The Commissions of Inquiry Act, 1952
The Commissions of Inquiry Act, 1952 allows the Central Government and State Governments to set up special bodies called Commissions of Inquiry. These commissions investigate serious matters of public importance such as major accidents, corruption, administrative failures, riots, or widespread public complaints.
Main Purpose of the Act
Main purpose: To find out the truth, identify what went wrong, and suggest steps to prevent similar problems in the future. The Act helps promote transparency, accountability, and better governance.
The Act came into force on 1 October 1952 and applies to the whole of India.
Key Definitions Under Section 2
Section 2 of the Commissions of Inquiry Act, 1952 defines important terms used throughout the legislation.
- Appropriate Government: The Central Government or a State Government, depending on which government has the constitutional power over the subject under inquiry.
- Commission: A Commission of Inquiry set up under Section 3 of this Act.
- Prescribed: Rules made by the government under this Act.
Appointment of a Commission Under Section 3
The Appropriate Government can appoint a Commission to inquire into any definite matter of public importance.
The following provisions govern the appointment and functioning of a Commission:
- Both the Central and State Governments can appoint commissions on subjects within their own powers. Two or more State Governments can also form a joint commission.
- If Parliament or a State Legislature passes a resolution demanding an inquiry, the government must appoint a Commission.
- A Commission can have one or more members who are qualified and experienced.
- The government must clearly state the exact issues to be examined and fix a time limit for submitting the final report.
- After the report is submitted, the government must place it before Parliament or the State Legislature (along with a note on the action taken) within six months (Section 3(4)).
Powers and Assistance of a Commission
Powers of a Civil Court Under Section 4
A Commission has the same powers as a civil court to collect evidence. It can:
- Summon any person from anywhere in India and examine them on oath.
- Call for relevant documents and records.
- Accept evidence through written affidavits.
- Ask for public records from any court or government office.
- Issue commissions to examine witnesses or documents in other places.
- Exercise any other powers given by the government.
Additional Powers Under Section 5
The government can give extra powers through a notification. These may include:
- Forcing a person to share relevant information.
- Entering premises to inspect and seize relevant documents or accounts.
- Taking action if certain offences are committed in the presence of the Commission.
- Treating the proceedings as judicial proceedings for certain legal purposes.
Help from Investigation Agencies Under Section 5A
A Commission can take help from government officers or investigating agencies (such as the police) to collect information and submit reports. However, the Commission must independently check the facts and conclusions.
Appointment of Experts and Assessors Under Section 5B
The Commission can appoint experts (called assessors) in law, finance, science, technology, or other fields to help it understand complex issues.
Protections and Safeguards for Witnesses
The Act provides certain safeguards to protect witnesses who participate in inquiry proceedings.
Protection of Witness Statements Under Section 6
Anything a person says while giving evidence before the Commission cannot be used against them in any later civil or criminal case. This protection does not apply if the person is prosecuted for giving false evidence.
Protection of Trade Secrets Under Section 6A
A witness cannot normally be forced to reveal a secret manufacturing process, unless the Commission was specifically set up to inquire into that process.
Procedure and Rights During the Inquiry
The Commissions of Inquiry Act, 1952 also establishes rules governing inquiry proceedings and protects the rights of persons affected by an investigation.
Ending a Commission Under Section 7
The government can close a Commission by notification when its work is no longer needed. However, if the Commission was set up because of a resolution of Parliament or a State Legislature, it can be closed only after that legislature passes another resolution approving the closure.
Inquiry Procedure Under Section 8
The Commission decides its own procedure, place of sittings, and whether hearings will be public or private (within the rules of the Act).
No Restart on Change of Members Under Section 8A
If the Chairman or a member is absent, resigns, or is replaced, the inquiry continues from where it left off. It does not start again.
Right to Be Heard Under Section 8B
If the inquiry may affect a person’s reputation or examines their conduct, the Commission must give that person a fair chance to explain their side and present evidence (principles of natural justice).
Right to a Lawyer and Cross-Examination Under Section 8C
The government and any person whose reputation is at risk have the right to engage a lawyer, present arguments, and cross-examine witnesses. Other persons may also be allowed these rights with the Commission’s permission.
Legal Status, Offences, and Rules
The Act also provides legal protections, defines the status of Commission members, and establishes penalties for certain acts.
Protection for Honest Actions Under Section 9
No legal action can be taken against the government, the Commission, its members, or staff for anything done in good faith under this Act.
Status as Public Servants Under Section 10
Members of the Commission and authorised officers are treated as public servants.
Penalty for Insulting the Commission Under Section 10A
Anyone who deliberately publishes statements or acts in a way that lowers the reputation of the Commission or its members can face up to 6 months’ simple imprisonment, a fine, or both. Only a High Court can try this offence, and the complaint must be filed within six months.
Extending the Act to Other Bodies Under Section 11
The government can extend the powers of this Act to other existing inquiry committees by publishing a notification in the Official Gazette.
Power to Make Rules Under Section 12
The government can make detailed rules on the terms of members, procedure, powers, and allowances for witnesses and experts. These rules must be placed before Parliament or the State Legislature.
Key Supreme Court Judgments on the Commissions of Inquiry Act
The Supreme Court of India has clarified the nature, powers, and legal significance of Commissions of Inquiry through several important judgments.
1. Ram Krishna Dalmia v. Justice S.R. Tendolkar (1958)
A Commission of Inquiry is only a fact-finding body, not a court. Its report is advisory and cannot pass enforceable orders.
2. State of Karnataka v. Union of India (1977)
A Commission has an investigative role without judicial power. Its findings are not legally binding like a court judgment.
3. T. Antony v. State of Kerala (2001)
Civil and criminal courts are not bound by a Commission’s findings. Courts must decide cases independently on the basis of evidence before them.
4. Ghanshyam Upadhyay v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2020)
A Commission’s recommendations cannot be enforced on their own. Their main purpose is to inform the government.
Importance and Limitations of the Commissions of Inquiry Act
The Act plays an important role in investigating matters of public importance. However, Commissions of Inquiry also have certain limitations.
| Importance (Why It Matters) | Limitations (Where It Falls Short) |
|---|---|
| Thoroughly investigates major public crises and scandals. | Cannot punish anyone or pass a conviction. |
| Brings hidden facts before the government and the public. | Findings are not binding; government is not forced to accept them. |
| Identifies administrative failures and abuse of power. | Inquiries often take a long time to complete. |
| Gives affected persons a fair chance to defend themselves. | Depends on cooperation from witnesses and officials. |
| Helps the government improve systems and prevent future failures. | Implementation of recommendations depends on political will. |
Conclusion
The Commissions of Inquiry Act, 1952 is an important tool for finding the truth behind matters of public concern. A Commission is not a criminal court — its report cannot establish criminal guilt or replace a regular trial.
Still, its investigations help the government fix accountability, improve administration, and prevent future failures. In this way, the Act supports transparency and good governance.

