet operations such as MySpace, TorrentSpy, DailyMotion and have set up filtering systems to block copyrighted material. Google is a $158 Billion company with arguably the most advanced search technology in the world. The argument that they cannot block pirated content because of technological or financial reasons is laughable.

    With the passing of this restraining order, the onus appears to now be on Google and YouTube to prevent users from uploading T-Series content. The other thing is - if this becomes a permanent injunction, then it sets a precedent in India which will impact other videosharing sites, including Rediff's. We need to wait and watch for the decision of the Delhi High Court as its decision might change the total scenario of IP Law.

    The author can be reached at: [email protected] / Print This Article

    Related Articles
    Cyber Crimes and General Principles
    Cyber Squatting- Clear and Present Danger
    Cyber Crime And Law
    Cyber Hacking
    Electronic Contract
    The Bpo Strategy
    Need For Conversion Of The Convergence Bill
    Data Safety And Privacy Protection
    The Menace of Cyber Crime
    Defamation on the web: Who do you sue?
    Internet telephony and related Issues

    How To Submit Your Article:

    Follow the Procedure Below To Submit Your Articles

    Submit your Article by using our online form Click here
    Note* we only accept Original Articles, we will not accept Articles Already Published in other websites.
    For Further Details Contact: [email protected]

    Divorce by Mutual Consent in Delhi/NCR

    Mutual DivorceRight Away Call us at Ph no: 9650499965

    File Your Copyright - Right Now!

    Copyright Registration
    Online Copyright Registration in India
    Call us at: 9891244487 / or email at: [email protected]