lawyers in India

Copyright Infringement in Cyberspace and Network Security - A Threat To E-Commerce

Written by: Tabrez Ahmad - Associate Professor of Law, KIIT Law School, KIIT University
Constitutional Lawyers in India
Legal Service
  • Information Technology is growing faster than any other communication vehicle in the history mankind.[1] Invention of digital technology was the most important revolution in the last century. The influence of digital technology on information technology is phenomenal. The present millennium is witnessing a new culture that is internet culture. It is changing our life style and way of doing business form traditional commerce to e-commerce. Originally confined to military establishment internet[2] has due to its speed, intercreativity and flexibility, tremendous potential to disseminated information beyond the geographical boundaries. Today the internet is not only used for educational purposes but also for business.

    The availability of radio, telephone, television and computer made it possible to carry out most of the business activities on-line, through the information technology and communication network. The government of India by passing IT (Information Technology) Act 2000 and further amending it on 27th October 2009 has given fillip to cyber law. But various issues are not specifically covered by the Act, such as copyright, payment issues, media convergence, domain name, cybersquating and jurisdiction. While these have wide ranging ramifications for the growth of e-commerce of India.

    The continued rapid evolution of a number key technologies and convergence of broadcasting media, communication media, home electronics, and publishing on computers creating a lot of legal issues. Today computer has made television, fax and telephone redundant. The threat posed by computer is well depicted in the figure below 6. Thus important attributes like data text images and voice are combined by the computers in the form of multimedia which raise the issue of neighboring rights.

    As technology creates new opportunities it also poses new challenges. Copyright is most complicated area of cyberlaw and facing greatest challenge.
    According to copyright act 1957, copyright is a negative[3] monopoly right which enables author of the work to prevent others to exercise that right which has been conferred on him. What an author creates he is an exclusive owner of that. The precise text to determine whether a person is entitled to copyright is to ascertain whether “skill, judgment and experience or labour, and capital has been expended in creating the work[4].

    Copyright law today protects works such as literary, dramatic and artistic works; cinematography films; sound recording and computer programmes, data bases and compilations.

    Any original work would exclusively belong to the owner of the copyright and any action with respect to the work done by any person without the owner’s permission or consent would amount to infringement.

    Nature of Copyright Infringement In Internet

    With the mergence of the internet and increasing use of the worldwide web possibilities of infringement of copyright have become mind boggling free and easy access on the web together with possibilities of down loading has created new issued in copyright infringement. Taking content from one site, modifying it or just reproducing it on another site has been made possible by digital technology and this has posed new challenges for the traditional interpretation of individual rights and protection. Any person with a PC (Personal Computers) and a modem can become a publisher. Downloading, uploading saving transforming or crating a derivative work is just a mouse click away.

    A web page is not much different than a book a magazine or a multimedia CD-Rom and will be eligible for copyright protection, as it contains text graphics and even audio and videos.

    Copyright law grants the owner exclusive right to authorize reproduction of the copy righted works preparation of derivative works, distribution etc. However application of this concept on the internet cannot be strictly applied to copyright. Duplication of the information is an essential step in the transmission of information on the internet and even plain browsing information at a computer terminal (which is equivalent to reading a book or a magazine at book store) may result in the creation of an unauthorized copy since a temporary copy of the work is created in the RAM of the users computer for the purpose of access. The law on the subject evolving and the general view is that more accessing a web page would not be an infringement as the copy created is temporary or ephemeral. Another common issue amongst web site owners is to create links to other sites within the design of their own web pages. Would such linking be considered a copy right violation as these links give access to other copy righted sites? Although strictly speaking it may be a violation of copyright. But there is an implied doctrine of public access for linking to other web pages. The Internet was created on the basic of being able to attach hypertext links to any other location and it is assumed that once a page is put on the net, implied consent is given, unless specifically prohibited by the web site owner.

    Computer Software And Internet Piracy

    Software is defined as a set of instructions which when incorporated in a machine readable form or in capable of causing a computer to perform a particular task. To put it simply, it is a series of commands which can be understood by the machine.

    There are three essential types of software which help to function the computer, micro code it is a programme which controls the details of execution, the operating system software which control the sources of a computer and manages routine tasks and is a necessary requirement for a computer to function and the third is a application software which is designed to perform a particular task.

    Piracy occurs when copyrighted software is made available to users to download without the express permission of the copyright owner. Such illegal software is offered over online sources such as online advertisements newsgroups bulletin board service and auction sites. Piracy hampers creativity, hinders the development of new software and local software industry and ultimately effects e-commerce. A piracy harms consumers and has negative impact on local and national economy. Consumers run the risk of viruses and having corrupted and defective programs.

    Judicial Approach In Dealing With Infringement of Copyright And Software Piracy

    The Indian Copyright Act is unable to protect the unauthorized distribution and use of work over internet. Infringement over internet and piracy posing a threat to creative works worldwide and thus the growth of the internet, the e-commerce and the digital economy.[5] Copyright owners exclusive right of distribution applies to e-mail attached or forwarded.

    In Play Boy Enter Inc v/s Frena [6] Defendant’s subscribers downloaded unauthorized photographs of playboy enterprises to a bulletin board system. US Court held that the plaintiffs exclusive right of distribution was infringed by customers of defendant. This creates an obligation on the bulletin board operators to ensure that its system is not being used to display and download copyrighted materials by its customers.

    In Feist publication v/s Rural Telephone Service Co. Inc. It was held that there must be at least some minimal degree of creativity and what should be protected by copyright were the fruits of intellectual labour and not just sweat of the brow.

    In India databases are protected as literary works. In US if author is creative in selecting and arranging the data and does not merely display the data as facts will be registered. In UK a database which lacks creative input and requires only modest skill and labour acquire the right of unfair extraction for a period of 15 years only. While data created by full creativity copyright protection is given i.e. life of author plus 70 years. Compilation of data are themselves not protectable can be the subject of protection when there is the necessary selection coordination and arrangement and combined it with the abstraction, filtration and comparison test.

    Through internet the work of authors can be displayed in different jurisdictions and which is very difficult to detect. So the display rights can be easily violated over Internet. Software can be easily communicated to the public without authorisation by downloading the software from computer and unauthorized copies made may be retailed or rented out.

    In Michael v/s Internet - Group Inc.[7] Court held that it is violation of copyright owners exclusive statutory right of display by making available videotape over the internet without authorization and posting unauthorized copies of electronic clipart on web pages.

    If a web designer creates a website by combining some special features of various web sites. This may amount to unauthorized adaptation of the plaintiff software and violation of plaintiff's copyright. In digital media one can make about infinite number of copies without loss of quality. So the transferring data from one computer to another violate the reproduction rights of authors. Unauthorsied reproduction or "scanning" a copy righted printed document into a digital file, and uploading, downloading copyrighted file to a bulletin board system is copyright infringement [8]

    In MAl System Corp, v. Is Peak Computers Inc, it was held that the temporary copies made into a computer RAM are copies. But in year 1995 in Religious Technology v/a Netcom[9] US District court held that temporary copying involved in browsing is the functional equivalent of reading and does not implicate the copy right laws. So as regards browsing one must come to the conclusion that it does not amount to violation and can deceived to be a fair dealing.

    Encryption Technology And Network Security

    Through the use of sophisticated cryptography, digital signature is created. The International Standards Organisation defines the concepts of a digital signature as data appended to or a cryptographic transformation of a data unit that allows a recipient of the data unit to prove the source and integrity of the data unit and protect against forgery. Encryption may provide a guarantee that the message has not been altered subsequent to its transmission but can not of itself provide conclusive evidence that it did originate from the alleged senders. One method of overcoming this difficulty is to invoke a third party. This notion of third party intervention has become an important element in governmental attempts to regulate the use of cryptography. One of the major areas identified for the use of cryptography is in the field of e-commerce.

    Complex issues of security, privacy, authentication and anonymity have been thrust to the forefront as confidential information increasingly traverses modem networks. Confidence, reliability and protection of this information against security threats are a crucial prerequisite for the functioning of e-commerce. A security threat is defined as a. crucial condition or event with the potential to cause economic hardship to data or network resources in the form of destruction, disclosure modification of data, software piracy, and denial of service, fraud, and abuse.

    As per the amendment made by IT Act 2000 in sec 65B of the Indian Evidence Act 1872, the electronic records can be produced as documentary evidence before the court of law. Access to computer databases and an analysis of "image copy" provide reliable evidence.

    Unauthorized Modification of Data and Computer Virus

    Perhaps the most notorious form of conduct in the computer field consists of dissemination of computer viruses. In many instances, the effect of a virus will be distinguishable from that of a logic bomb. The difference between the two concepts is that whilst a logic bomb is normally created is applied to a particular computer system, a virus will typically transferred from one system to another. This may occur through the transfer of disks of other storage devices.

    Computer viruses can take a wide variety of forms. One of the less harmful examples of the species is the ‘Cookie Monster’. Inspired by an American television character, this causes message ‘I want a cookie’ to appear on the computer screen. If the user types the word ‘cookie’, the message disappears, otherwise it returns with increasing frequency. In similar vein, the ping pong’ virus causes the image of bouncing ball to cross and record the screen. In neither instance are any data or programs affected.

    Other viruses are considerably more malign. One which is reported to have infected computers in a Maltese Bank had the effect of corrupting data. Evidencing a somewhat sense of humour or the part of its creator, the virus gave the user the opportunity to play what was effectively a game of chance. If the user won, the data would be restored otherwise it would be permanently erased.

    In other cases, not even this degree of opportunity is given to the user to avoid permanent loss of his data. One of the most notorious examples of a computer virus was the so called ‘AIDS’ virus. This was contained on a disk, which was mailed to subscribers of a popular computing magazine. Purporting to be an information program on the AIDS virus, the programme would corrupt and render useless the data on any computer on which it was loaded.[10]

    Trojan Horse:

    A deceptive program that steals passwords.


    Gains entry through access points for system maintenance.


    Tie up network computers by sending them tons of bogus enquiries.

    Data Didding:

    A fraud that input involves input manipulation.

    Salami Technique-

    Thin slices of information are removed and send to other accounts.

    BSA, NASSCOM, NITSC and Security Policy

    BSA (Business Software Alliance) recommended to put under US 301 list to those countries which lack rules to preserve and protect intellectual property right and who failed to follow vigorous enforcement action against software theft.

    In a recent survey by the computer society of India reveals that almost one out of every two InfoTech companies in India has had its network broken into by hackers. And there out of every four companies acknowledge that there was some financial loss involve in such an attack, which attract two companies claiming that they lost $500 000 per instruction [16]

    Robert Hollyman, chief executive of the Washington based BSA has estimated that the loss to the software developers on account of software piracy may be upto $1 billion a year. Through monitoring BSA has detected as many as 95,000 websites which offer pirated software called “Warez” by hackers.
    In India, the National Association of software and Service Companies (NASSCOM) has proposed the setting up of a National Cybercrop Committee to provide helping hand to government and private agencies to combat against cyber hacking.

    Hacking is an endless game. Whenever a new security device is announced, hackers take intellectual pleasure by cracking it. Six major security technologies that are connected to global net are: Firewalls, Anti-virus software, security scanner, internet protocol security (IPSE), Public key infrastructure (PKI). Among all these security technologies PKI is the principal tool to establish a trusted path for electronic transactions. PKI protects against assaults like disclosure of sensitive information, data alteration etc. The most protective technique is the use of “public key” and “private key”. With the help of these security on the Net, hoping to generate confidence in customers. So that the internet becomes a secure medium.[17]

    The ministry of information and technology has setup a National information technology security centre (NITSC) as a part of a multi-pronged approach to control crime.

    Top sources in the IT ministry revealed that the move was initiated following intruder attacks in many high profile organization web sites in India. For instance the web defacement of Bhabha Atomic Research Centre, the theft of telephone numbers related information from the system of the chief manager, department of Telecom in Hyderabad by a hacker of Australian origin and the more recently, the web page defacement of the department of electronics by a Pakistani hacker.
    The primary objective of this centre is to create awareness among the Indian IT community for IT security and related threats. It is also providing all relevant information and practical advice to help corporate sector to eliminate or mitigate security threats and make their systems secure.

    Functioning under the R&D wing of CMC Ltd, the centre disseminates information software tools and issue virus alerts through a web site. Provides newsletters, advisories and booklets. It also offers consultancy services through security audits and training course. One such training course for managers and technical staff is started recently. As e-commerce takes off and transactions go online all care has to be taken. Slipping of Microsoft's Bill Gates credit card information into the hands of cyber criminals reveals that cyber security is a greatest challenge before us. Day by day budget of cyber security is going high. As per the recent survey most of the companies dealing with e-commerce are wasting more than 15% of their budget on network security.


    With the arrival of digital technology, multimedia and internet copyright infringement and software piracy become very easy. Due to weak network security and hacking the problems becomes more grim and posing threat to e-commerce. US market is growing @ 20% annually. India is growing with CAGR of 59% over the last ten years. Mc Kinsey estimates that by 2010 the global market will expand to S200 billion and India is slated to be a major player in cyber space.
    E-commerce focuses its elements on telephone computer and websites as a basis of deciding competitiveness of a country. India performs badly on these fronts. To be a superpower in the present century it must take lead in all relevant areas.

    Indian Government has taken a remarkable step ahead in right direction by enforcing the Information Technology Amendment Act 2008, on 27th October 2009, but which does not mention a single word about copyright. While the copy right is one of the most complicated areas of cyber law, .Jurisdiction, cybersquatting , trademark, patent, domain name, media convergence, taxation, payment issues are also not covered by the said Amendment Act. While these are essential for the growth of e-commerce.

    Moreover internet, e-commerce and copyright related cases are only being instituted in the western countries, to be more precise USA. But it seems that the Indian courts might see and influx of internet related cases in the near future. Therefore we should prepare our legal institutions for the production of information superhighway gateway. India has to go a long way to realise the true potential of information technology for conducting e-commerce. A lot depend upon the policy of the government to built necessary infrastructure, but it can surely be said that e-commerce is the way of a better future.

    [2] The Term Internet is defined as a set of computer network –possibly dissimilar joined together by means of gateways that handle data transfer and the conversion of messages from sending network to the protocols used by receiving networks. See. Microsoft computer press dictionary 200. (2nd 1994)
    [3] Deepak Printings v/s Forward Stationary mart (1981) PTC 186 at P 189
    [4] Mac Milan v/s Cooper (1923) 93 LJPC 113 and 117
    [6] 839 F. Supp. 1552 (M D Fla 1993)
    [7] F. Supp. 2d C.D. Lal 1988
    [8] Tabrez Ahmad: Cybcrlaw e-commerce & m-commerce, APH Publishing Corp. New Delhi, 2003.
    [9] 907 F. Supp. 1361 (N.D Cal 1995)
    [10] Business Today March 21, 2001 p.35
    [11] Ibid
    [12] Ibid
    [13] Ibid
    [14] Ibid
    [15] Ibid
    [16] Ibid
    [17] Civil Services Chronicle April 2000 p. 67

    About the author:
    Associate Professor of Law, KIIT Law School, KIIT Univeristy. A science graduate, Dr. Tabrez Ahmad has been awarded Ph.D. in Cyber Law from Aligarh Muslim University. The SAARC Level Training Programme on Fact Based Teaching and Legal Research organized by United States Education Foundations of India are to his credit. He also practiced Law at the Bar of the High Court at Delhi and Supreme Court of India. He has the experience of teaching in many educational institutions of national repute. He has been the founding faculty of the National University of Juridical Sciences (NUJS), Kolkata and founder Director of the Durgapur Institute of Legal Studies (DILS). As an eminent researcher, he has participated in various national/international seminars and conferences (including International Conference on Intellectual Property Law organized by George Washington University Law School, USA and CII, SPCI08 an International conference of Cyberlaw organised by USA,France, Russia and Egypt, he was invited to deliver lecture in the International Conference of Cyber crimes ISSCRIM 2009 BRAZIL) and also worked on World Bank and UNDP sponsored projects. In addition to his numerous research articles, he authored a pioneering book on mobile commerce laws entitled "Cyber Law, E-commerce and M-commerce".

    The author can be reached at: [email protected] / Print This Article

    How To Submit Your Article:

    Follow the Procedure Below To Submit Your Articles

    Submit your Article by using our online form Click here
    Note* we only accept Original Articles, we will not accept Articles Already Published in other websites.
    For Further Details Contact: [email protected]

    Divorce by Mutual Consent in Delhi/NCR

    Mutual DivorceRight Away Call us at Ph no: 9650499965

    File Your Copyright - Right Now!

    Copyright Registration
    Online Copyright Registration in India
    Call us at: 9891244487 / or email at: [email protected]