Where Does India Stand on Same-Sex Marriage?
Where does India stand on same-sex marriage? After Section 377 was struck down (2018), many hoped same-sex marriage would follow. In October 2023, Supreme Court delivered a split decision – not legalizing same-sex marriage but acknowledging the need for rights. Let’s understand the complete legal landscape for LGBTQ+ couples in India.
Current Legal Status (2025)
| Issue | Status |
|---|---|
| Same-sex marriage | NOT legal in India |
| Developments | Important developments and partial recognition |
Timeline of LGBTQ+ Rights in India
- 2009: Delhi High Court decriminalizes homosexuality (Section 377)
- 2013: Supreme Court overturns, re-criminalizes
- 2014: NALSA judgment – Recognizes transgender as third gender, fundamental rights
- 2017: Right to Privacy judgment – Includes sexual orientation
- 2018: Section 377 partially struck down – Consensual homosexual sex decriminalized (Navtej Johar case)
- 2023: Same-sex marriage petitions – Supreme Court refuses to legalize, asks Parliament to decide
- 2025: Ongoing advocacy, some state-level initiatives
Section 377 Decriminalization (2018)
What Changed
- Consensual homosexual sex between adults decriminalized
- No longer a criminal offense to be gay/lesbian
- Historic moment for LGBTQ+ community
What Remains
- Non-consensual sex still criminalized (as it should be)
- Age of consent laws apply equally
Impact
- LGBTQ+ individuals can live openly without fear of arrest
- But no marriage or family rights yet
Same-Sex Marriage Petitions (2023)
What Happened
Petitions filed: By multiple LGBTQ+ couples and activists seeking:
- Legal recognition of same-sex marriage
- Equal rights under marriage laws
- Adoption rights
- Inheritance, succession rights
Arguments in Favor
- Equality before law (Article 14)
- Right to life and liberty (Article 21) includes right to marry partner of choice
- Dignity and autonomy
- Love is love, gender shouldn’t matter
Arguments Against (By Government)
- Marriage is between man and woman (traditional/religious view)
- Parliament should decide, not court
- Potential social disruption
- Personal laws don’t allow
Supreme Court Verdict (October 2023)
5-judge bench, 3:2 split:
Majority Opinion
- Cannot legalize same-sex marriage
- This is for Parliament to decide, not judiciary
- But: Discrimination against LGBTQ+ must end
- Right to choose partner is fundamental
Dissenting Opinion (2 Judges)
- Should legalize civil unions
- Adoption rights should be granted
- Can’t wait for Parliament indefinitely
What the Judgment DID
- Recognized queer couples’ right to cohabit
- Directed government to ensure no discrimination
- Set up committee to examine rights (without marriage)
- Acknowledged LGBTQ+ families exist and deserve protection
What It DIDN’T Do
- Legalize same-sex marriage
- Grant adoption rights
- Change personal laws
Result: Status quo continues, marriage not legal
Current Rights of LGBTQ+ Couples
What You CAN Do
- ✓ Live together – Cohabitation is legal
- ✓ Have consensual relationship – No criminal liability
- ✓ Joint bank accounts – As friends/partners
- ✓ Nominate partner – In insurance, PF, bank accounts
- ✓ Make will – Leave property to partner
- ✓ Power of attorney – For medical/financial decisions
- ✓ Rent/buy property together – As co-owners or joint tenants
- ✓ Work without discrimination – Employment equality (though not always enforced)
What You CANNOT Do
- ❌ Legally marry – No marriage certificate
- ❌ Adopt as couple – Adoption laws don’t recognize same-sex couples
- ❌ Automatic inheritance – Not “legal heirs” of each other
- ❌ Spousal visa – For immigration
- ❌ Tax benefits – That married couples get
- ❌ Medical decisions – Not automatic “next of kin”
- ❌ Rent control/succession – Tenancy doesn’t automatically transfer
- ❌ Insurance – Can’t be “spouse” in health insurance
Legal Workarounds (Until Marriage Legalized)
1. Cohabitation Agreement
What: Legal contract between partners
- Acknowledgment of relationship
- Financial arrangements (expenses, assets)
- Property ownership
- Responsibilities
- Separation terms
Notarize and register (provides some legal standing)
Not equivalent to marriage but better than nothing
2. Will/Testament
Crucial!
| Without Will | With Will |
|---|---|
| Partner gets NOTHING (not legal heir) | Leave all/part of property to partner Register will (better protection) Clearly state relationship |
Caution: Family may challenge will after your death
3. Nomination
In all accounts:
- Bank accounts – Nominate partner
- EPF/PPF – Nominate partner
- Insurance – Partner as beneficiary
- Shares/mutual funds – Nomination
Legal but: Family can still claim after death (complex)
4. Joint Ownership
Property:
- Buy house/flat jointly
- Both names on title
- Survivor rights (depends on type of ownership)
Bank accounts:
- Joint account with either-or-survivor clause
5. Power of Attorney
For medical decisions:
- Durable power of attorney
- Partner can make medical decisions if you’re incapacitated
- Otherwise, family decides (may exclude partner)
For financial:
- Partner can handle finances if needed
6. Adoption (Single Parent)
Currently:
- Single persons can adopt (regardless of sexual orientation)
- LGBTQ+ individual can adopt as single parent
- But not as couple
Process:
- Through CARA (Central Adoption Resource Authority)
- Same process as heterosexual single parent
- Don’t need to hide sexual orientation (post-Section 377)
International Comparison
| Region | Status |
|---|---|
| Countries with same-sex marriage legal | 30+ countries (as of 2025) including USA, Canada, UK, most of Europe, Australia, New Zealand, Taiwan, Thailand (2024) |
| Asia | Taiwan: First in Asia (2019) Thailand: Legalized 2024 Nepal: Court ordered (not yet implemented) India: Still waiting |
Global trend: Increasing legalization
Civil Unions/Domestic Partnerships
Alternative to marriage:
- Registered partnerships
- Civil unions
- Provides most marriage rights without calling it “marriage”
India:
- Supreme Court suggested government consider this
- Not yet implemented
- Ongoing discussions
If implemented, could provide:
- Legal recognition
- Inheritance rights
- Medical decision rights
- Tax benefits
- Visa rights
- Without changing “marriage” definition
Adoption Rights
Current law:
- Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act: Only married couples (man and woman) or single persons
- Juvenile Justice Act (CARA): Single persons can adopt
- Single LGBTQ+ person: Can adopt
- LGBTQ+ couple: Cannot adopt together (not recognized as couple)
Workaround:
- One partner adopts as single parent
- Other has no legal rights to child (problematic)
Workplace Rights
Currently: No specific LGBTQ+ anti-discrimination law
- Constitution’s Article 15/16 prohibits discrimination
- Navtej Johar judgment affirmed workplace equality
- Some companies have inclusive policies
In practice:
- Varies widely
- MNCs generally better
- Small companies/traditional sectors may discriminate
Legal recourse available but underutilized
Healthcare
Rights:
- Cannot be denied healthcare due to sexual orientation
- Medical confidentiality applies
- Partner can accompany (but not automatically “next of kin”)
Challenges:
- Some doctors discriminatory
- Insurance doesn’t cover partner as “spouse”
- Medical decision-making if incapacitated (power of attorney crucial)
Discrimination & Legal Recourse
If discriminated (employment, housing, services):
- File complaint with:
- Police (if criminal offense)
- State Human Rights Commission
- National Human Rights Commission
- Appropriate forum (labor court, consumer forum, etc.)
- Grounds: Violation of Article 14, 15, 21
But: No specific LGBTQ+ anti-discrimination law makes it harder
Trans Rights (Separate Legal Framework)
Transgender Persons Act, 2019:
- Provides:
- Self-identification as male, female, or transgender
- Certificate of identity
- Anti-discrimination provisions
- Reservation in education, employment
- National Council for Transgender Persons
Issues:
- Implementation weak
- Discrimination continues
- Medical procedures for transition expensive, not covered
Marriage:
- After transition, can marry as per new gender identity
- If transitioned to female, can marry man (and vice versa)
- But same-sex marriage still not legal
Religious Perspectives
| Religion | Perspective |
|---|---|
| Hinduism | No clear prohibition (some texts accepting, others not) |
| Islam | Generally prohibits homosexuality |
| Christianity | Varies by denomination (some accepting, many prohibit) |
| Buddhism, Jainism | Generally more accepting |
| Sikhism | No clear stance |
Personal laws based on religion: Major obstacle to uniform civil marriage
Scenarios
- 1. Parliament Legalizes
- New law passed
- Amends Special Marriage Act or creates new law
- Most democratic route
- But: Political will needed (currently lacking)
- 2. Supreme Court Review
- Fresh petitions
- Larger bench
- Could overturn 2023 judgment
- But: Court hesitant to bypass Parliament
- 3. Civil Unions
- Government creates separate framework
- Not “marriage” but similar rights
- Compromise solution
- Possible in next 2-5 years
- 4. State-Level Initiatives
- Some states considering LGBTQ+ welfare boards
- Not marriage but some protections
- Kerala, Tamil Nadu ahead in LGBTQ+ rights
- 5. Status Quo
- No change for years
- Community continues fighting
- Piecemeal gains
Realistic Timeline
5-10 years for legalization (optimistic estimate)
Advocacy and Support
Organizations Working on LGBTQ+ Rights
- Humsafar Trust
- Naz Foundation
- Lawyers Collective
- Alternative Law Forum
- Sangama
- Many state-level groups
Helplines
- It Gets Better India
- LGBTQ helplines in major cities
- Mental health support
Advice for LGBTQ+ Couples
Legal Protection (Do Now)
| Action | Notes |
|---|---|
| ✓ Cohabitation agreement | Get lawyer to draft |
| ✓ Wills | Both partners should have one |
| ✓ Nominations | In all accounts |
| ✓ Power of attorney | Medical and financial |
| ✓ Joint ownership | Property, accounts |
| ✓ Document relationship | Photos, evidence (for any future legal need) |
| ✓ Support network | Legal, community, friends |
| ✓ Stay informed | Laws evolving |
Financial Planning
- Can’t file joint tax returns
- Plan separately
- Consider financial interdependence
Family
- Come out if safe
- If not, protect yourself legally despite family
International Options
If Seeking Marriage
- Marry abroad
- Countries where it’s legal (UK, USA, Canada, etc.)
- Get married there
- But: Not recognized in India
- No legal benefits in India
Immigration
- Partner visa not available for Indian couples
- If one partner is foreign national, complicated
Conclusion
Same-sex marriage in India remains a work in progress. While Section 377 decriminalization was historic, full equality – including marriage – is still distant.
Current Reality
- Relationships legal, marriage not
- Must use legal workarounds
- Continued advocacy needed
Hope
- Global trend toward legalization
- Increasing social acceptance
- Legal community supportive
- Change is coming, even if slow
For LGBTQ+ Indians: You deserve equal rights. While we wait for law to catch up, protect yourself legally and keep fighting for equality!
Love is love. The law will eventually recognize it.


