Divorce by mutual consent
decree per se in matrimonial matter is not collusive. As would be evident from
the legislative intent of s. 13B of the Act divorce by mutual consent is no
longer foreign to Indian law of divorce.
In an appeal against the dismissal of a petition for divorce under s. 13 of the
Act a compromise petition signed by the parties and their respective lawyers was
filed praying for dissolution of marriage by mutual consent. It was held that s.
13B(2) of the Act is directory only. Section 13B(2) no doubt cautions the court
of its duty to fight the last ditch battle to save the marriage, but when the
court is fully satisfied on the basis of the proved facts that in the interests
of justice of the society and the individuals marriage tie should be put as
under immediately, s. 13B(2) does not impose any fetter on the powers of the
court to grant decree of divorce. The time-table fixed by s. 13B(2) does not
apply to an appellate court.
Where the ingredients necessary for a decree of mutual divorce under s. 13B are
proved by the evidence of the parties, the court cannot refuse a decree for
divorce. The ingredients are that they had been living separately for a period
of more than one year and that they had not been able to live together and that
they had mutually agreed that the marriage should be dissolved.19 Section 13B(l)
does not envisage the recording of the statements of the parties at the time, of
filing of the joint petition and merely because their statements were not so
recorded, they could not have been denied the relief of divorce.20 There is a
fourth ingredient for a decree of divorce by mutual consent, that i the consent
of the parties has been obtained not by force, fraud or undue influence.-I A
compromise decree can be recorded and divorce may be granted under Or. 22, r. ,
CPC provided the court is satisfied that a ground for divorce specified in the
statute can be spelt out from the records.
The parties in a case2 had signed a memorandum of compromise stating that th~
husband would pay certain amount to the wife in two installments by Demand Dra
and the decree for divorce by mutual consent would take effect after payment of
~ second installment. It has been held that the decree for dissolution of
marriage solemnized between the parties has to be passed in terms of the
memorandum of compromise filed in the court.
Divorce by mutual consent
to the provisions of this Act petition for dissolution of marriage by a decree
of divorce may be presented :0 the district court by both the parties to a
marriage together, whether such marriage was solemnized before or after the
commencement of the Marriage Laws: (Amendment) Act, 1976, on the ground that
they have been living separately for: a period of one year or more, that they
have not been able to live together. that they have mutually agreed that the
marriage should be dissolved.
(2) On the motion of both the parties made not earlier than six months after the
date of the presentation of the petition referred to in sub-section (1) and not
later than eighteen months after the said date, if the petition is not withdrawn
in the meantime, the court shall, on being satisfied, after hearing the parties
and after making such inquiry as it thinks fit, that a marriage has been
solemnized and that the averments in the petition are true, pass a decree of
divorce declaring the marriage to be dissolved with effect from the date of the
Corresponding law. Sections 13A and 13B of the Act correspond to ss.
27A and 28 of the Special Marriage Act 1954, respectively.
Insertion of sections 13A and 138. Sections 13A and 13B were inserted
by the Marriage Laws (Amendment) Act 1976. Section 13A provides that under
certain circumstances the court may, while dealing with a petition for divorce,
have a discretion to grant a decree for judicial separation instead. Under s.
13B of the Act divorce by mutual consent has now received statutory blessing.
Scope of section 13A. Under s. 13A the court can grant a decree for
judicial separation though the petitioner asked for a decree of divorce.9 This
is an alternative relief as provided in s. 13A of the Act. Section 13A commences
with the words "alternative relief in divorce proceedings" and provides power to
the court in a petition for divorce, if it considers just so to do, taking into
consideration the circumstances of the case, to pass a decree for judicial
separation. It is only when the ground on which divorce is sought is made out,
then the court in the circumstances of the case may grant judicial separation.
Scope of section 13B. In a petition under s. 13B of the Act the
parties are not required to prove anything in addition to that laid down in the
section itself.!! During pendency of appeal in divorce proceedings, the parties
may agree to dissolve the marriage by mutual consent or compromise provided it
is neither unlawful nor the result of collusion. It is now possible to dissolve
a marriage by agreement between the parties although none of the grounds on
which a marriage may be dissolved by a court is found to exist.!2 Even a
petition by one party may be converted into a fresh petition for dissolution of
marriage by mutual consent.13 Where a divorce is granted without following the
procedure laid down in s. 13B of the Act, the order is invalid.
Parties merely agreed orally at the time of arguments that they had mutually
agreed that their marriage should be dissolved by mutual consent. The petition
filed under s. 13(1)(ia) and (ib) cannot be treated to have been filed under s.
13B and the decree for divorce by mutual consent cannot be passed in such a
situation. Further it is also a mandatory provision under s. 23(1)(bb) of the
Act to satisfy the court that consent has not been obtained by force, fraud or
In Preeti Singh v Sandeep Singh the divorce between
the parties was granted by mutual consent according to the directions of the